Newbie 1971 [Game Over!]

[Menalque]

I feel like kanna does the sort of thing where she reads as super newbie but I’m not sure if it’s newbtown or newbscum

[Menalque]

And I feel like that specific paranoia about whether she was being SR is more likely from newbscum? But not sure

[Menalque]

What do you think of gbj independently at this point?

[skitter30]

I'm not sure why you're leaning to scum more than town?

She has a fairly good thought process, that makes sense, which i can follow. I can understand why she's making certain questions, and where her inquiries are coming from. That looks more like town to me

[skitter30]

What do you think of gbj independently at this point?

Literally null, has like no content. No idea if that's typical of him or not

[Menalque]

Have you read his other newbie?

[Menalque]

Even in ISO?

[Menalque]

I'm not sure why you're leaning to scum more than town?

She has a fairly good thought process, that makes sense, which i can follow. I can understand why she's making certain questions, and where her inquiries are coming from. That looks more like town to me

Okay, I’ll reread her again

[skitter30]

I feel like non is capable of ~real thought~ so the shitposting is alarming

[skitter30]

Even in ISO?

Nope. I'll try if i can, but no promises, i'm a little busy over the next couple of days

[Menalque]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go

[skitter30]

hey im finally online

billy: seems town
guilty: town
kanna: town
mapwolf:town
skitter: null
uncrowned: mixed
mena: mixed
non imh: scum

:squint:

What's up with the mapwold tr?
What does 'mixed' mean?

[skitter30]

Let me catch up first

[skitter30]

I was kind of considering that, but I didn't do it as I feel it'd be easier to lynch him on d2 or d3 if he was scum.

I dont understand.

Why do u think it would be easier to lynch gl later and why does it preclude you from voting him today when yoh suspect him

It doesn't really preclude me from voting him. It's more that I sort of liked to assume that he wasn't scum, even though he clearly could be.

I feel like the billy vote was oppurtunistic

[Menalque]

Okay

I think he reads v diff and much more solvey there whereas here he’s just coasting

[Menalque]

And like asking questions but not doing anything with the answers

[Menalque]

And I think if he’s scum it spews billy scum

[skitter30]

hey im finally online

billy: seems town
guilty: town
kanna: town
mapwolf:town
skitter: null
uncrowned: mixed
mena: mixed
non imh: scum

Like imagine if scumteam is Gbj/Billy. "Seems town" could in theory be a really bad scumslip in that case. Why the "seems" town? Why not just "town" or mixed/null like the other reads on this list? What if this is just "I can't justify townreading this guy, but I still want to try and defend him somehow".

I might be reading too much into this though, but still... This post is just kind of weird if town.

Idk i feel like this would be an incredibly egregious slip if that were exactly the scumteam and i like to imagine that scum would be more careful

[Menalque]

Yeah but newbscum tho?

[skitter30]

And I think if he’s scum it spews billy scum

Because of the unvote and seems town thing?

Unvote would be ridiculously obvious as a scumteam and seems town i dont think means much

[Menalque]

Like that’s exactly the sort of perspective slip I could see from newbscum who knows the person they’re trying to TR is scum

I don’t think either this or the billy unvote would be indicative alone at all

But together it’s enough to make me raise my eyebrows

[skitter30]

Yeah but newbscum tho?

Yeah idk that would be a p bad slip.

I feel like scum are more careful about where they put their partners, tho

[Menalque]

If I didn’t find gbj independently scummy, I wouldn’t be interested in going there

But I do, so I am, and the bonus is that if he does flip scum I think it’s just (gbj, billy)

[skitter30]

Expand on why you think that

1) the speed was insane
2) Mena didn't even explain why GBJ was his highest scumread but 2 people sheeped him
3) This isn't really a point but I don't agree about GBJ and I'll explain later

This is townie, and i kinda agree with her tbh

[Menalque]

Yeah but newbscum tho?

Yeah idk that would be a p bad slip.

I

feel like scum are more careful about where they put their partners, tho

Yeah this is a fair point and my main issue with the connection theory

But equally if billy hasn’t been around to mentor him then I can see it happening

Like with what’s his name in 1949 where he was obvscum and it was because he wasn’t checking the pt enough for you to coach

So it does happen