Guns & Roses III [Game over]

[Menalque]

Explain all of those and respond to the other point in that post about why we shouldn’t massclaim

We won't have a 1v1 if the town gun claims NOW before theres a wagon. Its unlikely scum claims a town gun here and initiates a 1v1? Thats what I think at least. Once we have a cleared, we can re-evaluate based on that new info.

We don't know if the extra kill on N1 was town or scum.
If it was the town gun on N1, we need to know that, because it means the scum are stockpiling guns for later and this could be LYLO or MYLO potentially....

I mean if scum have been weighting guns towards late game then yeah they probably just CC because it’s winning if they can get the actual gun lynched

Regarding the extra N1 kill: unless we full massclaim then it doesn’t really help bc we won’t know if scum shot N1 or N2 roses and missed so we’d still be working in the dark. The only case we’d know they didn’t miss on N1/N2 is if basically everyone claims late game roses (N3+)

Overall I don’t see the advantage of giving scum extra information about rose night distribution vs not doing that?

[Datisi]

S_S, reasons for alimdia TR? I'm kinda forgetting that slot exists honestly, and I almost find it a bit weird you've got a TR on them while you don't remember anything I've done?

wasn't I in ur town list in post 1568? (and 1912)

hm......

yes you were
and then you dissapeared for a while

I never reappeared between 1568(or 1572) and 1912.....

VOTE: Datisi

ok? I don't see the problem in "I've been TRing this slot, and while I still do, the read is growing stale, I'm forgetting it exists, and I find it weird that S_S has a read on it while "forgetting anything I've done" when I've been plenty active"

@datisi well yes but do you have actual reasons or is this just ~*paranoia*~

right now it's just ~paranoia~
i haven't reread anything yet
will get back to ya if I find anything that truly pings me

[Menalque]

I think datisi and GL are still town but I’m not really sure about anyone else

Can I get a readslist from everyone pls

Gonna pop this here as a reminder

[alimdia]

We don't claim what night roses we are obviously...

[alimdia]

S_S, reasons for alimdia TR? I'm kinda forgetting that slot exists honestly, and I almost find it a bit weird you've got a TR on them while you don't remember anything I've done?

wasn't I in ur town list in post 1568? (and 1912)

hm......

yes you were
and then you dissapeared for a while

I never reappeared between 1568(or 1572) and 1912.....

VOTE: Datisi

ok? I don't see the problem in "I've been TRing this slot, and while I still do, the read is growing stale, I'm forgetting it exists, and I find it weird that S_S has a read on it while "forgetting anything I've done" when I've been plenty active"

It's just that you and SS have the same read on me, but you ask him to explain yours while saying yours is stale.
Then a few posts later you make a new read list that has me as TR again.

I'm prob overreacting ig...
UNVOTE:

[Datisi]

gun to head, pending rereads:
{GL, Icon, Mena}
{DW, alimdia}
{Amrun, S_S}
{GE}

[Datisi]

It's just that you and SS have the same read on me, but you ask him to explain yours while saying yours is stale.
Then a few posts later you make a new read list that has me as TR again.

I'm prob overreacting ig...
UNVOTE:

The point of that question wasn't "hey S_S, why do you TR alimdia?"

it was "hey S_S, how come you have a TR on a slot that hasn't been here for a long time while saying that you don't remember anything that

I

have done when I've been plenty active?"

[Menalque]

We don't claim what night roses we are obviously...

Yes but if we don’t then we’re not actually learning anything that useful about whether scum have weighted their guns towards later nights making your second point worthless and again, so long as scum haven’t got their guns weighted towards later then pre-emptively having the gun claim is just giving them additional information earlier than we need to given that the gun can just claim at L-1 if necessary

[Menalque]

Alim I want a readslist from u

[Menalque]

ty dats

[alimdia]

I gave readlist already.

But now I adjusted it cos I reread what the context after Datisi explained and its correct.

Scum reads:
Dogwatch
SS
Gamma Emerald
GuiltyLion

[Menalque]

What about your TRs

Is that your SRs in order?

[Something_Smart]

Where have all the scum kills gone?
As our city's roses get pulverized
We've mislynched several townies, though
It seems we still aren't in LYLO
So stop dicking around and solve this game, ooh

[alimdia]

Also is anyone else gonna remention that fact that SS was sheeping Creature - a dead person?

[Something_Smart]

Alimdia's tunnel on me was hella genuine, it being a long time ago doesn't change that.

[Datisi]

what song is that

because I'm trying to read that to the tune of Holding Out for a Hero and I don't think that's it

[Something_Smart]

Letterbomb by Green Day.

[alimdia]

What about your TRs

Is that your SRs in order?

idk about Icon.
I think at least point, Amrun being an informative lynch is no longer, just because of SS


Fuck I have too many scumreads lmao

[alimdia]

S_S, what's on your mind? Any reads?

GL town, Menalque town, Iconeum town, alimdia town

DogWatch said something I didn't like a while back

Nvm that DogWatch bit I think 1719 is towny

Where have all the scum kills gone?
As our city's roses get pulverized
We've mislynched several townies, though
It seems we still aren't in LYLO
So stop dicking around and solve this game, ooh

Lit your only scumread is Amrun... Whos tunneling now?

[alimdia]

What about your TRs

Is that your SRs in order?

idk about Icon.
I think at least point, Amrun being an informative lynch is no longer, just because of SS


Fuck I have too many scumreads lmao

forgot to answer the last part.
GL is the lowest SR, DW and SS are on the same highest level and GA slot is literally because they haven't said stuff

[Something_Smart]

...do you know what a tunnel is?

[Menalque]

Letterbomb

by Green Day

.

I didn’t know you were an RC alt

[Menalque]

SS what’s your current readslist?

[Something_Smart]

Err

{Menalque}
{GuiltyLion, Iconeum}
{alimdia}
{DogWatch}
{Gamma Emerald}
{Amrun, Datisi}

I feel like that's more precise than it has any right to be though.

Also I just recalled that I've hard misread scumconeum multiple times so maybe he doesn't deserve to be where he is but then again none of those tiers are particularly confident anyway.

[Menalque]

Why is datisi so low and when did I get so high?