Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Bingle]

That argument does nothing for me. Do something town if you want to live.

Do something town even if you don't want to live. There's a boatload of analysis in the thread, but not a lot of feels reads and you're a decent feels-reads-player. I promise to come back to your reads if you flip town and I'm not likely to be going anywhere any time soon.

[RCEnigma]

Yall don't you think I'd play with a little more direction if I was

cult,

scum, ergo I'd know what's going on

Why would we assume you're town because you didn't play?

[RCEnigma]

FTR, I'm not sure what an incriminating flavor message from RCE would look like for the cult, nor do I particularly trust RCE's role to be overtly useful in this fashion

Agreed but I'll play along. Dunno how the role worked in the first iteration of this game.

[chennisden]

That argument does nothing for me. Do something town if you want to live.

VOTE: deb

[chennisden]

Yall don't you think I'd play with a little more direction if I was

cult,

scum, ergo I'd know what's going on

Why would we assume you're

town

scum because you didn't play?

[RCEnigma]

Because scum benefits more from lack of interaction than town. Agreed?

[chennisden]

Fair

[chennisden]

RCE I dont feel like ur town

[chennisden]

That argument does nothing for me. Do something town if you want to live.

Do something town even if you don't want to live. There's a boatload of analysis in the thread, but not a lot of feels reads and you're a decent feels-reads-player. I promise to come back to your reads if you flip town and I'm not likely to be going anywhere any time soon.

The last line is weird, Bingle, and it feels overtly pockety

[chennisden]

If it helps I feel like scum has led the dialogue for a while

[Rautherdir]

That argument does nothing for me. Do something town if you want to live.

Do something town even if you don't want to live. There's a boatload of analysis in the thread, but not a lot of feels reads and you're a decent feels-reads-player. I promise to come back to your reads if you flip town and I'm not likely to be going anywhere any time soon.

The last line is weird, Bingle, and it feels overtly pockety

Unless Bingle got recruited then he's town. I checked him night 1.

Also, Bingle, you do realize if Kid protects Pine then I can't get motivated, right? I need people to target within and have posts I can target before we end the day anyways.

[pisskop]

Ok sure I dont think pk's info on me could be called a role name. Nothing about what power I have appears anywhere in the thread afaik.

yous a dearven bartender.

[pisskop]

sorry barkeep

[Rautherdir]

If it helps I feel like scum has led the dialogue for a while

So, do you have any suspects due to this?

[Cephrir]

Ok sure I dont think pk's info on me could be called a role name. Nothing about what power I have appears anywhere in the thread afaik.

yous a dearven bartender.

ya, their point was this is a flavor title not a role name (e.g. doctor)

[Cephrir]

btw this is me in the n2 flavor

On the other side of town, a beefy Bugbear was using the original pad and quill to take notes on a target of his own. The Dwarf at The Rotten Crop knew none the wiser.

[Cephrir]

not that anyone is contesting it, but here are some flavor crumbs

I headed down to the dumpy bar nearby for a drink instead. Maybe the barkeep could offer me some clues. Maybe the liquor could ease my feeling that something was very wrong here.

for now, I need a drink.

I was washing out of the case. There was so much information, most of it worthless, and I found my desire to parse it was less than my desire to have a drink. These things happen even to the best. Slumps are just part of the job. Really, if you aren't having at least one brooding slump a week, you're not even a real PI.

I've solved my share of cases from bars and nightclubs with nothing but my wits and a stream of whiskey.

[Cephrir]

VOTE: TSE

That. Voting so it shows in my ISO.

Would you join the Vork wagon instead?

I would. I haven't had any interaction with Vork, so I'd prefer TSE who is actually scummy versus a null read.

My pitch to you is twofold:
1. There's no need to rush a TSE lynch.
2. Vork is a good alternative to TSE (especially for you).

On the first point: TSE's behaviour might look scummy, but that same behaviour can come from town or 3p. With that in mind, I'd say a more reliable way of reading TSE is through the flavour of his role.

If you go read the flavour of Drew's execution, you'll see that TSE is a spider person. TSE confirmed this later, saying his name is something like "goblin eater." Assuming TSE is telling the truth about the goblin aspect of his role, all we have to do is wait until we figure out where goblins fit into this game. If goblins are exclusively scum, then TSE is likely town. If goblins are mixed scum and town, then TSE is likely 3p. If there's no goblins, TSE lied and he's scum. In all 3 of these cases, we can figure out TSE's role if we wait for more information. There's no need to rush a lynch on TSE.

Looking at Vork for the second point: he's cruising under the radar, lurking, and disregarding the seriousness of his wagon. It's possible he's disinterested town, but I'd say it's more likely he's scum trying to downplay the pushes on him. The wagonomics of D1 points to Vork being possible scum, as he was the alternative wagon to Drew.

Finally, considering the fact that you're the third wagon, and recalling that TSE will be sorted later, your best play should be to join on Vork.

VOTE: Vork

Appealing to my sense of wagonomics, I'm in until I can verify. I also like the rationale especially compared to the reasons some players got on my wagon.

#pocketed

this doesn't seem like a scumbuddy interaction to me

[Cephrir]

the only other thing i get from titus/virgo iso is that i have no idea why she was calling UT obvtown

[Cephrir]

i don't have much to say about zor iso. his push on gamma started out strong and just sort of disappeared, and it's interesting he never addressed my post on his interaction with ut.

[Cephrir]

ok i see why no one has reread day 2 yet the relevant portion is 120 pages

[gobbledygook]

btw this is me in the n2 flavor

On the other side of town, a beefy Bugbear was using the original pad and quill to take notes on a target of his own. The Dwarf at The Rotten Crop knew none the wiser.

So you're the dwarf?

[gobbledygook]

Pisskop, who do you think is the cult leader?

[Cephrir]

btw this is me in the n2 flavor

On the other side of town, a beefy Bugbear was using the original pad and quill to take notes on a target of his own. The Dwarf at The Rotten Crop knew none the wiser.

So you're the dwarf?

yeah

dwarven barkeep, as pk said. my bar is the rotten crop.

also i'm working through d2 now and i so far i think we are focusing on all the wrong people today

[gobbledygook]

also i'm working through d2 now and i so far i think we are focusing on all the wrong people today

I agree, but I have no idea who we should be focusing on. It is quite sad.