Guns & Roses III [Game over]

[Amrun]

Why would scum pick N4 rose?

why wouldn’t they?

It’s probably more likely though hmmm. Interesting point.

[Amrun]

His decision about gamma being gun read as the most fake to me. It's not a strong read, but I'm 50/50 off of random chance and it's as good a starting place as any.

I'm open to being convinced on scumreads.

Can I towncase icon instead?

[Bingle]

why wouldn’t they?

It's a terrible choice.

It first presumes that town would pick N4 gun when they're vastly more likely to pick early roles and then presumes that both town N4 gun and scum N4 rose survive to N4.

Gun is just always a better choice for scum there, and early choices are better than later ones. If I were playing this setup, I'd never pick anything later than D3.

There's the potential that alim is fakeclaiming as spent gun (in which case they die) or just made an insane pick without input from partners, but leaning on Occams makes alim N4 rose crazy likely town if we can prove that is the case.

[Bingle]

Can I towncase icon instead?

You can, but I'm traditionally really hard to convince with towncases.

[Amrun]

Can I towncase icon instead?

You can, but I'm traditionally really hard to convince with towncases.

Have you read the whole game? (No judgment just asking)

[Menalque]

Ahhh jinglejanglebingleboi

[Menalque]

I think bingle makes it into the category of people I don’t feel bad about losing because of following them

[Menalque]

Hot take, soft preference on lynch order is Ico > Datisi. Thoughts?

How would you feel about doing amrun first instead?

[Amrun]

I think Bingle’s alim point is good, and his plan is good.

I think the lynch should be DogWatch. No truly viable teams work without her or alim in it, and alim is out for obvious reasons.

[Amrun]

Like even if I’m wrong on all my townreads, and both datisi/Ico are scum, DW or alim is the partner, never Menalque.

If one or more of them is right, both DW AND alim is scum.

[Menalque]

0-1 scum in mena/Amrun means 2-3 scum in Ico/datisi/dw/alim.

Dw feels like the unpopular consensus, but is being pushed by both Ico and datisi, which means he’s very unlikely to be pushed by a pure wagon. The fact that it’s a well, I guess wagon makes it an unlikely bus.

Alim is getting shot tonight.

Does anyone feel strongly about any of these points being wrong? If so, why?

DW is also being pushed by amrun, and harder than by datisi iirc

I also have some doubts about icon based on the interaction we had a few pages ago but it may be real time bias

[Menalque]

I also don’t really see datisi and think that if icon is scum amrun makes by far the most sense there

And i don’t really know what you’re seeing that’s scummy in dats beyond for instance alim, although I see how that’s a moot point if you’re shooting him

You realise that if we lynch scum today and alim is town tho then shooting him auto loses?

[Datisi]

Alim claimed N4 rose
If he's town he'll survive

[Menalque]

Wait I thought he said that was a meme?

[Datisi]

Idk
Claimed N3 then changed to N4

[Menalque]

Yeah I thought he’d then said later that that was a meme but maybe I got mixed up

[Datisi]

Icon said that N3 roses are a meme

[Menalque]

@bingle i need to sleep bc exhausted but I’ll case amrun tomorrow afternoon/evening if you can wait

[Menalque]

Icon said that N3 roses are a meme

Okay I think I may have just mixed up who was calling what a meme

[alimdia]

First, Bingle I hope you know that scum has a NK as well in addition to any guns

Secondly, I thought we all knew I was trolling when I changed my claim. I had breadcrumbs for night 3 rose and shit that I Showed ya all...

[alimdia]

I think Bingle’s alim point is good, and his plan is good.

I think the lynch should be DogWatch. No truly viable teams work without her or alim in it, and alim is out for obvious reasons.

@Amrun whats your post 3138 doing/implying?

[Bingle]

Can I towncase icon instead?

You can, but I'm traditionally really hard to convince with towncases.

Have you read the whole game? (No judgment just asking)

Not even close.

[Bingle]

First, Bingle I hope you know that scum has a NK as well in addition to any guns

Secondly, I thought we all knew I was trolling when I changed my claim. I had breadcrumbs for night 3 rose and shit that I Showed ya all...

Damn, I was hoping you'd stand by the claim. That makes this more complicated.

Why did you think you were worth keeping around by casting doubt on your ability to be nightkilled?

[Bingle]

Hot take, soft preference on lynch order is Ico > Datisi. Thoughts?

How would you feel about doing amrun first instead?

Via Dat's logic that there is 0-1 scum in you/Amrun, Amrun shouldn't be lynched today.

[Bingle]

With that said, I'm not tr-ing amrun. Neither her nor Dat gave me townvibes when I repped in.