Newbie 1976 - Game Over

[Naerys]

why is it impossible for you to reconsider

Not for me
UNVOTE: Saladman27

[NorwegianboyEE]

Wanna hear what Salad has to say about why he repped out.

[Ph0enix]

ok so
he has a history of constantly doing this exact same thing as Town
why is it impossible for you to reconsider that hey maybe? he's actually Town?

How does his behavior differ when he's scum then?

[Datisi]

consindering that he's been acting like this across his multiple Town games and has flaked out of his

only scum game

on site (that i know of, but i'm like 80% sure there aren't any others), i'd say he's solidly in his town meta

[Ph0enix]

Phoenix, if i may. What are your reads right now? I'd also like to know if you agree with my towncore. Me, you and Non Imh are unmistakably town.
Datisi, Saladman. Are most scummy.
Naerys and Map Wolf secondary in scumminess. (Although i think Naery's is most likely town, especially due to my scumread Datisi constantly trying to paint her as scum)

Will have to reread again more thoroughly in order to answer this one. I'll get to it, though.

[Ph0enix]

consindering that he's been acting like this across his multiple Town games and has flaked out of his

only scum game

on site (that i know of, but i'm like 80% sure there aren't any others), i'd say he's solidly in his town meta

How do you know that he does not behave in a similar way when playing scum then?

[Datisi]

I don't.

But considering the data I have, and the fact he's being pushed by Norway in blatantly bad faith, makes much more sense he's Town.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Your townread of Salad makes no sense. What has he done in this game that's convincing you so strongly he's town?
Only because i push him? You can't make that excuse, because i only started strongly pushing him on D2. You were defending him back on D1.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Waiting for you to link that same post Salad made again, like it somehow completely saves his slot from his previous suspicious behavior.

[Datisi]

Your townread of Salad makes no sense. What has he done in this game that's convincing you so strongly he's town?
Only because i push him? You can't make that excuse, because i only started strongly pushing him on D2. You were defending him back on D1.

so, you're purposefully ignoring me screaming "this is literally how town!Salad always plays" for the past Day and so? ok.

and yes, if you could actually explain how that post in which he shades his only defender??? (or any posts that he's made) actually make him scum i would be very happy

[Saladman27]

I repped out as scum cause I had too many games on and I thought playing as scum (an alignment I never rolled before) on a large wasn't worth to play. I didn't know any scum strata and it was my first large.

@mod I am vla till the 10th.

[Map Wolf]

I don't like Saladman's posts. 575 comes off as defeatist, which I don't like.

ok
why is it scum indicative

like if anyone manages to tell me why 575 makes any sense coming from scum!Salad i'm paying a round for everyone

It doesn't make sense to post this regardless of your alignment. I didn't say it was scum indicative.

[Datisi]

Yes, you didn't. But you were calling it out in such a way that pretty much all but said you were fine voting him, without explaining why that post makes him scum, after I said I don't think it does. If that's not truly the case, then my bad, but he is at the bottom of your readslist, so. Why is he there then?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Honestly, i'm not feeling a TR on Saladman just because of your trust tell. What's stopping Salad from rolling scum in this game and trying to emulate his town playstyle? If he literally always replaces out as scum he is actually breaking the rules of this forum.

[Datisi]

I really hope you are just scum who's trying to discredit me any way he can. Because otherwise that's disgusting.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Because otherwise that's disgusting.

Because i'm not townreading your golden boy?

[Datisi]

Because you're accusing me and/or him of cheating.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Hm...

Datisi, i'll ask the same question you asked me earlier.
Say i'm town. Including you and Saladman.
Who would the scum be then?
Naery's and Map Wolf?
What about Phoenix? Do you trust him?

[Datisi]

I trust him, so yes.

[Naerys]

I trust him, so yes.

Why do you trust Phoenix?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Assuming you as scum wouldn't be so unethical as to TR a scum!Saladman in bad faith, and he really is town here. Then maybe it really is Map Wolf with either Phoenix or Naerys.

[Datisi]

I trust him, so yes.

Why do you trust Phoenix?

He seems to be genuinely solving, at least the most out of all of us alive.

[Datisi]

Ok then
VOTE: Map

[NorwegianboyEE]

I keep thinking back on Map Wolf. No attempt at solving, just sheeping reads lists and opinions. I think Map Wolf could be a good alternative here.
Naery's are you opposed to a Map Wolf lynch?
VOTE: Map Wolf

[NorwegianboyEE]

Datisi, if you're actually scum and fooled me out of this i'm going to be so annoyed.