Mini Normal 2115: Fin

[profii]

quote it and remind me sorry

[profii]

I've read what I've missed and these are my thoughts on the current state of affairs.
Frost and insomnia are both town.
Luca and Profii are both scum.
I felt that Luca's jump onto frost was opportunistic and a way to distract from the profii discussion which has now dissolved.
VOTE: luca
I'll read through Luca's iso now to see if it was just the way I was reading through the thread.

The timing of this makes it look really bad.

Spoiler: The VC looked like this

VC 1.5

Looker
EeveeLution Army
Wimpy
Ame
Luca Blight (2) - AaronFrost, Looker
Alchemist21 (1) - Egix96
Chara (1) - Macabre
Macabre (1) - Wimpy
insomnia
JTheophrastus Bartholomew (2) - profii, Chara
profii
AaronFrost (4) - insomnia, Ame, Luca Blight, Alchemist21
Egix96 (1) - JTheophrastus Bartholomew

Not Voting

(1) — EeveeLution Army

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2020-01-24 16:00:00)[/color]

JT previously had me as Town and had said nothing of Frost. How did he suddenly reach this conclusion? It looks like a desperate attempt to save his scum buddy.

was that VC post aaron-slip? I think it would be weird that anyone wouldnt vote aaron after that post as it seemed really obvious to me that it was a slip but like i kinda wouldnt categorise it as 'not getting a on a scum wagon' because it was pretty obvious he was going to go either way so as scum i think you'd have to say to yourself there is no point resisting this.

why would this be post slip if he stated Frost was town

i just checked and slip was 434 so yeah ok JT resisted the wagon and luca pointed it out. Noted.

[Ame]

Points*

which bit are you interested in feedback on

The case here viewtopic.php?p=11531677#p11531677

There's three things I'd like your opinion on specifically:

1. The JTB/Egix/Aaron case I made here.
2. Egix having a solid town read on you yesterday. My view is that it was unwarranted and he was coming from a place of TMI.
3. His going after Al for apparently attempting to role fish Looker, but doing so in a way that actually brought attention to Looker. #249, 266, 343, 371

[Ame]

We should have lynched obvious when we had the chance. His wagon died and I doubt it’ll come back now.

Oh don't worry, it'll come back

[Wimpy]

@profli - Macabre was also hiding his statue and intentionally lurking. Right after I call him out for it he posts within 20 minutes and his log in status still said Saturday. Imo town doesn’t do that.

It really is birdman and Bart now OS.

I’m pretty confident in that solve.

[Wimpy]

We should have lynched obvious when we had the chance. His wagon died and I doubt it’ll come back now.

Oh don't worry, it'll come back

I don’t have faith it will

[Ame]

Updated

Looker -- Hydra
EeveeLution Army -- Roman lover
Wimpy -- Burger
Ame -- Scarfboii
Luca Blight -- Knight
insomnia -- Sleepy boiii
OS -- Hedgehog/mysteriousone/seal
profii -- Chimera
Egix96 -- Wolf

Macabre -- this crow

Aaron -- Ghost
Alchemist -- Colonel
Chara -- One-Eye

[Ame]

based on #827 Ame thinks Looker and I are town now.

So you are voting him because Ame thinks you guys are town? What do YOU think about looker?

On D1 I felt that Looker was town, but since Alch flipped town my read there has kinda reset

What does Alch's alignment have to do with your read on Looker? Please walk through how Al being scum leads to scum Looker and how Al being town nullifies that.

[Ame]

based on #827 Ame thinks Looker and I are town now.

So you are voting him because Ame thinks you guys are town? What do YOU think about looker?

On D1 I felt that Looker was town, but since Alch flipped town my read there has kinda reset

What does Alch's alignment have to do with your read on Looker? Please walk through how Al being scum leads to scum Looker and how Al being town nullifies that.

Edit nevermind had it backwards

scum al means town looker

[Wimpy]

Updated

Looker -- Hydra
EeveeLution Army -- Roman lover
Wimpy -- Burger
Ame -- Scarfboii
Luca Blight -- Knight
insomnia -- Sleepy boiii
OS -- Hedgehog/mysteriousone/seal
profii -- Chimera
Egix96 -- Wolf

Macabre -- this crow

Aaron -- Ghost
Alchemist -- Colonel
Chara -- One-Eye

we shouldn't even have to worry about these names

[Ame]

Fuck man why am I so bad at playing scum

I probably get lynched today 9/10 times so I'm gonna try my best not to draw associations

Wow scum slip.

fuck

Unlucky Frost. My perfect record at reading you continues

sighhhhh

VOTE: AaronFrost

Why am I so bad at playing scum

It's weird to me that these posts are so close in time signature. Does this interaction effectively clear Luca?

Why is it weird?

[insomnia]

Macabre was also hiding his statue and intentionally lurking. Right after I call him out for it he posts within 20 minutes and his log in status still said Saturday. Imo town doesn’t do that.

[Wimpy]

Man when bird man flips scum I’m gonna copy pasta all over your ass

[Ame]

The One-eye would not try to kill me, but this crow cannot share the same sentiment for the dead-eye. Mourn!

Please claim. Currently, I can't see any other scum mate with Aaron/Obvious other than you and wimpy. If you're vig, we can sort the game today.

It is troubling that the scarf boy had failed to re-evaluate the Chimera on the previous day and the wolf-hydra this day. Pattern!

All my final (and relevant) D1 reads are posted here, where I explicitly renounce any suspicions of profii. Are you correcting yourself in the post below?

It was in fact a read against a potential Chimera-Ghost team on the previous day. Correction!

If so, I don't get why you asked this:

Could this scarf boy, who believed that the One-eye was a high level criminal, miss this critical piece of information? Inquiry!

As I also renounced suspicions of Chara in the same post. Hmm!

It is troubling that the scarf boy had failed to re-evaluate...the wolf-hydra this day. Pattern!

While the scarf boy appears to have changed their read, this is based mainly on the testimony of the mysterious one. It should not have taken this long to come to this conclusion. Hood!

Please do explain why I should have changed my mind on Egix and Looker before I knew about the neighborhood.

We must ask ourselves, why come forward in these moments specifically? Could we find motive in negative spaces? Speak no evil!

You mean like you did after wimpy called you out ?

[Wimpy]

Please claim. Currently, I can't see any other scum mate with Aaron/Obvious other than you and

wimpy

[insomnia]

Man when bird man flips scum I’m gonna copy pasta all over your ass

[Ame]

Locked on profii town. Reading through Aaron (

again

) it's clear that he had a lynch profii agenda.
Locked on Luca, Insomnia
Think it's highly unlikely EV or Looker are scum
Think it's unlikely Egix is scum

Locked on Obvscum scum.
Unable to PoE Wimpy and disregarding Aaron's RVS hard Mac TR. If Mac is Vig, then wimpy is scum.

[insomnia]

If the bird man flips scum, it will ultimately be an arbitrary call than actual scum hunting but I'll give you the satisfaction.

[Wimpy]

Locked on profii town. Reading through Aaron (

again

) it's clear that he had a lynch profii agenda.
Locked on Luca, Insomnia
Think it's highly unlikely EV or Looker are scum
Think it's unlikely Egix is scum

Locked on Obvscum scum.
Unable to PoE Wimpy and disregarding Aaron's RVS hard Mac TR. If Mac is Vig, then wimpy is scum.

looker and insomnia both look like scum partners for aaron. you're insane to lock town on insomnia

[Wimpy]

bird and OS are the final two though for real. trust in the burger

[Wimpy]

I'll gladly pay you Tuesday for a bird burger today

[insomnia]

I think Looker's scummier than OS.

I mean, it's hard for me to envision a third with OS. Looker has a general theme of not trying to sort anyone.

[Ame]

looker and insomnia both look like scum partners for aaron. you're insane to lock town on insomnia

Insomnia's reads are too legit. Led Aaron wagon when Aaron was being town read. Game solve mode post-aaron flip too genuine. Honestly, there's a million reasons why Insomnia is town. Did you guys kill Alch to discredit him1?!?!?!?!??

I can't disagree with you on Looker. I'm sorting her by the assumption that there aren't two scum in the neighborhood and that if there are, Egix is more likely to be the second.

I think Looker's scummier than OS.

I mean, it's hard for me to envision a third with OS. Looker has a general theme of not trying to sort anyone.

Who's third if Looker is scum?

[Wimpy]

He was very fence sitty early on about Aaron. He made a post saying something about tvt which means he’s aware of site meta.

The way he started the push on Aaron definitely feels like it was planned scum theater. I don’t think he honestly expected it to take off.

Hard busses are becoming more common. If he's scum he rides his town cred to victory. Nobody is going to come after him. If he does get into trouble he busses his other buddy.

It’s a great strategy especially if you have weaker scum buddies.

[insomnia]

I'm sorting Looker with the assumption that there aren't two scum in the hood either.