"You are the Joker of mafia players" - Oversoul
"last time I was scum with Firebringer
his first post in the scum PT was "yes I rolled scum!"
I decided to post "haha just don't post that in the main thread", but to get up to date on the main thread first.
His first post in the main thread was "yes I rolled scum!" -popsofctown
In post 5005, panthaleon wrote:I'm going to pout, sit on nom, hammer DV if someone needs to by deadline, and then spend tomorrow tunneling on nom until she, like, does anything.
k
if it makes you feel better I still feel that nom+DV being scum together is in the realm of possibility
cause if you're both going to be scummy and the game's stalling out due to town apathy might as well bus and make the other look better when one of you inevitably gets lynched (and what would their other plan be today - lynch DEB and both look like garbage tomorrow anyway for switching onto him assuming he flips town?)
but hey maybe I'm wrong about nom too and she'll actually like play the game and look town on her own terms after a DV-scum lynch that's possible too I guess
And actually know that I’m on it, if I should know that and I am scum, why aren’t I creating pretend scumreads? (Which I can very easily do)
I mean, I’ve indicated a pool that I think the scum are likely within, I feel passionate about non hmmmm being scum, and that has been looking like a potential option for a significant portion of the day.
I don’t actually get what you’re trying to say.
It’s like you’re making an argument for me being underwhelming town
DeasVail wrote:
It’s like you’re making an argument for me being underwhelming town
I mean I have said basically exactly that you've underwhelmed me earlier in the game so it's p. close to that
But I also don't see a particular reason why you're more likely to be underwhelming town than complacent scum who didn't think a wagon would flip on you by the end of the day.
And persistent sure but I dunno if passionate is how I'd describe how you've gone after nom.
I don't think there's a single player in the game who wouldn't lynch DEB over themselves at the end of the day but if you have more nuanced thoughts on FL I certainly wouldn't mind hearing them.
I think as with much of this game, there is a lot of not-so-helpful filler.
I was happy with the growing suspicion on nom and the wagon on her. I still don't really know why it fell apart. People seemed to be into it and then get cold feet? I don't know.
I think that the hysteria surrounding neighbourhood actions was kind of overblown, but I think dave's suspicion of me seems town-driven.
Skimming over various parts of the day I think I'm back to being suspicious of kuribo and if I'm lynched I think it would be unwise to give him a free pass.
The reason I'd be okay with an FL lynch is that there's a lot of posts and a lot of talking but I don't get the impression from his posts that he actually cares what happens. Nothing specific, just a general impression.
I think it was ridiculous that panth became someone that people suspected with MariaR strongly vouching for the slot being town and there being very little in the way of explanation for why the things that made people upset with panth actually would come from scum.
More specifically on my wagon.
Dave is town and I understand why he would think I'm scum.
I think A50 and I are just on a totally different wavelength when it comes to everything so I don't understand what he's doing but I struggle to see the slot as scum. Related, when going over things I think that kuribo used my suspicion of him as a convenient excuse to go from a townread to a scumread of me. I just don't feel it. That could be affected by him not having his mind in the game recently though, so I'm hesitant to act on that immediately.
Despite earlier concerns, Ank is someone who I had a growing townread of. She seems genuinely bogged down by the various frustrations of the game and voting me makes sense coming from that place. I think that she is wrong about nom.
I think that nom's approach to my slot comes from scum. She's always had me as a scumread, but her reasons for thinking I'm scum have never justified the enduring and unquestioning nature of her scumread.
EP is still a big question mark for me. His approach to reads and the game generally have been weird to me in an out-of-left-field way that I think is strange to come from scum, but possible. That's why he's not an explicit townread for me but I don't really want to lynch him.
Most likely to be scum imo are nomnom, Flavor Leaf (combination of PoE and just a general impression). With DEB and Kuribo as alternative options. EP as a maybe.
If I'm wrong about nom, then FB is a strong contender for scum. MariaR has an outside chance of being scum imo. I could also just be totally wrong on A50 because I don't feel confident in reading his sort of play but I'm holding to my townread.
I think that dave, chenn, gamma, Ank, panth are all town and it would be difficult to convince me otherwise.
In post 5016, DeasVail wrote:The reason I'd be okay with an FL lynch is that there's a lot of posts and a lot of talking but I don't get the impression from his posts that he actually cares what happens.
Did somebody say L-1?
VOTE: DeasVail
In what world do I never care what happens as any alignment.
In post 5016, DeasVail wrote:I think it was ridiculous that panth became someone that people suspected with MariaR strongly vouching for the slot being town and there being very little in the way of explanation for why the things that made people upset with panth actually would come from scum.
I was specifically stating 1 of them were scum, not both.
Also, DV is pandering at the end, looks like clever distancing from Maria.
And before anyone goes “scummy shutting down discussion” i waited until he posted his last stuff, and I didn’t even have to do it because Panth stated he’d hammer by deadline, which is in a day.
Main thing I should have waited for was to see if Maria would do anything, but she was probably just lurking out to try and not have to explain being off the wagon.
I was here, I lived, I loved, I was here
I did, I've done, everything that I wanted
And it was more than I thought it would be
I will leave my mark, soul, everyone will know, I was here
When things seem hopeless, remember that you're all great <3
