In post 937, Farkran wrote:Chara still strongly townread hectic, providing reasons - except, look at my reply to its post 380, several lines above this. All the reasons stated by Chara in 561 were already present at the point in time of 380. Still, Chara is healing Replica now.
This makes sense - disagree with the Replica spare at that stage, but stewing on the reasons for sparing someone and then coming to a stronger conclusion is reasonable enough. I understand why you had this interpretation if you thought that Chara experienced a significant drop on the Hectic townread, but I don't think that was the case.
In post 937, Farkran wrote:
In post 607, Replica wrote:
HEAL: popsofctown this one's not just an unvote, it's really for you, the MVP for all the work you put into running this and for letting me replace in.
HEAL: Hectic but ONLY FOR A SECOND WE STILL ON THE SPARE TRAIN CHOO CHOO
Remember my keep in mind note ¹? The train of votes on Hectic suddenly turned from a reservation to a bonus reason to heal there.
Roughly at this point, Sujimichi townslip was pointed out, and shortly later the long and passionate exchange between me and Replica happened.
.
Hmmm. You're misinterpreting Replica's uncomfortableness with the wagon -
301 implies that he doesn't like Chara and I being on the wagon but I don't see him saying that he was uncomfortable with the number of votes on it. I don't understand the keep in mind note - there was only one that you left and it clearly wasn't connected to this.
In post 937, Farkran wrote:Chara starts scumreading me for my push on Replica and nothing else.
...yeah, I don't actually understand that attack at all? Awkward that at the end of the "it is dangerous to cast a fight vote" exchange Chara starts to scumread you based on how you worded a defense as opposed to addressing any of the content itself.
In post 937, Farkran wrote:
In post 337, Chara wrote:
and besides that, even if i don't know if i agree with what they think is best, because we aren't playing math here but mafia (as they said themself)
Here Chara pretty much agrees with
literally the same thing
i will say later in my argument against Replica. KEEP THIS IN MIND².
In post 937, Farkran wrote:
In post 848, Chara wrote:i think Farkran is scum for reasons besides disagreeing about optimal strategy.
I would be very curious to hear these now, since you are already fighting me in d2 when i argued against Replica
for the exact same reasons you pointed out in my note ²
.
Chara is still agreeing with you here - just also stating that it is scumreading you for reasons OTHER than disagreeing about optimal strategy, which I understand.
In post 937, Farkran wrote:At the end of day 1, both Chara and Replica are scumreading me, whereas they are townreading themselves and Hectic. This is pretty much a very convoluted omgus/chainsaw defense,
there are no other reasons to scumread me at this point
- none of Asriel ISO has been used for a scumcase, which would have been something i would agree with - but i specifically asked if they scumread Farkran because of Farkran, and they said they do.
The bolded is wrong; that isn't how mafia works. The thrust of your point here is "they're scumreading me and there's no reason to scumread me", which is problematic - yes, you are town, and yes, people are scumreading you incorrectly and their reasons are wrong. Doesn't mean they can't be coming from a genuine place.
I don't think that the progressions on either of those two reads is problematic - Hectic went from scum on Chara to lean on Chara to town on Chara. It makes sense that he's willing to spare the person he's had the most interactions with hands down - that's the person he's put the most effort into reading. Hectic had a lean town on Replica simply grew stronger with time, which makes sense.
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
