Titus v. Alisae (endgame)

[OkaPoka]

Sherlock you need to vote bitmap

[insomnia]

Sherlock you need to vote bitmap

[OkaPoka]

For the same reasons why i ended up choosing mako over you

[Sherlock and Watson]

Aaron hasn't claimed other than being hooded by chemmy right?

-S

[Titus]

I do have a theory if Bitmap flips scum that will satisfy almost everyone. Just give me this one.

@RR, Bitmap lynch is preferred due to him hooding before protecting in addition to being a universal scumread.

[Sherlock and Watson]

What's he at? I wanted ank to weigh in before day closes

-S

[OkaPoka]

Yes but titus is vetoing

Titus wants bitmap lynch and itll be helpful for town to see your support

[Titus]

What's he at? I wanted ank to weigh in before day closes

-S

Ank and I weighed in when discussing the lynch.

Let's end the day.

[insomnia]

ank is kind of reluctant to vote bit but she said she would vote him

[AaronFrost]

Ali what about 3952? is that a slip?

See, now if I were to say "Chemist hooded AaronFrost and they're in a neighborhood together" then that would be a slip

The only think needed here is a scum tracker if Alisae knows Chemist role as a neighboring player.

Chemist claimed JoaT though, so in order for this to be the case

1) Chem would have to be scum
2) Ali would have to somehow know that Chem was a JoaT and which shot he was using and who he was using it on

[AaronFrost]

Aaron hasn't claimed other than being hooded by chemmy right?

-S

Nope

Did someone ask me to claim earlier? I thought someone did but I can't remember.

[Ankamius]

Where's ank

Ank bitty vs chemmy?

-S

I'd rather lynch chemist tbh

[OkaPoka]

Look, certain slots need to support Titus right now and if that doesnt happen then the door is open to chaos

Sherlock you are one of those slots

Ank you too

[Reasonably Rational]

Want to help me lynch you then


Nah i i I cleared hectic

Okay, cool, so the question about why you're distinguishing between my slot and AF's, when we're both talking about essentially the same things, needs to be addressed.

Sure, Ali could have randomly selected two individuals and declared they were in a hood; given the high density of hoods in this game, such a declaration would have a chance of yielding a positive(not a good chance, likely something like 5% or less, but still a greater chance than in a game with less hoods); it's the fact that chance is so low given she would have to accurate select both halves of a pair that means you have to view that as improbable and not something that should be strongly considered when deciding how likely it is that people are town or scum.

-Cerb

Context isn't random. There was a hood discussion at the point before the "slip".

Mmm that's fair. Alright. If you want to, I would welcome being directed towards the posts that occurred prior to that which may have given Ali cause to name specific names over others; otherwise I'll try to get around to looking at it myself.

-Cerb

pedit: Hooding before using any other role is just good play, if you have a strong enough townread on someone to use them as a channel for communicating results and actions(barring some way of being certain that your action will 1) catch scum or 2) save town. That's not a strong argument.

[Ankamius]

I'm purposely not talking because my opinion either is going to cause tension or derail a lynch that the majority wants

no real benefit

[OkaPoka]

Unless you have reasonable objections you are going to encourage wildcards to be wildcards and tilting titus isnt a good thing

Just show support and vote stop dragging feet

[Titus]

I'm purposely not talking because my opinion either is going to cause tension or derail a lynch that the majority wants

no real benefit

I respect this. I feel the pull to lynch in the hood at the last second is scum motivated.

[Bitmap]

Hooding N1 is not scummy fyi

[insomnia]

^^^

[OkaPoka]

And if you dont show support well titus is going to be mor3 susceptible to being buddied

Having a buddied ic is not good

[Bitmap]

if there's a good player that's worth hooding, I'll always hood before any other action especially on N1 and that's NAI.

[Sherlock and Watson]

I do agree with you tho ank I think I prefer chemmy rn too

Bitty says all sorts of weird noise but its hard to tell and also it would break tse's tunnel one way or another

That being said not thinking more about bitty would be nice

-S

[insomnia]

that's such a bad argument

tse will always tunnel someone anyway

[Bitmap]

If I had a cop shot and the option to hood RC/Ank

I'd hood RC/Ank any day everyday.

[Titus]

Hooding N1 is not scummy fyi

Over protecting it is.

Strong Investigative
Protect
Anything else

You're not convincing me here. Protecting someone so they live > hooding them and they die.