Newbie 1987 | Game Over

[Karnage]

Vote Count 2.3

Maduisha (2) ~

GeneralWu, OldMapleNostalgia,

72offsuit (2) ~

clidd, JacksonVirgo,

OldMapleNostalgia (1) ~

Maduisha,

GeneralWu (1) ~

72offsuit,

Not voting (1) ~

ceejayvinoya,

With 7 alive it's 4 to lynch

Deadline: (expired on 2020-03-04 07:38:13)

V/LA: none

[clidd]

Not sure if it's shyness or something, but it weirds me out that a lot of people haven't even voted yet

It weirds me out that you had voted for somebody who hasn't even posted yet

Yeah, voting for people that haven't even showed up feels wrong. I don't really know who to vote for yet, but those asking for people to cast votes aren't giving me good vibes, and two of them have votes on the same person.

I agree with these
There's no point in forcing everyone to cast a vote, especially this early in the game.
Also it's especially not good to vote for people who probably haven't even looked at the thread yet
It's much better to wait till they actually post something before voting them

This feels like a contradiction. You are saying pushing for people to vote is a bad idea.
JV votes PKP and we get a very non-chalant response from PKP at being voted. This prompts you to scumread/at least question PKP's response.

So basically JVs vote has stimulated discussion and a potential scum read on PKP and yet you are saying pushing others to bote is bad?

Votes are good because they stimulate discussion and force players to take a stance, rather than sit on the fence, which favours scum, as scum can then just come up with a fake 'scum read' late in the day to lynch a townie.

Im on board the GW lynch train.
Jump aboard people, plenty of room on the wagon.
Choo choo

VOTE: GW

VOTE: GeneralWu

I'm tracker by the way. GW visited the masonhood wielding a bazooka.

Would

scum!72offsuit

buss his partner ?

[clidd]

Well, I have already expressed my opinion on Maduisha case. If majority wants to lynch her, that's fine, but I won't get involved for two reasons:

1° She being scum implies early-game suicide strategy.
2° Volatile behavior indicates authenticity of thought, difficult to fake as scum. Newbie!Scum usually plays more timidly, especially the first time. The way she attracted attention is opposite to that premise.

THIS. Town is reckless. Scum is calculating, has a scum private thread to discuss plans. Scum cares about appearances. Town is more likely to have an i dont give a shit attitude.
Furthermore, I seriously doubt! ScumMad's scum buddy to scummily hammer like that.

Mad is town.

zzz. Ok.

[clidd]

Can you confess soon? it won't be long before we catch your partner.

[clidd]

I'm getting impatient with this idle playerlist.

[72offsuit]

Now, changing the subject: who is the second

mason

among us ?

72offsuit
Maduisha
GeneralWu
OldMapleNostalgia
ceejayvinoya (SE)
JacksonVirgo (SE)

At this point, the chance of fake claims has passed. There is no point in continuing to keep your identity hidden.

Agree with this. It would stop scum from ccing and give us a confirmed townie

A Cc gives 50*50 of lynching scum. Should be saved for tomorrow. Mafia have only 20 percent chance of night killing mason tonight. We scumhunt without a mason claim.

[72offsuit]

Well, we basically broke the game here if that's right.

You havent broken shit.

[clidd]

? I'm not understanding you.

[clidd]

Can you shut up ? im losing I.Q with each of your posts.

[72offsuit]

Mad, you, myself and the Mason are probably all town. Scum is in ceejay, maple, general and 72

My guess is maple and 72

Nice guess. Care to elaborate?

[clidd]

Ok, guys

72offsuit

is scum. Vote on him.

[72offsuit]

As of right now my solve is ceejay and GW. Their interaction early in the game sounded extremely artificial

[72offsuit]

Ok, guys

72offsuit

is scum. Vote on him.

Coolstorybro

[clidd]

Now, changing the subject: who is the second

mason

among us ?

72offsuit
Maduisha
GeneralWu
OldMapleNostalgia
ceejayvinoya (SE)
JacksonVirgo (SE)

At this point, the chance of fake claims has passed. There is no point in continuing to keep your identity hidden.

Agree with this. It would stop scum from ccing and give us a confirmed townie

A Cc gives 50*50 of lynching scum. Should be saved for tomorrow. Mafia have only 20 percent chance of night killing mason tonight. We scumhunt without a mason claim.

'' I don't trust your plan ''

Ok, guys

72offsuit

is scum. Vote on him.

As of right now my solve is ceejay and GW. Their interaction early in the game sounded extremely artificial

'' Wait, i changed my mind ''

[72offsuit]

Not sure if it's shyness or something, but it weirds me out that a lot of people haven't even voted yet

It weirds me out that you had voted for somebody who hasn't even posted yet

Yeah, voting for people that haven't even showed up feels wrong. I don't really know who to vote for yet, but those asking for people to cast votes aren't giving me good vibes, and two of them have votes on the same person.

I agree with these
There's no point in forcing everyone to cast a vote, especially this early in the game.
Also it's especially not good to vote for people who probably haven't even looked at the thread yet
It's much better to wait till they actually post something before voting them

This feels like a contradiction. You are saying pushing for people to vote is a bad idea.
JV votes PKP and we get a very non-chalant response from PKP at being voted. This prompts you to scumread/at least question PKP's response.

So basically JVs vote has stimulated discussion and a potential scum read on PKP and yet you are saying pushing others to bote is bad?

Votes are good because they stimulate discussion and force players to take a stance, rather than sit on the fence, which favours scum, as scum can then just come up with a fake 'scum read' late in the day to lynch a townie.

Im on board the GW lynch train.
Jump aboard people, plenty of room on the wagon.
Choo choo

VOTE: GW

VOTE: GeneralWu

I'm tracker by the way. GW visited the masonhood wielding a bazooka.

Would

scum!72offsuit

buss his partner ?

1. Im town
2. Had i rolled scum, in this scenario i would not bus when the game is like 70 percent won with mason dead night 1

[72offsuit]

How did i change my mind? What are you smoking?

[clidd]

A genuine reaction would not have been confusing, but would have immediately contributed to the PoE.

Now, changing the subject: who is the second

mason

among us ?

72offsuit
Maduisha
GeneralWu
OldMapleNostalgia
ceejayvinoya (SE)
JacksonVirgo (SE)

At this point, the chance of fake claims has passed. There is no point in continuing to keep your identity hidden.

Agree with this. It would stop scum from ccing and give us a confirmed townie

Like this.

[clidd]

Im considering

you

and

GeneralWu

as a team. Checkmate.

[clidd]

You right now:

Spoiler:

'' Dammit, they got me '' -

72offsuit

[clidd]

Can you start your AtE (appeal to emotions) or something ? unless you want to skip this stage, of course.

[clidd]

VOTE: 72offsuit

[72offsuit]

Your vote is just bad. Your reasoning is bad. You completley ignored my responses to your questions which makes you scummy.

[72offsuit]

A genuine reaction would not have been confusing, but would have immediately contributed to the PoE.

Now, changing the subject: who is the second

mason

among us ?

72offsuit
Maduisha
GeneralWu
OldMapleNostalgia
ceejayvinoya (SE)
JacksonVirgo (SE)

At this point, the chance of fake claims has passed. There is no point in continuing to keep your identity hidden.

Agree with this. It would stop scum from ccing and give us a confirmed townie

Like this.

Your PoE means nothing.
You put yourslef as town which is looking less and less with your recent posts.

[72offsuit]

Welcome!

NEWBIE 1987

mod: Karnage

Player List

• 72offsuit
  
  
• clidd
  *
  
• Maduisha
  
  
• Phi Kappa Phi
  
  
• GeneralWu
  
  
• OldMapleNostalgia
  
  
• ceejayvinoya
  (SE)
  
• JacksonVirgo
  (SE)
  
• ObviousScum
  (SE)

* indicates a prod

Spoilers

Spoiler: living

• 72offsuit
  
• clidd
  
• Maduisha
  
• GeneralWu
  
• OldMapleNostalgia
  
• ceejayvinoya
  
• JacksonVirgo

Spoiler: dead

• Phi Kappa Phi
  Vanilla Townie
  - Lynched Day 1
  
• ObviousScum
  Town Mason
  - Killed Night 1

Major Events

• 5 - Day 1 Starts
  
• 230 - Day 1 Ends

• 231 - Day 2 Starts

Ebwop less and less likely*

[72offsuit]

Z idk why it quoted that, misclick, im on mobile