Titus v. Alisae (endgame)

[Sherlock and Watson]

Did you read my post about Hectic's fencesitting response to my "slip" that other players took as either slip/not slip?

link me his reaction to the slip?

AF has permission to flip scum for having a bad bitmap progression on day 1

AF has permission to flip town for vibing with me in feel/reads most the game

RR has permission to flip scum for approaching the ascetic claims in a way that feels dumb to me but Titus maintains this is just a plausible playstyle difference

RR has permission to flip town for the initial AtE about not being mason but also they double down on the point so I actually don't like it that much

-S

[Sherlock and Watson]

fuck I denied myself the pagetop

[Sherlock and Watson]

Well what are you doing to determine which of your TRs is wrong?

not to be critical but I feel like almost every time I do anything in this game you tell me to stop doing it

-S

[gobbledygook]

Sherlock, how many total posts do you think Watson has made in this game?

[gobbledygook]

i don't normally like "scumslips" but this one might have grounds tbh
i feel like this sort of thing can be checked if people meta Gobsie and see if they ever ever refer to town as "they" while also being town

i'm too lazy to do this and should also be working so good luck whoever takes up this honorouable task!

i don't normally like "scumslips" but this one might have grounds tbh
i feel like this sort of thing can be checked if people meta Gobsie and see if they ever ever refer to town as "they" while also being town

Hectic what? There's no way you actually think that right?

maybe?
i can see the world where scum forget to include themselves as town
but true it is more likely that it's just another NAI thing being considered as a "scumslip"

[Sherlock and Watson]

Hmm ballpark 40+?

-S

[Sherlock and Watson]

He'd probably have more but whenever we talk about stuff on discord I usually recount the conversation before he does

-S

[Sherlock and Watson]

I mean it was a dumb argument that only works in the context of a larger case and meta so I can vibe with him wanting to ignore a linguistic tell like that until someone else actually proves it means anything

-Sa

[Sherlock and Watson]

Sherlock, how many total posts do you think Watson has made in this game?

No worries, turkey. I'm following along.

~W

[Flavor Leaf]

Hmm liked his early game tone, the gambit on Oka could go either way but all in all I think scum would be aware that rolefishing that blatantly is more likely to generate blowback, have generally felt like I see where he's coming from irt reads. Only seen his scum game in marathons iirc; in those he tended to have a lot more noise but marathon not a great metric. Don't really see why he's getting scumread rn?

-S

Are you talking about Hectic? Because I’m really annoyed if so, because I spent a page and a half casing him.

[gobbledygook]

I mean it was a dumb argument that only works in the context of a larger case and meta so I can vibe with him wanting to ignore a linguistic tell like that until someone else actually proves it means anything

-Sa

What do you think scum do in the event a town player tunnels on another town player for a "scumslip" ? Do you think they support the slip, discount, ignore it altogether?

[Sherlock and Watson]

Small chance of Hectic/Gobbledy

On one hand I'm offended Ali didn't want me and on the other hand I am relieved.

Like when someone doesn't sit next to you on the bus.

town

scum

There’s actually a tinfoil theory of Hectic/Espe.

tbh I'd sooner scumread you for these posts then Hectic, boon

in the rest of your page the only thing that I at all notice is that 404 is the sort of stuff that could come from scum Hectic, but I'd expect a lot more of those types of posts early game than what we actually have and it's not nearly enough to make me want to flip him to scum rn

I mean I have no scumreads so sure I could be wrong but I wouldn't bet on Hectic before most of the other slots we got on the block

-S

[Sherlock and Watson]

What do you think scum do in the event a town player tunnels on another town player for a "scumslip" ? Do you think they support the slip, discount, ignore it altogether?

Would you actually call RR's push a "tunnel"?

-S

[Sherlock and Watson]

P.S. - That looks like an actual slip. When you're typing fast and slinging one liners is when you're most likely to forget to adjust things like pronouns. You just say what your brain knows is true. Telling a linguist to "Learn to English" might feel like a good "comeback" but it doesn't change that fact that your brain

excluded

you from the town.

Yeah that is definitely NOT a scum slip. I often use they when referring to the town as a whole and in general try to refer to myself neutrally when talking about myself under the assumption that no one knows my alignment (unless I'm conf town or something). This just feels nitpicky.

this could be scum but it could be scum because it's the "right" answer (you see how that works)

That kind of slip isn't like guaranteed to be a proper "slip" always. It depends heavily on how trained in rhetoric the person typing the post is.

The

reaction

to being pushed on it is the point. GGs reaction is bad and then he disappeared. That's way more telling than a grammatical slip by itself.

~D

This is probably townie tbh

-S

[Sherlock and Watson]

I could lynch Aaron for using the word "nitpicky"

That's a scummy word LOL

-S

[Alisae]

BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE JUST SITTING ON INFO AND LIKE NOBODY WITH A CLAIM IS PUSHING ANYTHING SO LETS JUST GET IT ALL OUT THERE

IF ESPY CAME OUT WITH ASCETIC YESTERDAY I BET CHEMIST WOULD HAVE LIVED

he came out with it day 1 hello???????

[Alisae]

I could lynch Aaron for using the word "nitpicky"

That's a scummy word LOL

-S

you are being nitpicky

[gobbledygook]

What do you think scum do in the event a town player tunnels on another town player for a "scumslip" ? Do you think they support the slip, discount, ignore it altogether?

Would you actually call RR's push a "tunnel"?

-S

Yes. What would you call it?

Also answer my question.

[Sherlock and Watson]

7488 was an answer

-S

[Sherlock and Watson]

I could lynch Aaron for using the word "nitpicky"

That's a scummy word LOL

-S

you are being nitpicky

see, look how scummy that is!

-S

[Alisae]

but im town

[Alisae]

:c

[Flavor Leaf]

Hectic, Hectic, Hectic.

SandW’s gone insane, don’t listen to their reads here

[Sherlock and Watson]

Are you trying to say I'm Krazy?

-S

[Espeonage]

Vote: Hectic