About the topic at hand, i never felt like i have been significantly townreaded. As i said in the past, every player in this game - except pretty much just hectic - has been simultaneously townread and scumread by the two halves of the playerlist, at some point. During d1, Asriel has been scumreaded by Nacho, Chara, Amrun, Suji, and later by Hectic when i started scumreading him. During d2 i have been townreaded by Chemist, Bingle, Psyche; scumreaded by Hectic, Nacho, Chara, Replica, and Amrun to some extent. Then Hectic was spared, Psyche died, and during d3, Nacho entered the day re-evaluating his hard-townread of me for no reason at all, Amrun has always been flipflopping his read of me, Chara seems to have reconsidered me to some extent, Bingle and Chemist weakened their townread of me but ultimately still maintained it, Replica at first weakened his scumread but as soon as we started quarreling again he immediately reinstated it just because of his stubborness rather than any concrete reason.
Out of these players, and considering the mindset that scum was forced to have during d3 (avoid a scum lynch at -ALL- costs), i think that the most scummy player among that list is definitely Nacho, followed by Amrun and Chara, followed by Bingle whom i don't really consider scummy atm. I don't buy that Nacho's progression on me is hardtownread > potential reconsideration > hardscumread while not admitting even for a second the possibility that i could have been right about Hectic or Chara when i was pushing them, when the only added information during those progression shifts was a psyche flip. If there's a player that has been taking the easy route over all days so far, it's Nacho. D1 lynch asriel/spare hectic, d2 spare hectic and nothing else, d3 nothing but endorse a farkran lynch, d4 directly pushing a farkran lynch.
I also don't really like Amrun recently, d3 eod was... not what i would expect from her, but Amrun looks like the only player who is genuinely
looking for
scum in this game rather than just tunneling on her first impressions, if you know what i mean. She has been wrong every single time, i think she is wrong on bingle too, but she's not scummy. I don't know why she wouldn't admit scum!Hectic though, i am starting to think that everyone is ignoring the matter just because they don't want to admit they're wrong on it - which could be said about me too, but at least i am pushing a theory that would fit with the gamestate and not go against it. I have yet to hear an explanation as of why nobody opposed Hectic's spare except for me and flipped town (Chemist).
