BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Venus and Mars]

HMMMMM
espe was my top guess for cosmic's identity

tinfoil:
GB and conspire are scum, and espe has been posting in scum pt on main

-x

That fucked over one scum slot in HP, I remember.

[GeorgeBailey]

Something completely went over some people’s heads. lmfao

Yeah, I'm talking about our maple leafs of course.

It's in our flag.

[Venus and Mars]

When I saw Wooper replace in:

Not worse than Corona though.

Does Corona make your tootsies hurt?

[Michael Scott]

BTW - Volxen will be busy af for a couple of weeks at least, treat any unsigned posts which aren't walls as Auro.

[Venus and Mars]

Something completely went over some people’s heads. lmfao

Yeah, I'm talking about our maple leafs of course.

It's in our flag.

I knew it! Maple syrup always gets me patriotic and hungry.

[Michael Scott]

Does Corona make your tootsies hurt?

Yeah, I'll have to make a trip to Crentist the Dentist sometime soon.

[GeorgeBailey]

Hugs, not drugs, kids.

[Conspire]

I don't buy it. What are you hiding, George?

-Cosmic

My role lets me know people's main.

/s

I knew it. But I bet you didn't expect us to be a redirector, did you? I now know

your

main.

Spoiler:

It's been a while, ducky.

-Cosmic

[Venus and Mars]

What about my 230?

About your Vecna read:

1.

Where did you get the impression that something's been hinted to Vecna which he isn't letting on?

2.

Also, what makes you say Boon wouldn't have a miller plague? He likes doing funky stuff regarding investigatives; his last game had a universal-investigative-enabler.

Bolded to seperate.

1. Not including his slight-at-best role claim in 189 (linked for ease to find), he hinted in 178 and again in 199 that HE thought that Boon was implying there's more to his role. Hinting and not outright saying what a role does in and of itself is bastard and, while these setups are known to be a little whacky with their own set of Boon roles to have as options, this game is very different. It wasn't advertised as bastard so it goes without saying that nothing in our roles should be unexplained regardless of Boon's tendency to use "strange"/Boon roles. Vecna knows what his role does, he just isn't openly admitting it.

2. I was in the last game and wouldn't be surprised if someone got juvenile delinquent. But that vs a quasi-randomly parsed out plague that, once it starts, simply cannot be stopped are leagues different IMO. One cripples cop and cop-like roles. I wouldn't be surprised if this virus did more than millerize. I'm well aware that Vecna stated we can chain it to the same two people; however, I don't fully believe he's being completely honest to begin with. So it isn't a stretch to me that all of a sudden keeping it to those that are already infected isn't actually a legitimate option. And lynching him tomorrow for that is too little too late as it'll continue two-by-two down the line until the end of the game.

No thanks.

Chk is making some decent points here and I think it could possibly be a mistake to ignore them. Vecna needs to make it much more clear exactly what we’re dealing with. He claims his role could be protown. Is that what he was alleging in his “17 layers of awesome” post or possibly something that may come back to bite us?

[Michael Scott]

Didn't The Fonz also say there was some hidden/unexplained part in his role?

[Venus and Mars]

I don't buy it. What are you hiding, George?

-Cosmic

My role lets me know people's main.

/s

I don't buy it. What are you hiding, George?

-Cosmic

My role lets me know people's main.

/s

I knew it. But I bet you didn't expect us to be a redirector, did you? I now know

your

main.

Spoiler:

It's been a while, ducky.

-Cosmic

What? Is this a troll or something?

[Michael Scott]

Spoiler: Full Roleclaim

[Venus and Mars]

Didn't The Fonz also say there was some hidden/unexplained part in his role?

Eh, I think this is a reasonable twist on a juvenile delinquent; instead of potentially disabling all cops N1, it slowly removes cop abilities from the thread. And it makes sense for it to be a penalty you can remove, but it costs you a town lynch. It's also possible that certain roles are immune;

my own role has a modifier whose in game effect is explicitly unknown, so I'm guessing there may be other unexplained modifiers out there, one of which might confer immunity

.

So, you think there could possibly be some actual benefit to Vecna’s role?

[Michael Scott]

At least if not a benefit, something to neutralize / something that makes it not as bad as it seems?
Because I feel claiming it gives him ++town equity and why lynch a townslot because we fear it?

[Titus]

Who the crap is this? Is this another Elsa Jay/Bambi Jay situation?

[Titus]

VOTE: Vecna

Not 100% sure I agree with this policy lynch given who is pushing it but I can't refute the logic behind it either. Therefore, Drunk Titus will plug her nose and vote.

[Krazy Katz]

Drunk Titus, who do you dislike that's pushing vecna?

-K

[Conspire]

Page 17:

• 414:
  Dave's post was made what looked like during a catchup. So the fact others have mentioned it doesn't
  Though, I did just go look at Dave's posts from during that time, and it was just that one post he commented on during that "catchup". Fair point.
  
• 419 is again scummy. I don't get these hypothesises and they come across as unnatural. Someone tell me if this is a NAI playstyle thing.
  
• Haven't wrapped my head fully around the argument Mars/Chronos are having but Chronos town from tone.

Page 18:

• Mars town from meta.

People are so rude to giraffes. This is what a google search for "majestic giraffe" yields:

Spoiler:

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

What? Is this a troll or something?

I prefer the term

trickster

.

-Cosmic

[Michael Scott]

Titus, no strongish scumreads?

[Michael Scott]

The Fonz, what do you think about Mechanic?

[Titus]

Drunk Titus, who do you dislike that's pushing vecna?

-K

Chkflip.

I know people say I'm crazy there but I find it odd the Vecna push happens just after that.

[Michael Scott]

VOTE: Kakegurui Addicts

[Krazy Katz]

Chkflip.

I know people say I'm crazy there but I find it odd the Vecna push happens just after that.

if you don't like chkflip why not just push chkflip instead of saying "oh mang don't like the wagon in response to chkflip mangg"

-K

[Conspire]

1. Not including his slight-at-best role claim in 189 (linked for ease to find), he hinted in 178 and again in 199 that HE thought that Boon was implying there's more to his role. Hinting and not outright saying what a role does in and of itself is bastard and, while these setups are known to be a little whacky with their own set of Boon roles to have as options, this game is very different. It wasn't advertised as bastard so it goes without saying that nothing in our roles should be unexplained regardless of Boon's tendency to use "strange"/Boon roles. Vecna knows what his role does, he just isn't openly admitting it.

This is a good point.

Vecna, I'd like to hear exactly what gives you the impression that Boon is suggesting there's more to how the role functions. Paraphrase please.

-Cosmic