BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Conspire]

Their entrance to the game and then their ISO 3 post calling everyone morons. The roleplay feels like it's coming from a place of fun instead of a place of "I need a bullshit filter so I'm not scumread".

I agree with this. Their play in Alisae vs Pine felt more like they were fake frustrated/annoyed, and Dunn was very whiney (for lack of a better word). He seems different here.

-Cosmic

Too many pronouns. Can you repeat this post replacing he and their with the actual names? I am not sure who Dunn is.

If I'm not mistaken, Dunnstral is Yumeko from Kakeguri Addicts, and was Kaito from from the Maki and Kaito hydra from Alisae Vs. Pine.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

1. Not including his slight-at-best role claim in 189 (linked for ease to find), he hinted in 178 and again in 199 that HE thought that Boon was implying there's more to his role. Hinting and not outright saying what a role does in and of itself is bastard and, while these setups are known to be a little whacky with their own set of Boon roles to have as options, this game is very different. It wasn't advertised as bastard so it goes without saying that nothing in our roles should be unexplained regardless of Boon's tendency to use "strange"/Boon roles. Vecna knows what his role does, he just isn't openly admitting it.

This is a good point.

Vecna, I'd like to hear exactly what gives you the impression that Boon is suggesting there's more to how the role functions. Paraphrase please.

-Cosmic

Mind answering this please, Vecna?

-Cosmic

[Michael Scott]

Ooh so I was right about Dunnstral! Nice.

[Michael Scott]

I don't think it's a coincidence that Vecna is claiming to have got an item at the halfway mark in the day

What's your implication?

[Conspire]

Wow, over 3 town wins? I didn't know we were dealing with a pro.

Exactly. I'm surprised no one's pushed to policy lynch us out of fear yet.

Dislike Krazy Katz' reasoning for voting Vecna on page 57. Do people forget that Vecna can simply target Krazy Katz (a miller), and another person who is a UTR (low check-priority), and those two can be leashed to targetting each other on future nights?

JJH is suddenly looking better since his thoughts on this Vecna lynch are identical to mine.

Vecna's blatant apathy towards his wagon is....

I think how he's acting is par for the course. He was dealt an incredibly anti-town role, he claimed said role because it's optimal to do so, and now has an uphill battle of trying to convince people not to lynch him because he's town nonetheless. It's demoralising.

-Cosmic

[Krazy Katz]

Were you town or scum in avp cosmic?

[Conspire]

vecna you need to claim the pro town power you alluded to
game is stalled and i dont think significant wagons are gonna be possible until we answer "is vecna the d1 play"

Vecna, I'd like to hear exactly what gives you the impression that Boon is suggesting there's more to how the role functions. Paraphrase please.

the conspire question is pretty good. ill try to answer without breaking the rules.

I pmd the mod a bunch of questions.

one was: Do infected people need to pass on the virus once, or every consecutive night.

The mod answered something like: They only pass it along the following night, and for as far as you can tell thatll be the only spread. but there might be more to it that I cannot go into.

It seemed like a pretty weird reply to me since it alluded to extra info without me asking for it.

Oh, sorry, you already this, Vecna. Interesting.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

Were you town or scum in avp cosmic?

I'm not giving clues to my main just yet! I won't confirm or deny whether I was in that game in the first place.

-Cosmic

[Krazy Katz]

You were obviously in that game and there's like maybe 4 people you can be

[Conspire]

I suggest he doesn't answer that and he should absolutely be considered townie for not answering it.

VOTE: GeorgeBailey

Jesus that's blatant.

How is this blatant?

Vecna and I weren't on the same page. Such is life

VOTE: BTE

Mind explaining what page you were on?

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

At the top of page 63. Will catch up on rest later.

This is the best place I can see right now to place my vote:

VOTE: Davesaz

You were obviously in that game and there's like maybe 4 people you can be

-Cosmic

[Krazy Katz]

Its dumb to try to remain stealth when you start discussing meta

[Conspire]

Its dumb to try to remain stealth when you start discussing meta

Yeah, probably should've thought that one though a little more. Let's keep this on the down low please if you've figured me out lol.

Please brace yourself for Esper's grand return.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

Thanks for the introduction, Cosmic! Got up to page 30 of the boon game (skimmed a lot though). Chronos is my strongest townread from whatever happened back there (posts seem natural, can understand their push + extra: they seem very self aligned from everyone else's reactions). Titus/Jjh/Venus+mars look scummy. I feel like I'm wrong on at least one of them though because I'm not familiar with their playstyles (Post #738 seems genuine). Don't want to lynch Vecna. I thought about their role being third party/scum, but it really wouldn't make sense for them to shoot themselves in the foot like that against their wincon. Maybe the plague won't be so bad.

~Esper

p-edit: oh wow

[Krazy Katz]

Bte is bef? Tell me you're town with a straight face and I'll unvote.

Rce would you make the exact same play as scum two games in a row?

[davesaz]

At the top of page 63. Will catch up on rest later.

This is the best place I can see right now to place my vote:

VOTE: Davesaz

You were obviously in that game and there's like maybe 4 people you can be

-Cosmic

If you read 1540 and think I'm scum then...

VOTE: Conspire

[Conspire]

At the top of page 63. Will catch up on rest later.

This is the best place I can see right now to place my vote:

VOTE: Davesaz

You were obviously in that game and there's like maybe 4 people you can be

-Cosmic

If you read 1540 and think I'm scum then...

VOTE: Conspire

Why should I think you're town for backing down on a read which got you pushed by a couple of other people?

Why did you decide to vote us over the other people on your wagon?

-Cosmic

[Krazy Katz]

Thanks for the introduction, Cosmic! Got up to page 30 of the boon game (skimmed a lot though). Chronos is my strongest townread from whatever happened back there (posts seem natural, can understand their push + extra: they seem very self aligned from everyone else's reactions). Titus/Jjh/Venus+mars look scummy. I feel like I'm wrong on at least one of them though because I'm not familiar with their playstyles (Post #738 seems genuine). Don't want to lynch Vecna. I thought about their role being third party/scum, but it really wouldn't make sense for them to shoot themselves in the foot like that against their wincon. Maybe the plague won't be so bad.

~Esper

p-edit: oh wow

LOL ok not sure how to guess this head. Maybe new player? who has not played with nancy titus or jjh hmmmmm

[Krazy Katz]

'maybe the plague won't be so bad' said trump

[davesaz]

Why should I think you're town for backing down on a read which got you pushed by a couple of other people?

Why did you decide to vote us over the other people on your wagon?

This should not need explanation.
IDGAF about being "pushed".
I had a conversation with Vecna and changed my mind.
You came in after seeing that conversation. SR me for that is fake, where earlier suspicions were misguided but reasonable given how my lack of time to play made it look.

[Krazy Katz]

what's dave at?

[Conspire]

Why should I think you're town for backing down on a read which got you pushed by a couple of other people?

Why did you decide to vote us over the other people on your wagon?

This should not need explanation.
IDGAF about being "pushed".
I had a conversation with Vecna and changed my mind.
You came in after seeing that conversation. SR me for that is fake, where earlier suspicions were misguided but reasonable given how my lack of time to play made it look.

Why can't scum!you simply backtrack on a read that was getting you scumread? I fail to understand why you expect me to think you're town for 1540.

Do you enjoy playing scum or town more, Dave?

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

who has not played with nancy titus or jjh hmmmmm

Can confirm that this is the case.

-Cosmic

[RCEnigma]

Bte is bef? Tell me you're town with a straight face and I'll unvote.

Rce would you make the exact same play as scum two games in a row?

Blatantly yes.