Newbie 1992 | Game Over

[Karnage]

Vote Count 1.8

team rocket queen (2) ~

Datisi, skitter30,

Datisi (1) ~

team rocket queen,

Not voting (6) ~

Marashu, UnhealthyKids, GeneralWu, Maduisha, clidd, Menalque,

With 9 alive it's 5 to lynch

Deadline: (expired on 2020-03-27 19:08:54)

V/LA:

• skitter30 - Fridays and Saturdays

[Datisi]

datisi immediately saying i die for it still feels off to me.

Nah
My thoughts were
Either you're scum doing an extremely shitty push or you're Town who we can't trust to make any sort ot objective decision in the later, more important days if THAT case is something you believe in
So it's a win win

This was partly influenced by emotion but I'm not sure if I've walked away from that completely rn

Because the last post by Marashu, which had words but didn't say anything really doesn't make me feel better about them

But I'm still torn between voting for either of you
So

[clidd]

Hum.

I need to analyze the TRQ's ISO to understand her point of view.

[Datisi]

Tried?

[Maduisha]

So, Datisi is playing with two people that know how he plays. Even if he's legit upset, don't you think scum would try to cover that up, especially if those people that know him are aware that he usually doesn't get upset like that when he's playing town?

i got the sense from menalque and datisi that datisi doesn't get this upset as either alignment and is more likely to do so as town, so why would scum hide that?

What you said before is that scum can get legit upset if they get a vote on themselves from an accusation with the "wrong logic". So that's why I said that scum in his place would try to hide that genuine emotion, as it's subject to be mistaken as emotional manipulation (like it was here by Menal), which can look scummy on their part, even if it makes people unvote. Town!Datisi is more likely to get his feelings out without thinking about the consequences of doing so, is what I'm trying to say.

[Datisi]

It's more or less wifom. "scum would show it to look like town" vs "scum wouldn't show it to not get caught trying to emotionally manipulate".

Have you gotten any new reads other than GW/me? (sorry if you already said and i missed)

[Maduisha]

Yes, I have moved to TR you for reasons I gave in post 452, while my TL on GW hasn't been updated. I don't like that he started talking about things he will do later, because that throws me back to the game I played with him in which he was scum and kept saying thing like that to pad the thread with his posts and make it seem like he's present when he's not. But everything will be okay as long as he fulfills the promise of coming back when he has more time. He also asked for a summary, which I don't know how to interpret. Still a TL, will wait to see if he reads it all and brings post that are more related to the game itself and less to his real life schedule.

Everybody else stays null.

I want to be cautious about Clidd specifically because I'm not sure if he's his usual game-solving mentality Clidd, or if he's trying to pocket the ones that have already played with him, but I don't read him as anything at the moment.

[Datisi]

do you usually get reads this ~slowly~? bc we're 20 pages in, and i find having 2 reads (and no sls) is kinda low? especially with 6 people not voting

[Maduisha]

Well, I don't read people as leaning scum right now, but I think I have expressed which behaviors are worrying me so far. Clidd, who I'm not sure if he's pocketing or not. Menalque who appealed to emotions after stating that he felt uncomfortable due to potential emotional manipulation from you. And the TRQ bit in which I feel like she's trying to make you doubt Skitt, but she already corrected me and her weird accusation makes me think she's town, so I don't think I'll try to dig deeper into that.

[Maduisha]

I only have a game of experience over here, so I don't really know what is "usual" for me in term of reading speed... and that one game was particularly different because I made day 1 end pretty quickly, and my reads were based on behavior before/after lynch on the next few days. I think I read scum in that game in a reactionary way, if that makes sense. It almost costed us the game, which I agree is pretty yikes.

[Datisi]

can I just say dats that if you have faked this then I think I might need a break from playing games with you for a while

Menal also got my attention here because he made a comment of this nature after commenting that he's uncomfortable because Datisi's post felt like emotional manipulation, yet he's appealing to emotions here too right after that. Feels like an emotional response to justify the unvote (if he needed said justification). Unless I'm misunderstanding the tone, which is entirely possible.

this post is your thoughts on menal right? do you think he's scummy because of it or?

[Maduisha]

I think it's a strange post considering what he said before, that's all. I don't think it's enough to SR him, as he likely posted it in the heat of the moment, too.

[Karnage]

Mod Note

word321 replaces UnhealthyKids.

[Menalque]

Good

[Menalque]

Are you scum, word?

[Menalque]

Maduisha is like the towniest slot in the game rn

[Menalque]

@dats do you think there’s any chance that maduisha is doing a you from 149?

[Menalque]

1949*

[skitter30]

Actually VOTE: marashu

1949 is the one i modded with scum!datisi?

[Menalque]

Actually VOTE: marashu

1949 is the one i modded with scum!datisi?

Yeah

[Datisi]

Maduisha is like the towniest slot in the game rn

can i get a tldr from your pov

@dats do you think there’s any chance that maduisha is doing a you from 149?

ehhh... maybe? i'm generally not keen on townlocking people on day 1 unless i'm really frikking sure
and given no prior experience w madu and their comment that did make me go hmmm I'm not there yet
like for now i do think they're town
but like
it's not set in stone

mena are you still reading skitt town?

[Menalque]

VOTE: marashu

[Menalque]

I still think skitt is town, yes

[Datisi]

then the game might not be as hell as i previously thought

[Menalque]

Maduisha just seems insanely earnest and like she’s actually thinking in the posts she’s made in the game

I really liked her calling me out for emotional manipulation bc I can see how it looks like that from the outside even tho it didn’t feel that way to me when I made that post because I was upset at the idea of you manipulating me, which in turn has made me sort of feel better about you