BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Venus and Mars]

Hostility and calling people assholes is toxic. Go read for yourself?

i will. link me?

No, look it up yourself. I wasted that game on him, I’ll be damned if I’ll do that here.

Last Boon game: To Boon or Not to Boon and that’s all of the undeservied attention that person is getting from me.

[Michael Scott]

I'm not going to paste quotes here and bring up that stuff, I don't think this is a productive discussion, and clearly it's best to stop talking about it given how Nancy feels about it.
Just go to page 180 of the game here https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... start=4550.
If you want to talk further, maybe later in postgame.

[chkflip]

Beat me to it but I'll post his ISO anyway since I went through the trouble, lol.

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go

[chkflip]

UNVOTE: Venus and Mars
VOTE: Vecna

Ol' Standby.

[sore feet]

I'm not going to paste quotes here and bring up that stuff, I don't think this is a productive discussion, and clearly it's best to stop talking about it given how Nancy feels about it.

im conflicted because i agree, but it would be remiss for me not to challenge it.
thanks for the links guys

[Michael Scott]

Chk, why not Dave?

[Venus and Mars]

I'm not going to paste quotes here and bring up that stuff, I don't think this is a productive discussion, and clearly it's best to stop talking about it given how Nancy feels about it.
Just go to page 180 of the game here https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... start=4550.
If you want to talk further, maybe later in postgame.

<3 Thank you.

Yeah, I really dislike Dave’s reasoning for voting Conspire. At least RCE is scumhunting even if he is dead wrong. Still. he should realize I’m town here. It’s uncharacteristic for him to be this bad at reading me. You should ISO me in that game. I was flaming obvscum. That’s why anyone thinking I’m playing at all similar to that game, completely blows my mind.

[chkflip]

I've very much eloquated my stance on dave, no?

I think he's town. I've never seen him be anything but what you're describing as why he's scum. Unless I'm missing something, I see what you see but am coming to a vastly different conclusion.

[Venus and Mars]

UNVOTE: Venus and Mars
VOTE: Vecna

Ol' Standby.

Are you voting Vecna because of his role or are you actually sr him?

[Venus and Mars]

Looney Toons

Vote Count 1.05

Vecna [6]:

Chkflip, BooneyToonzExpert, Titus, Davesaz, Krazy Katz, Venus and Mars

Mechanic [3]:

GeorgeBailey, sore feet, Chronos

Davesaz [2]:

The Fonz, Kakeguri Addicts

GeorgeBailey [1]:

Jjh927

BooneyToonzExpert [1]:

Michael Scott

Xtoxm [1]:

Vecna,

Titus [1]:

Conspire

Kakeguri Addicts [1]:

Nomnomnom,

Not Voting [1]:

Mechanic,

With

17

alive, it takes

9

to execute.

Day 1

ends in (expired on 2020-03-25 21:00:00) on

March 25th

.

Mod Notes:

Don’t be outta pocket.

Mechanics hasn’t posted in 4 days, I’m replacing the slot. I got a juicy replacement ready anyways.

We have almost 6 days to figure this out. I hate D1s.

[Michael Scott]

I took a look at your ISO and while you do agree he's lacking in content, you say that's his town game - have you seen him play scum before?
This sort of "do nothing much" style seems incredibly easy to stand behind.

[Venus and Mars]

@Davez, can you link one of your scumgames? Thanks.

[The Fonz]

Can someone ISO Kakeguri and tell me what they think? Reason being, I see their play specifically toward me as scummy, but am having a hard time parsing out how much of this is me feeling omgus.

[Michael Scott]

They're voting Davesaz, great

Their attack on you at the time was on the basis of you being called "underwhelming" by other people - that seems like a perfectly valid reason (at that time), why do you think that's scummy in particular?

I feel like they're underwhelming and Dunn's walls aren't that impressive, they're a good push by the same metric lol

[The Fonz]

They quoted me saying I was taking time out of the game for mental health reasons to ask me if I'd responded to people calling me underwhelming. I was obviously not going to respond because... I was taking time out for MH reasons, so it looked kinda fake.

It's also unclear how anyone can usefully respond to people calling them underwhelming. Like, I can absolutely see why people thought that, I was having trouble getting reads. The only way to change that is to get more into the game. Am I supposed to turn around and lie and say that I'm not having trouble getting into the game? Am I supposed to OMGUS people for not unreasonable reads? It feels like a trap question.

Also, if you read their justification, it's not "I feel Fonz is underwhelming." It's "Other people are saying Fonz is underwhelming." Which has that "Hiding behind other people's reasoning" aspect to it.

[chkflip]

UNVOTE: Venus and Mars
VOTE: Vecna

Ol' Standby.

Are you voting Vecna because of his role or are you actually sr him?

I took a look at your ISO and while you do agree he's lacking in content, you say that's his town game - have you seen him play scum before?
This sort of "do nothing much" style seems incredibly easy to stand behind.

Can someone ISO Kakeguri and tell me what they think? Reason being, I see their play specifically toward me as scummy, but am having a hard time parsing out how much of this is me feeling omgus.

Mental note to return here after some rest.

Kake does need to show the fuck up, though.

nom as well.

[Chronos]

Ah fuck 10 pages

[BooneyToonzExpert]

Something happened and a SECRET ROLE POWER was activated and I had to

immediately

send out 3 poisonous barbs to 3 players.

I was not told what they do and I was not allowed to talk about it until I chose the targets.

I thought about sending one to Titus but the word poisonous made me stop it as it could have a negative effect, again I have no idea what they do or if they can be passed along. I also do not know if it has a connection to Mod's mid-game announcement.

So I picked Vecna solely because of his claim and the other 2 were randomly chosen. So it's wait and see what happens with the barbs I guess.

[BooneyToonzExpert]

@BTE what is your current read on RCE? If you think he’s actually town, I’ll unvote him.

RCE is a slowburn with me. I think I would have a hard time changing reads on RCE once I commit, so I'd like to keep RCE null for now.

[Titus]

I am not sure if what to think of BTE. My gut instinct is anti-town play, lynch. Yet he claimed it when he could have coasted on it as it was a day event. Just an odd move overall that doesn't help his alignment, whatever it is.

[chkflip]

Yaaay more shit that'll probably be detrimental to town. Huzzah!

UNVOTE: Venus and Mars
VOTE: Vecna

Ol' Standby.

Are you voting Vecna because of his role or are you actually sr him?

My stance here hasn't changed. There's town+ in having part of his role around, but only if he's town, and it doesn't really outweigh the fact that he's still forcing a miller situation on us. His reaction to said push is borderline meh levels of actual involvement in the game beyond himself. I'm just not overly enthusiastic from a mech standpoint or a slot standpoint as of now. It

was

just policy to start but I'm actually scumreading him at this point.

I took a look at your ISO and while you do agree he's lacking in content, you say that's his town game - have you seen him play scum before?
This sort of "do nothing much" style seems incredibly easy to stand behind.

I haven't. He's an older guy, so it naturally makes sense to me that he doesn't get on as much or falls behind at times. I also see his progression in-game as coming off naturally because, as town, I've seen him do the OMGUS voting in several different games. Give this guy enough time and his reads will be very solid.

You know who I'm actually getting concerned about? KA. Eight posts in nine days is fucking abysmal. nomnomnom's ISO leaves a hell of a lot to be desired as well, especially considering all the promises to catch up with zero fucking follow through. At least dave is trying.

Can someone ISO Kakeguri and tell me what they think? Reason being, I see their play specifically toward me as scummy, but am having a hard time parsing out how much of this is me feeling omgus.

Yeahhh Idk. I was town reading them because it felt right, but the more they lurksack the more I become wary of falling back on shit reads like I like to do.

[chkflip]

Holy fence-sitting, Batman! Titus looks to be fence-sitting again!

Better pull out my anti-fence-sitting spray...

[BooneyToonzExpert]

I am not sure if what to think of BTE. My gut instinct is anti-town play, lynch. Yet he claimed it when he could have coasted on it as it was a day event. Just an odd move overall that doesn't help his alignment, whatever it is.

I didn’t choose yo send the barbs, I was obligated to do so immediately without being able to discuss it with anyone.

And if you are sour that I didn't send you something that is poisonous, then I don't know what to tell you.

We should wait to see what the barbs actually do before you pass judgement.

[davesaz]

You know who I'm actually getting concerned about? KA. Eight posts in nine days is fucking abysmal. nomnomnom's ISO leaves a hell of a lot to be desired as well, especially considering all the promises to catch up with zero fucking follow through. At least dave is trying.

I agree with this.

KA posting didn't seem necessarily bad as I was seeing it (that part of it that I can remember) but I think it's pretty underwhelming in general and not just volume.
I think nomnom had a lot more fight in TM. I do not have a scumgame to compare with.

[davesaz]

Why should I think you're town for backing down on a read which got you pushed by a couple of other people?

Why did you decide to vote us over the other people on your wagon?

This should not need explanation.
IDGAF about being "pushed".
I had a conversation with Vecna and changed my mind.
You came in after seeing that conversation. SR me for that is fake, where earlier suspicions were misguided but reasonable given how my lack of time to play made it look.

In reply to whomever it was that called my Conspire vote OMGUS. No, it's an actual SR. I think their SR on me is fake.