Newbie 1989 (Game over!)

[Atarashi Hajimari]

I think the answer is /probably/ still 72 but I don’t really like it

What don't you like?

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Just making sure we're on the same page

[72offsuit]

I think the answer is /probably/ still 72 but I don’t really like it

What don't you like?

Whatshesaid ^

What has changed to you not liking it? You seemed pretty keen yesterday.

[72offsuit]

Think I prefer Walrus over Elmo.
Rereading Elmo's ISO from the perspective of !townElmo makes sense.
I feel like I was confbiasing yesterday.
Elmo has more more scummy posts, but also has a few townie-vibe posts.
Conversely Walrus is pretty much null with a pinch of slightly scummy posts.

Stay tuned... beep-beep-beep-beep

[72offsuit]

I think scum is much more likely to lie in null,
as compared to a mix of scummy and townie vibe posts.

[72offsuit]

Overall find Elmo to be much more reckless and flow of consciousness, rambly sort of posts, which i think is more of a town-mindset - not giving a shit how you come off as, but more focussed on scumhunting.

Walrus' posts feel more calculated and planned, more agenda-based.

Could be a meta/posting style thing overall, but this indicator has worked for me more than its let me down

[Menalque]

We’re in a weird world

I looked at a bunch of newbies where scum was lynched on D1 and the overwhelming trend was for scum to be off wagon on D1

That’s not the case this game

When they were on wagon they were normally on at the end of the wagon but hmm

@people asking what I don’t like

[72offsuit]

terminology and abbreviations everyone is using here are foreign to me

What terms?

terms like: SSS, PoE, etc. and also how to read stuff like (term)!(term) -- I kinda guess based on the color coding, but not really sure how you're supposed to parse that. I think there were a few more things in the rules as I was skimming through them, but can't remember off the top of my head.

Hi all,

I've skimmed through the thread, and to be honest I feel pretty lost. I've played a few online mafia/werewolf games at another site, but this is my first game here, and the terminology and abbreviations everyone is using here are foreign to me, so I'll take a while to adjust I imagine.

Looking at the setup notes, it doesn't look like it's possible to have masons and another flavor of power townie in the game at the same time, or am I misunderstanding the table?

Off to a meeting, but will get back to re-reading over lunch.

1. I still find this playing-the-noob-card entrance post scummy
2. Might seem silly, but I find feeling the need to justify one's presence/absence scummy.

For the moment, I'll go with VOTE: Elmo TeH AzN: as others have pointed out, she seemed to get unduly flustered by Menalque's SR of her.

Not liking the "for the moment" wording. You can hardly genuinely build pressure on a scumtarget when you are letting them know ahead of time that its "only for the moment".

You're right of course, about it being bad that we've leaked information about the setup to the baddies. Now they know what sort of power townies they have to deal with, and will plan accordingly.

However, it didn't seem to me that you were reacting to the information leak, but rather to the fact that the finger was being pointed at you. I could possibly have misread though, I've been speed-reading/skimming everything to try and catch up. I'll go back and reread.[/quote]

Feels like fence sitting here. "Could possibly have a misread". Scummy as can later justify changing a "read" on Elmo from scum to town or vice versa as convenient later on.

Riddle me this. Why are we solving this game on day one?

Isn't the point of the game to solve it? Why wouldn't we start on day one?

Super serious tone to this post, which I find to be LAMISTY and thus scummy

In 765
So, where does a baddie stick their partner in this list? Along with himself, clidd, atarashi, wizened, icon, or with doobie, elmo, menalque?

Information instead of analysis. Looks like he is trying to appear to be scumhunting but does not actually state where he thinks Lotus/Lootz/Jorm would fit their scum partner on the "reads" list

[72offsuit]

We’re in a weird world

I looked at a bunch of newbies where scum was lynched on D1 and the overwhelming trend was for scum to be off wagon on D1

That’s not the case this game

When they were on wagon they were normally on at the end of the wagon but hmm

@people asking what I don’t like

as in, you looked into several newbie-level games?

[72offsuit]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... &start=775

Newbie 1978 post 778 - scum on wagon d1

[72offsuit]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... &start=700

Newbie 1973 post 702 - also 1 scum on wagon

[72offsuit]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... &start=750

Newbie 1965 - post 770 - 2 scum on wagon

[72offsuit]

thats 3/3 that ive checked, lol

[72offsuit]

what point are you trying to make anyways?

[72offsuit]

lolz 4/4

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... start=1225

Newbie 1961

[Menalque]

No, you misunderstand

I mean newbies where the D1 lynch was on scum specifically

[72offsuit]

oh.

[72offsuit]

Well still, what point are you trying to make?

[Menalque]

My point is that this game is weird because scum didn’t avoid the wagon D1 and I’m not sure what that means yet

[72offsuit]

That you;re scum?

[72offsuit]

VOTE: Walrus

[Atarashi Hajimari]

We never lynch Walrus.

VOTE: 72off

[Datisi]

~

[Datisi]

~

[Datisi]

~