Micro 930: Neon Mafia (Game over!)

[Chemist1422]

Obviously I’m gonna focus more on explaining my scumread than my townreads.

Why would not voting you give you pings when some players have barely posted? I mean yeah, I could have voted you, but Is it not also reasonable to wait until I have a read on everyone?

My townlean on Luca that I forgot to mention is gone

Why does this make you townread Luca less?

Second line felt like deflection to the lurking slots

Then you misunderstood the point as it had nothing to do with that.

I was stating that there was nothing wrong with not automatically voting a SL when:

A) she already has a couple of votes and I’d be putting her to L-2

B) a few players had barely posted, and I wanted to get a firmer grip on them before pushing a lynch.

Oh alright

[skitter30]

ok i don't think a post-by-post is going to happen and i want to get caught up, so just key thoughts as i read through.

- while i think nom's part of the argument was p bad, i think that at least some of the things luca is scumreading her for is nai; the 1v1 i can see her doing as either alignment, and unfortunately some of the ate too
the stuff she brought up about me was weird tho

- the luca wagon was p bad imo, and i think that quag's vote was one of the worst, as was his reaction to the claim / lack of unvote

- i believe luca's claim

- @nom (382). neap with a neighborhood makes a lot of sense, precisely because it gives false positives and that's in vogue these days. i'd actually expect there to be scum in {furret/nom} given neap. or if not at least one scum has some kind of pr to give scum a way to hide behind a truthful claim. i don't super like that you're shading the claim in this way. also if he's scum fake-claiming, what, scum were informed that there's a neighborhood? so he knew to fake-claim nea? and why'd he fake-claim nea at that point and not some other pr? also i think the macho bit makes it more likely to be true, and not less

- i'm having a lot of trouble getting anything out of luca vs nom round 2 and 3

- @quag, why did your unvote of luca come in 491 and not when he first claimed?

- i'm not sure that looker's luca vote in 515 comes from scum

- aldu's catchup is p icky

thru bottom of page 21 ^

[Chemist1422]

TR: Luca Blight
TL: nomnomnom, Captain the Furret, skitter30
Null: Quagsire
SL: Alduskkel,
SR: Chemist1422, Looker

After reading through once, I think this is pretty much where my reads are.
I found myself agreeing a lot with Luca's plays, but I don't find nom particularly scummy.
As for Chemist and Looker, I think Looker is scummy for reasons stated above, and Chemist for his predecessor, Heaven.

VOTE: Chemist1422

What did my predecessor do to make my slot scummy to you

Lurk? Because I think I've done a decent job of making up for that

[Chemist1422]

I think I would probably switch Looker and Aldus in my reads

rest are still fine

[skitter30]

My impression is that nom has been somewhat emotional/confrontational which has attracted votes but I don't think there's scum motive. Why try to provoke Luca into a 1v1 instead of deflecting? In a Luca vs. nom battle I think Luca is more likely to win and I think nom knows that as scum. As town, if she thinks Luca's scum then it might be an uphill battle but at least she's pursuing scum.

i think she's fully capable of forcing the 1v1 as either alignment and i'm not sure she thinks that luca is liable to win if she's scum

[skitter30]

I really don’t understand her vote on me, though

yeah i think it's too lolrandom to come from scum there; like lolvoting a pr claim once it's been p accepted for little gain is not really something scum do most of the time; there's no way he thinks it actually gains traction there

[skitter30]

I felt like people were ignoring him but the wagons he jumped on always made it to L-1/L-2 (Heaven, Luca). I don't remember Heaven; you've been gone for a while. I probably thought he was lurking on purpose.

i literally don't remember his early play beyond for the obnoxious gif pokeomon things
but he had several things i disliked while i was catching up

[skitter30]

oh and heaven i was townreading because his tone felt ridiculously different in comparison to his last scumgame wherein i caught him on tone. i think he's probably town for that
i don't know who the new!heaven is

[skitter30]

hey skitter

hey

[Luca Blight]

It’s not that I don’t believe Nom would 1v1 as Town, it’s that she would 1v1 over such poor reasoning.

[Captain the Furret]

I just noticed GiF edited a vig button in that image I linked lmao

[skitter30]

i think she believed what she was posting she would, beacuse she fundementally would disagree that the reasoning was poor
now whether or not she actually believes most of her argument against you is a different story

[skitter30]

As for Chemist and Looker, I think Looker is scummy for reasons stated above, and Chemist for his predecessor, Heaven.

VOTE: Chemist1422

wrong

[skitter30]

2. I don't scumread Luca, catching up, one post I really liked was:

this gives me townpings on george ^

i don't especially agree with george's readslist tho

[Captain the Furret]

HEY SKITTER

[Captain the Furret]

Why isn’t quagsire dead yet ;~;

[skitter30]

Chancellor Alduskkel. Catching scum lords is my speciality.

This particularly was right after he was being brought up to L-2.

i don't see it? why does this make thier reaction to the wagon seem bad to you?

[skitter30]

i'm very likely going to be voting there but let me just finish reading to get into like ~real-time~ again

[Captain the Furret]

Ur already voting it I think

[Captain the Furret]

Also I like aldusk atm

[Captain the Furret]

I think he is trying to solve and is trying to understand my motivations.
Basically, the sun has me pocketted atm.

[skitter30]

Ur already voting it I think

oh lol
i haven't been here in a while sorry

i don't really have any thoughts on aldu

[skitter30]

ok i'm caught up
i will admit to having skimmed some pages tho, esp. pages with nom v luca or large obnoxious images/gifs

i'm roughly hereabouts:

{luca}
{new!heaven (chemist?)}
{george, looker}
{aldu, furret} - null
{nom}
{quag}

[skitter30]

yep i'm on quag already

can people start consolidating wagons? we're starting to get close-ish to deadline

[Captain the Furret]

Yeah ok
Our reads are basically similar