Mini Normal 2128: Normal Mafia - Game Over!

[SirCakez]

Votecount 1.10

Espressojet (3) - Espressojet, Titus, iDanyboy
Madoka (3) - TheTrollie, Morning Tweet, Cat Scratch Fever
iDanyboy (1) - BBmolla
TheTrollie (1) - geraintm
mavsfan41 (1) - Allomancer

Not voting (4) - Bambi Jay, bob3141, Madoka, mavsfan41

(expired on 2020-04-06 10:34:00) remain until day end

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to reach a majority.

[Morning Tweet]

I dont think scum actualy push a mason claim. Thst something ive realy only seen town do.

now I don't usually agree with bob, but he's right here; mavs is town

[Titus]

VOTE: iDanyboy

Wagonomics guess.

[TheTrollie]

madoka - i like ur last post. thats the first post I've liked from ur slot the whole game actually.

What are your reads? Are you ready to place a vote?

Hi Titus!

[BBmolla]

What do you think it is, BB?

Meh. Unsure. Leaning town atm.

Real quick, someone said they were town reading CSF, why?

@BBmola: was it your decision to full claim at the time you did or did you discuss this?

My own, I didn't tell her. It's not an optimal decision but it saves us about four to five days of me defending myself.

VOTE: iDanyboy

Wagonomics guess.

nice

[Espressojet]

Any big disagreement with my list or something anyone want to discuss

I can't tell if I love or hate this post

What do you think is to love or hate about it?

It reads very over-eager to me

I don't see iDanyBoy being read anywhere near neutral this game

Anyone who reads otherwise, I'd be wary of

[Espressojet]

I'm having trouble forming a read on him.

Is that my fault, or yours?

[Morning Tweet]

VOTE: iDanyboy

Wagonomics guess.

been a while titus!!

Any big disagreement with my list or something anyone want to discuss

It

(above)

reads very over-eager to me

I don't see iDanyBoy being read anywhere near neutral this game

Anyone who reads otherwise, I'd be wary of

I think, given how people have been scumreading iDany for lurking tendencies, this is his way of saying "I was open to having a discussion" at that point in time. NAI in my opinion

[Espressojet]

People are scumreading Dany for lurking tendencies?

[Espressojet]

That doesn't sound like a strong day 1 lynch priority

[Titus]

Was Dany bussing you?

[Morning Tweet]

People are scumreading Dany for lurking tendencies?

That doesn't sound like a strong day 1 lynch priority

maybe not exactly scumreading but I can recall it being mentioned a lot. I don't really disagree w/ u on that, since iDany typically posts infrequently as both alignments

[TheTrollie]

Any big disagreement with my list or something anyone want to discuss

I can't tell if I love or hate this post

What do you think is to love or hate about it?

It reads very over-eager to me

I don't see iDanyBoy being read anywhere near neutral this game

Anyone who reads otherwise, I'd be wary of

I'm neutral on iDanny

[Espressojet]

Was Dany bussing you?

Whombst?

Also, welcome in!

[geraintm]

What do you think it is, BB?

Meh. Unsure. Leaning town atm.

Real quick, someone said they were town reading CSF, why?

@BBmola: was it your decision to full claim at the time you did or did you discuss this?

My own, I didn't tell her. It's not an optimal decision but it saves us about four to five days of me defending myself.

VOTE: iDanyboy

Wagonomics guess.

nice

this post seems like it has interesting content

[iDanyboy]

I really think that only Scum-Skell could have interpreted my post the same way you are, iDanny. I don't buy that town-skell would make that same misinterpretation if she was scumreading Allo.

Why couldn't the post come from town Skell, when you know I see it the same way but you don't think I'm scum for it.

[Titus]

Was Dany bussing you?

Whombst?

Also, welcome in!

Why are you spending so much effort defending a slot voting you?

[TheTrollie]

I really think that only Scum-Skell could have interpreted my post the same way you are, iDanny. I don't buy that town-skell would make that same misinterpretation if she was scumreading Allo.

Why couldn't the post come from town Skell, when you know I see it the same way but you don't think I'm scum for it.

Because you werent scum-reading allo.

[iDanyboy]

I really think that only Scum-Skell could have interpreted my post the same way you are, iDanny. I don't buy that town-skell would make that same misinterpretation if she was scumreading Allo.

Why couldn't the post come from town Skell, when you know I see it the same way but you don't think I'm scum for it.

Because you werent scum-reading allo.

Because if Skell was town with a legit scumread on Allo, then when she got to my post that says "yeah Allo has some townie looking posts but they don't strike me as especially hard to fake," TOWN-Skell would have to have AGREED with that completely. Because if she was scumreading allo, then she has to also agree that any townie looking posts are fabricated from scum-allo. The reason I think that slot is scum is becuase scum-Skell, with a fake-scumread on Allo would know Allo is town, and then pounce on my post saying "What makes you think Allo is faking"

I feel like we're going in circles, but this is the part that doesn't make sense with me, she can agree with you that the town tells are fake but asking why you feel he is scummy is to find out if you have a valid reasoning or your making it up because you already know the alignments.

[Espressojet]

Was Dany bussing you?

Whombst?

Also, welcome in!

Why are you spending so much effort defending a slot voting you?

...

Have I been defending iDany?

[Espressojet]

Also, hold up, why should that even be a problem?

I just spent a whole game with Gera and I being tunneled to oblivion by a person we townread

You just got here, why are you trying to throw some heavy scumbuddy accusations this way

Post 452 makes me believe you either haven't read the thread yet, or don't intend to

[SirCakez]

Prodding Bambi Jay

[TheTrollie]

I really think that only Scum-Skell could have interpreted my post the same way you are, iDanny. I don't buy that town-skell would make that same misinterpretation if she was scumreading Allo.

Why couldn't the post come from town Skell, when you know I see it the same way but you don't think I'm scum for it.

Because you werent scum-reading allo.

Because if Skell was town with a legit scumread on Allo, then when she got to my post that says "yeah Allo has some townie looking posts but they don't strike me as especially hard to fake," TOWN-Skell would have to have AGREED with that completely. Because if she was scumreading allo, then she has to also agree that any townie looking posts are fabricated from scum-allo. The reason I think that slot is scum is becuase scum-Skell, with a fake-scumread on Allo would know Allo is town, and then pounce on my post saying "What makes you think Allo is faking"

I feel like we're going in circles, but this is the part that doesn't make sense with me, she can agree with you that the town tells are fake but asking why you feel he is scummy is to find out if you have a valid reasoning or your making it up because you already know the alignments.

Totally. Everything you said is true. But it's a strawman - the way you describe her actions is incorrect. She wasn't "finding out if I had valid reasoning" for "why I feel he is scummy" and she didn't "agree that the town tells are fake."

She specifically picked out my response to BB where I argued against his claim that allo was obvs-town, and seems to indicate that she

does not

or at least has questions as to whether the allo posts are authentically town or not:

Allo is town homeboys

I agree he has some townie posts but i think all of his towntells are easily fabricated.

Just because they are easily fabricated doesn't necessarily mean they are. Since you are voting him I assume you think they are fabricated, so what makes you think so that scum!Allo is faking his towntells here?

If the above post was more like the situation you articulated above, I wouldn't have had a problem with it. The part that makes it scummy is that it didn't go down as you described it. I'm not making a case in 106 for scum-allo, I'm defending my vote by saying that allo having townie looking posts is not inconsistent with my read on him as scum, because they could just as easily have been scum faking town.

tl;dr

106 says:

"It is possible to believe that scum-Allo would be making the same posts that you all are reading as town."

To question the legitimacy of that take is inconsistent with a player who is, in their next post, going to vote allo. If you are going to vote allo, you also MUST agree with 106, and Skell's 121 shows that she's not fully on board.

[Bambi Jay]

Did you have to prod me with the super pointy stick? Ouch.

And is it just me or am I seeing someone who wasn't here before? Was Titus here at the beginning or replaced in? Dang I gotta reread this game.

[Bambi Jay]

Since I don't wanna read too much RN on this game imma just blatantly sheep Titus. She knows what she's doing.

But I checked to be safe and it wasn't her who voted.

I'll keep in touch again and whatnot. Or maybe I'm gonna get bailed out. I dunno.