who am i townreading that i shouldn't be?In post 2897, Eddie Cane wrote:Yes. And I think wagoning you is pro town while your lynch pool is generally people I lean town.In post 2895, northsidegal wrote:you really think i could be scum, eddie?
>I think you said that about Oka also. I feel like saying that during the opening before actually reading is slightly scummy, yeah. I think it was a response to my asking you to scumread Alch -- which negates it somewhat -- but still.In post 2892, northsidegal wrote:unreadability of who? i said that i've found alchemist hard to read historically. is that scummy?
why are my thoughts as to schadd's setup philosophy more likely to come from scum? don't you think that if i wanted to use mechanical analysis as a way to avoid talking about reads or a way to get townread, i would actually make a specific effort to come to some conclusion?
i didn't offer an early lynch pool – literally the opposite. i had an early group of townreads, and it was an offhand comment that if i were correct in all of them, it would give a 50% chance of hitting scum in the rest of them. the idea that that's early preparation for mislynches is a little absurd.
i've never once thought that cop checking me was a good idea, and i think that my logic for that tracks pretty well? everyone knows that they're town, the only benefit to someone checking you is that everyone else would presumably know that as well. that isn't an advantage if you think it can happen anyways without the check, though.
I don't think it's explicit preparation for mislynches, more preparation to acknowledge that you can be wrong, if that makes sense. As town I don't know if you'd feel the need to do that. 
rcenigma's replacementIn post 2902, Eddie Cane wrote:If I was scum this game, assuming I have no partners, who do you think I'd fear the most this game?
Whoever guesses first try wins a prize
I think Comical is town. At least I think that's a fine starting point to gamesolve. If you're not willing to lynch either of us today, why not operate under that assumption for a while and solve?In post 2898, Eddie Cane wrote:I think if I knew Comical and Auro's alignment I could solve this game.
To be fair if you were a slot known for having more accurate reads than most would you want to get BoP'd every game, every lynch?In post 2901, Auro wrote:more preparation to acknowledge that you can be wrong
FirebringerIn post 2902, Eddie Cane wrote:If I was scum this game, assuming I have no partners, who do you think I'd fear the most this game?
Whoever guesses first try wins a prize
But as scum driving lynches you're guaranteed to get pushed for them.In post 2905, Alchemist21 wrote:To be fair if you were a slot known for having more accurate reads than most would you want to get BoP'd every game, every lynch?
In post 2900, northsidegal wrote:who am i townreading that i shouldn't be?In post 2897, Eddie Cane wrote:Yes. And I think wagoning you is pro town while your lynch pool is generally people I lean town.In post 2895, northsidegal wrote:you really think i could be scum, eddie?
why should i be townreading you, auro, alchemist or idany?
I know this isnt a good answer, but it's the answer. Your luna and oka strong trs make it hard for me to find a world with you as town. I know I'm town. Auro is leaning town (sorry Alch -if hes mafia he is an ally atm). Alch is leaning town. iDany is fine, although if Comical is town hes probably town. And the auro/alch independent reads dont matter, because they arent theatering, so there is a max of 1 scum there.In post 2886, Eddie Cane wrote:There is quite literally not one slot I feel super good about being town, which is a bit of a puzzler.In post 2881, Comical wrote:Eddie, i feel scum are taking us on, and literally throwing stuff and nonsense at us, but i can’t tell where it’s coming from, but now that I’m taking a step away from it, both of us are being played with by scum somewhere
This helps me know I'm not completely crazy.In post 2910, Eddie Cane wrote:Though even though I independently town lean both auro and alch, I will stipulate it doesnt feel like a TvT argument.
OTLIn post 2909, northsidegal wrote:I don't strongly townread Luna
You believe they're definitely aligned, no?In post 2909, northsidegal wrote:I don't strongly townread Luna. I don't townread either of Comical or RCE, I just think that it doesn't make sense to lynch either of them today.
Why do people like asking this question.In post 2916, Auro wrote:Luna, who are my partners?
People left us without a full mass claim so I will not comment on anything mechanicalIn post 2912, Auro wrote:I don't see how you townlean Alch.
Eddie, do you still think Oka's doc claim was memey? If it's serious, would you say he's +town?
I could answer if it makes him town knowing the rest of the claims. Imagine if we had enough information to consider the likelyhood of this BibleThumpIn post 2915, Auro wrote:a legitimate possibility that they're S-S
