mini 2126: the game is OVRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Nero Cain]

there is at least 1 scum in OkaPoka/Comical/Eddie Cane possibly 2

[Eddie Cane]

is there some secret april fools prank going on i'm not a part of where people try to post the most tremendously terrible solves possible?

[Nero Cain]

y r u town Eddie?

[Eddie Cane]

why are there at least 1 and possibly 2 scum in oka comical eddie

[Nero Cain]

I asked u first!

[Eddie Cane]

i am town because i can see my role pm and it is GREEN

what about you

[Nero Cain]

just seems like too many pr claims. voyuer and fruit vendor seems kinda low powered and townish though slight paranoia about PP targeting the guy that got killed.

I know you fake claimed cop so you could say you aren't a PR but even if you weren't a pr there's still 1 too many pr claims I think.

[Eddie Cane]

You should iso me (look at recent posts) for my opinion on claims

[Eddie Cane]

How much does Alchemist bus / distance? I don't really know him.

[PenguinPower]

just seems like too many pr claims. voyuer and fruit vendor seems kinda low powered and townish though slight paranoia about PP targeting the guy that got killed.

I know you fake claimed cop so you could say you aren't a PR but even if you weren't a pr there's still 1 too many pr claims I think.

I was quite clear about targeting Warmpup for almost all of Day 1 is that helps assuage your paranoia.

[Comical]

@Nero - this was not your scum game to lose, i apologize.

But yeah, Nero is obv scum on replace in.

[Comical]

RCE (now Nero)
NSG
Something Smart

Let’s lynch NSG, we can wait to see results from Nero and I tomorrow, but eh, alright

[northsidegal]

i actually think i would rather vote eddie over alchemist

should i be lynching you for saying this?

is there an expectation that i should easily be able to read you?

[Comical]

Jk
Gunsmith
Gunsmith
Voyeur
Fruit vendor

Am I missing any more PR claims? Because Nero said both “seems like too many PR’s” refuses to believe some, and then states “low power”

[Comical]

Nero is likely a scum gunsmith, maybe not even, and that was a fake claim.

Hell, Something Smart probably TMI setup when he mentioned Role Cop, which also would come and have a fun, so scum likely have a role cop, and maybe it’s even Nero.

[Eddie Cane]

i actually think i would rather vote eddie over alchemist

should i be lynching you for saying this?

is there an expectation that i should easily be able to read you?

You are the pargaon, right?

[northsidegal]

honestly i don't actually think that alchemist's whole thing with oka being a gunsmith is scummy. he has some pretty bad lines ("Nobody's saying Oka's not Jailkeeper so I'll assume that's the case here.") but i can actually track his thought process about a scum gunsmith / jailkeeper pointing towards vigs and thus a scum jailkeeper protecting a partner. i'm not saying that i agree, but it feels like a pretty genuine and complex thought that seems unlikely to have been pulled from nothing by scum.

was there some change in the gamestate that caused alchemist to want to basically go in an entirely new direction – against oka, who people were starting to townread more? i don't think so. i feel like this post is fairly accurate:

alch you want to tell us why you scumclaimed

It's not a scumclaim. I challenge you to explain why scum me would correctly guess that you're Jailkeeper and then push you for it instead of quietly passing on the info to my scumteam?

And unless I'm scum with RCE, why would I as scum shake up the status quo when he was on track to being lynched?

[Comical]

i actually think i would rather vote eddie over alchemist

should i be lynching you for saying this?

is there an expectation that i should easily be able to read you?

You are the pargaon, right?

That was for 2018, i believe. RC is for 2019.

[Comical]

I think this day phase started the correct way, and that I have a legit guilty on RCE slot, and RCE gambited with the claim.

[Something_Smart]

Hell, Something Smart probably TMI setup when he mentioned Role Cop

Lmao.

[northsidegal]

i actually think i would rather vote eddie over alchemist

should i be lynching you for saying this?

is there an expectation that i should easily be able to read you?

You are the pargaon, right?

not this year – and i find this something of a hard to believe answer from you, and i think you know it. i think that your thoughts on my abilities and your thoughts on your abilities as a scum player would lead you to believe that you could easily outmaneuver me if you were scum.

(i also don't think that you put a lot of stock into scummies correlating with ability and so you wouldn't have phrased it like this unless the point was more for other people to agree with, but i don't have anything to back that up and it's possible you just worded it that way to be concise.)

[Eddie Cane]

i actually think i would rather vote eddie over alchemist

should i be lynching you for saying this?

is there an expectation that i should easily be able to read you?

You are the pargaon, right?

That was for 2018, i believe. RC is for 2019.

I'm just meming.

[northsidegal]

SS, who are your scumreads / people you're willing to vote at this point?

[Eddie Cane]

not this year – and i find this something of a hard to believe answer from you, and i think you know it. i think that your thoughts on my abilities and your thoughts on your abilities as a scum player would lead you to believe that you could easily outmaneuver me if you were scum.

(i also don't think that you put a lot of stock into scummies correlating with ability and so you wouldn't have phrased it like this unless the point was more for other people to agree with, but i don't have anything to back that up and it's possible you just worded it that way to be concise.)

The fact you took that as a serious response when my first reply was a direct quote of your post to me is actually scummy I think.

But to clarify, yes, paragons can be wrong, and yes, NSG has never been good at reading me.

[northsidegal]

i mean, obviously i recognized that you were echoing what i said to you. sorry for assuming that it meant anything at all?