Doubles Mafia Day 2/ Day 2

[jjh927]

I have a confession to make

[Trojan Horses]

JJH LOCKTOWN NOW

[RadiantCowbells]

You can't case someone for traits you know are NAI!

Besides my case isn't for scumreading me it's for trying to silence the entire top tier player section of the playerlist.


Besides I don't really need to talk to you anymore, you outed.

[jjh927]

I can't actually read Mastina and just assume she is town

[Trojan Horses]

FARSIDE LOCKTOWN NOW

[gobbledygook]

I think Nancy would appreciate this
But JJh getting killed by Mastina is the karmic Justice I needed in this world

im going to miss u

-bitmap

It’s ok we can make a hydra called the birds and the boys with you, fire being the boys and me and Oka being the birds

[RadiantCowbells]

Birds boys bells

[Trojan Horses]

FARSIDE LOCKTOWN NOW

JJH LOCKTOWN NOW

Actually cancel this lol

[northsidegal]

i feel like i've seen birdblocks in so many games

how many birds are on ms?

[gobbledygook]

Birds boys bells

RC you should be careful what you wish for

[RadiantCowbells]

BEARS EAT BEETS

BEARS BEATS BATTLESTAR GALACTICA

[We are not helping]

I think Nancy would appreciate this
But JJh getting killed by Mastina is the karmic Justice I needed in this world

im going to miss u

-bitmap

It’s ok we can make a hydra called the birds and the boys with you, fire being the boys and me and Oka being the birds

I'm very down for this.

-bitmap

[gobbledygook]

i feel like i've seen birdblocks in so many games

how many birds are on ms?

It helps that me Oka and PenguinPower are prolific players so you might just be seeing the same birdbloc over and over again

[mastina]

if she is in fact doing this out of spite for out of game reasons

You can sell that narrative all you like RC but it will never cease to be a fabrication of yours given that I know my own emotions and for you I have none--zero.
Nadda.
The entirety of my push on you is because I think you are scum.
That's it. There's nothing else to it. I think you are scum, I think your actions are scum, I think your posts this game being manipulative as they are is scum, this one no different.

mastina has never displayed the level of open disrespect towards nsg that she shows towards me so theres a hole in this

I have a scumread on nsg--that's not disrespect; that's

respect

.

scumreading all of gif rc nsg and townreading you guys is just wrong

That is, again,

respect

for the competency of the players in question as both town and scum.

As town, they are underperforming.
As scum, they are hyper-competent and performing incredibly well.
That is the binary truth of the situation. Either they're town underperforming, in which case I am giving them more respect than I should, or they are scum playing at the level they should, in which case the level of respect is precisely deserved. And to reiterate:

There is value to be had in paragons being alive, if they are town--but they wouldn't be paragons if they were rattled, if they were shaken, by an incorrect scumread on their slot. They wouldn't be paragons if someone incorrectly scumreading them threw them off their beat, threw them off their kilter, kept them from putting in a paragon-level performance.

And there is value to be had in paragons being alive, if they are town--but if they

aren't

town, then why the fuck would I fear pushing scum just off of the value of "what if they're town", given the above? Given that being erroneously scumread shouldn't rattle, shouldn't shake, a paragon winner, there's no reason not to state a scumread on one.

I don't give a fuck about player skill. Scum are scum, regardless of how good or bad they are at the game. I happen to think this game has more good scum than bad scum, yes, but that's in part because the players who would be 'bad scum' are just so immensely transparently town.

Like, in a game where most people have towntold, more people have towntold than there are town in the game, which is more likely?
That players who have shown no previous strong scum performances suddenly, miracuously, are performing at a whole new level of talent and are miracuously deepscum...
...Or that players who have a known skill for being good at scum, are just being good at scum?

Occam's razor, the latter is far, far, far, FAR more likely than the former.
Which means, yes.
Players like RC, nsg, etc. as scum here.

[RadiantCowbells]

Hey I also said you could be scum

The quickhammer makes that version of events much more likely!

[gobbledygook]

Ok but real talk if JJH is town that means Mastina is lockscum from my point of view and she hammered because she saw the writing on the wall.

Straight up think WW is town because Ali does not hesitate to poop on scum who lurk and do nothing. See Furret Adventure V2 dead thread for most recent example. I don’t think e becomes the very thing e hates

I think farside is pretty town for her play today but her catchup made me think she was very political with her reads.
NSG is town
BBmolla is town I think, but I could be fooled
JJH dead animu but I think still possibly scum given his reaction to hammer actually
Elmo is ??? And probably scum imo

[RadiantCowbells]

the writing on the wall.

I've spent a lifetime running but I always get away

But with you I'm feeling something that makes me want to stay

[northsidegal]

Ok but real talk if JJH is town that means Mastina is lockscum from my point of view and she hammered because she saw the writing on the wall.

Straight up think WW is town because Ali does not hesitate to poop on scum who lurk and do nothing. See Furret Adventure V2 dead thread for most recent example. I don’t think e becomes the very thing e hates

I think farside is pretty town for her play today but her catchup made me think she was very political with her reads.
NSG is town
BBmolla is town I think, but I could be fooled
JJH dead animu but I think still possibly scum given his reaction to hammer actually
Elmo is ??? And probably scum imo

i think this is a pretty good analysis

[RadiantCowbells]

Ur face is a pretty good analysis

[gobbledygook]

Baezu is my pick for scum in Halloween
I think TH is town because after rereading WF I think I see similar weird things in Auro’s play that I do here
WANH town
RC town
Gamma town
SirCakez struck me as town early in the game but I have mellowed on that read

[mastina]

this is kind of the same thing mastina is doing where you are saying that lack of reasons to support a claim discredits the claim itself even though i am notorious for having few reasons and lots of correct reads

Again, apart from NSG, which claim did Mastina made which she refused to substantiate?

Yeah people keep accusing me of this.

But then if you look at my iso you realize they're full of shit because my reads' reasonings are

incredibly

substantiated.

[We are not helping]

What do we do if jjh flips scum?

-bitmap

[gobbledygook]

the writing on the wall.

I've spent a lifetime running but I always get away

But with you I'm feeling something that makes me want to stay

Love me sam smith
I low key love a lot of the James Bond songs. Even madona’s

[gobbledygook]

What do we do if jjh flips scum?

-bitmap

Watch RC carry your game

[Trojan Horses]

I see similar weird things in Auro’s play that I do here

You call my play weird and scummy yet logically sound.
Post-game feel free to actually describe to me what makes them look scummy to you.