Jigsaw's Revenge - Game Over

[Xtoxm]

a50, why are we removing people in hoods from the poe?
most of the game seems to be in one, so surely that's where we should be lynching?
my slot, for example, can be cleared pt cop/similar, hood members cant

[davesaz]

@A50, I had assumed that you inferred my answer from my posting. It should be relatively clear if you look closely enough.

[Almost50]

a50, why are we removing people in hoods from the poe?

Mate, you misunderstand the PoE. It's one of "unclaimed" status. They need to claim whether they are or are not in a hood. That's all I want to know. They are suspicious until they had claimed this (or confirmed the alternative hypothetical statement to be true). I am not saying we should lynch/not lynch based on who is/isn't in a hood.

[VaultDweller]

I'm here, catching up. At the start of page 2 now.

[Morning Tweet]

Oh good, nice to see you VD!

[VaultDweller]

Thanks!

Up to page 7

I'm keeping hectic alive for flavour reasons

Rampage can be town for now

[VaultDweller]

Also, I have just decided that I am going to ignore the game of Mafia for now and play the game of Choose Your Own Adventure instead. Seems way more fun.

[VaultDweller]

momo's reasoning on morning tweet is weak and battle mage looks bad for jumping on it so quickly

[VaultDweller]

iDanyboy can be town

[iDanyboy]

I guess I can actually see the comment possibly making sense from a town flavored character in a flavored hood. if danyBoy can confirm that that's what he is then I guess that solves like 90% of my issues with his post, maybe? though there is still a questionable assumption there that the scum in PTs have a fakeclaim that is also flavor linked to their PT. What if they had an entirely separate fakeclaim?

I am indeed in a flavoured PT, and if someone claimed a role that didn’t match the PT’s one then they would get lynched straight away. Say you’re in the Cartoon character hoods and someone on it claims to be Walter White they are probably scum.
I will post more later on tonight, I’ve been busy with work the last few days so I could only get a quick read.
Something I did see though is EJ refusing to say if she is in a hood and then in the next post say’s she isn’t in one.
VOTE: EJ

[VaultDweller]

Not a strong read, but I'm getting townie vibes from Morning Tweet

[VaultDweller]

Townie vibes from Drixx, also not very strong though

[VaultDweller]

I will let him get away with it as sometimes people just can't post on weekends. MagnaOfIllusion used to be on permanent weekend V/LA, for example.

Thanks. I'm mostly V/LA over weekends.

[farside]

That hat looks wonderful on you, why take it off

How do you feel about Drixx pretending he never whooshed on whatshisname pasting the playerlist and Drixx claiming it was scummy?

I have drixx as a scum read on my list.
I noted he had BM as scum for the reasoning of the scum list and then gets all pissy when people call him out on it as not being a scum tell.
It makes no sense to call, when BM himself never call it a scum list to begin with.
I agreed with Drixx first point on BM but the second part where BM even explains about the post and others chime in and he swipes at them is very irrational for him to do.

@a50 Vault and Pine haven't even posted yet. You're in my lynch list because you're acting antitown.

Try ISOing them. You won't even have to. You will find their names on the list though, which proves they each have posted at least once.

They haven't posted any content, meaning they might not even have had time to post in a PT or catch up.

It would be helpful if everyone provided a list of players in their lynchpool so we can get some bandwagons underway.

Drixx, a50, EJ, are the top and light scum reads or not enough info are as follows:
xtoxm, Bella, George, Pine, Vault, gamma
null: momo, hectic ABR

a50, why are we removing people in hoods from the poe?
most of the game seems to be in one, so surely that's where we should be lynching?
my slot, for example, can be cleared pt cop/similar, hood members cant

How do you know whether someone can be cleared or not from a hood?

Townie vibes from Drixx, also not very strong though

Why? I know it's a vibe, but what post gave it.

VOTE: EJ

[VaultDweller]

The Drixx/battle mage exchange doesn't feel TvT.

[VaultDweller]

Townie vibes from Drixx, also not very strong though

Why? I know it's a vibe, but what post gave it.

It's mostly because of his mindmeld with me for finding Battle mage's sheep vote scummy

[VaultDweller]

Vecna and momo hard defending battle mage like that is interesting. I can't see two teammates defending him so early in the game, unless he has a very powerful role. Though it could be that vecna is town and scum!momo jumped on vecna's defense of battle mage. Not sure what to think of the whole thing, but there's a good chance there's scum in it, probably either Drixx or Battle Mage/momo.

[Drixx]

momo's reasoning on morning tweet is weak and battle mage looks bad for jumping on it so quickly

We have a winner! Vecna seems to have succeeded in getting people to ignore it, but my vote went on BM for that bullshit jump on. The comment about the "reads list" was in relation to it being "someone else posted a "reads list" so I'll post a "reads list" too!" play. Monky see/Monky do is bad pretty much always.

Please note that hectic has dodged the fuck out of the game since I asked for his actual reads list to get some explanation. Meanwhile Vecna has been on a crusade to misrep and cherry pick me into looking absurd.

I've seen that playbook in action before.

VOTE: Vecna <--- that can eat rope. Had plenty of chance to re-read simple posts and adjust to reality. At this point has to be intentionally doing it and there's nothing at all useful about play like that. That shit needs to get flushed.


P-Edit: Hood is up to 8 players now.

[VaultDweller]

I find myself disagreeing with most of what Rampage is saying in the latter stages. My town read on him is dwindling.

[Drixx]

I find myself disagreeing with most of what Rampage is saying in the latter stages. My town read on him is dwindling.

Why does you disagreeing with him mean that he's scum?

[Drixx]

Corollary question: why would someone saying something you agree with make them town?

[Vecna]

Ive only asked you to clarify one thing Drixx:

Did you, or did you not REALIZE that battle mage copied the player list as a joke and represented it as his reads list to mock the person doing it before him.

Because you called it strike two as to why he is scummy.

[Vecna]

I have no read on battle mage outside of that whatsoever. I dont even remember any of the posts he has done. I dont care for your case on him. I dont want to involve myself.

This is all that I care about.

And your mega-over-the-top response to me following that

[Vecna]

And know that if you ignore this again and talk over it, I will instantly day vig you

[Drixx]

Ive only asked you to clarify one thing Drixx:

Did you, or did you not REALIZE that battle mage copied the player list as a joke and represented it as his reads list to mock the person doing it before him.

Because you called it strike two as to why he is scummy.

Re-read my post: I called the behavior of posting it in copy-cat style scummy. Like ... the entire emphasis of my comment towards it was on the "monkey see/monkey do" aspect. You can clearly understand my thinking if you take a few moments to read what I typed and think about what produces that content.