Animals Upick [Game Over]

[jjh927]

Mastina should be read by cross-reference to emotional state due to the many flavours of Mastina play

Inactivity is not scum-indicative with Mastina's current mood. The level of activity and the multiple attempts to find ways to be involved with the game in order for her to circumvent her irl emotional state and play this game is highly town-indicative

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

I am taking emotional state into account. My read is not activity based, but rather that her content is bad. I think as town she'd still have some genuine insights, but it instead feels like barely enough made-up stuff.

-Calvin

[jjh927]

I don't really get the journey of Farside's iso.
Farside votes Votato, disbelieves Votato's claim, switches to Clover Ebi, switches to Dunnstral for his vote on Votato, says she nullreads Votato, then says Votato's reaction to their wagon was town, then votes Votato again (immediately after Dunnstral unvotes) citing Holden's push which isn't really that much of a push and happens after HG unvotes
It feels kinda like votes are being made to predict and respond to the flow of the game rather than interact directly with it, with inferences generally made on the outcome of that flow rather than trying to place people on the individual level they occupy within it.

Townier side is the left side

Hard town: votato, HoldenGolden, Dr Easy Bake, Clover Ebi, April Ludgate, Creature
Town: mastina, chemist1422, Birds and the Boys, Conspire
Town but with mixed feelings: Calvin and Hobbes
Null: Bingle
Scum: PenguinPower, Dunnstral, Blatant Scum, farside22

That's my readslist


I think the main important thing that happened in the game is the votato wagon which I think peaked at 2 different points. Votato claimed something around the first peak that looked a lot like a meme fakeclaim at a glance. But it was serious, and it got expanded on, and I'm pretty sure it's very real and very town

I'm currently talking about farside22 who I think has mostly just been following the gamestate and trying to predict and direct the flow when it looks like momentum has fallen

I would appreciate it if you would make a list of your top 5 favourite dinosaurs because I wasn't joking when I said that I need people to do that for my role

I personally really didn't like Farside's reaction to my push. Could do a writeup there.

Then, IDK, maybe read like, the entire second half of April Ludgate's iso. Farside's reaction to April was also bad.

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

I'd appreciate a full write-up yeah

-Calvin

[jjh927]

Dunnstral doesn't have very much content, and what is there is mostly opportunism and pointed questions. I think it's pretty clear he's aware of things happening in the game but not involving himself in it very much

[jjh927]

I'd appreciate a full write-up yeah

-Calvin

Not yet

I'd appreciate a full write-up yeah

-Calvin

On one hand, two people with no solid case on them; one of them lynched a lot D1 for lurking.

There are at least two solid cases on Farside, as well as wide agreement for reasons why Dunnstral is scummy that can't quite be called a case simply because it's about as long as his iso at most.

So what's up with this? You just ignoring other people talking about Farside in the past?

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

I don't think that's at all scum indicative for Dunn, I can cite multiple games where he's done "nothing much" D1

-Calvin

[jjh927]

Okay sure

VOTE: Farside

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

Didn't see your farside case lol, just someone calling her "meh", I asked y'all to give your cases

Yeah the "wide agreement" is wrong, I'm informed from personal experience which is stronger.

-Calvin

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

Skim leaves me with gut town on farside but I'll give a closer look to and maybe deconstruct it later, but we're nearing deadline and I dunno if it's worth being arsed about

-Calvin

[jjh927]

Farside is likely scum trying to make sure Votato lynch goes through today

Farside is likely scum trying to make sure Votato lynch goes through today

Farside also hopped off of Dunnstral when it looked to be picking up steam

Farside effectively scum claimed in their last post agenda wise, to be honest.

VOTE: Farside

Farside-Dunnstral have high scum equity together.

Spoiler: The referenced post

fotahdo is still scum but I don't think we're lynching him today for...reasons.

here you go
VOTE: votato

There it will stay until one the following:
(1) April does more then defending votato
(2) hell freezes over.
(3) votato starts looking less scummy
(4) bird votes start to appear.

Especially because Bingle stated that he was only voting Dunnstral as almost a placeholder.

Farside being on the wagon was for show originally, and now that Dunn was picking up he made sure to try to change momentum back to Votato.

fotahdo is still scum but I don't think we're lynching him today for...reasons.

here you go
VOTE: votato

There it will stay until one the following:
(1) April does more then defending votato
(2) hell freezes over.
(3) votato starts looking less scummy
(4) bird votes start to appear.

Also this is actually incredibly scum indicative as well. Bird votes appear?

There’s already a big wagon on Birds.

And he was voting Dunnstral.

And Hell is cold this time of year, everyone knows that. It’s why I have a time share here.

So that is 4 out of 4 of those.

[jjh927]

Oops I quoted the first one twice oh well

[jjh927]

How would I look good from it?

And where did I ever say you called him town?

You are blatantly misrepping.

I specifically stated you went to votato after Dunn wagon was picking up.

You also stated when Bird votes start going.

Birds is the current top wagon.

You are actively caught out fabricating and faking stuff

Your entire big wall quote is 100% irrelevant and pointless and does nothing to comment on what actually was said, you just made a defense against stuff that wasn’t even thrown at you because you felt the need to defend yourself.


Lynch Farside

Lets talk facts over fiction. I asked at least 2 times why keep a player alive based on the claim. Even if proven how does that equal town?
I also asked beside the claim why your defending votato.
Second im scum reading bird and votato the strongest. They both voted dunn. Why would i join a wagon 2 players im scum reading are voting.
Finally, you presented no case just a lot of whiny about moving my vote on someone ive stated many times im scum reading.
So your points are all moot.

That’s what I’ve been talking.

A mechanical god even stated that there’s no reason to go Votato today.

Why would I need any other reason to defend him? People act like that’s not enough for a Day 1 defense. It completely is, and I don’t feel like he makes that claim up.

You misrepped. I don’t need a strong case, i need to warrant agenda, which you did.

You’ve lied. You effectively stated you would go birds if more votes were there, well with your vote, you’d have made them the leading wagon, so that was a mixed response


You acting like I’m stating nothing is just plain wrong.

Not all the points might be reasons to go for.

Also, if you say I’m pushing something fictious, why aren’t you pushing it as scum, because town has no reason to push something as fiction. You are using that as an excuse to try and discredit my case, not push me, which is a scum indicative push.


As town, I very much believe in my push, and sure, I wasn’t like dead set on you being scum, this is day 1, but I feel like there’s enough there to have merit in the push, and to believe what I am pushing in, so regardless if I was wrong about your alignment, the merit of the push itself is genuine, just the wrong conclusion would be there. However, in its stead, you choose to discredit, which only benefits ScumFarside.

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

Thanks.

-Calvin

[Dunnstral]

1735 doesn't seem like a convincing case to me

[jjh927]

Interesting choice of pop-in

What of the things said about Farside on this page do you not agree with?

Why are you voting Mastina right now?

What are your personal thoughts on Farside, as opposed to the case on Farside?

Are you aware that deadline is 5 and a half hours away?

[Dunnstral]

Didnt we play together a lonnnnnng time ago in a newbie?

Yeah, we did

Why are you voting Mastina right now?

1694 was some scum posting.

What of the things said about Farside on this page do you not agree with?

I don't see a case. Saying that farside is scum trying to lynch votato is not a case... there's no explanation as to how that makes farside scum, versus town - it's just saying that she's pushing votato

Saying that farside moved their vote off of me is not a case - how does that make farside scum?

Are you aware that deadline is 5 and a half hours away?

I'm here, aren't I? If there's anyone you should be concerned about, it's the numerous previously active players who entered prod range to avoid posting at deadline:



Just saying it how I see it. Isn't that a 4 person hydra too? I guess all four of them are just too busy to post.

[Dunnstral]

I realize Alyssa is a mod, I should have cropped that out

[Dunnstral]

Votecount 1.24

farside22(3)

~ jjh927(91), April Ludgate(184), votato(99)

Birds and the Boys(3)

~ Creature(139), Conspire(80), Blatant Scum(138)

votato(2)

~ mastina(35), farside22(83)

Blatant Scum(2)

~ Dr Easy Bake(33), PenguinPower(216)

mastina(1)

~ Calvin and Hobbes(79)

HoldenGolden(1)

~ Birds and the Boys(137)

Dunnstral(1)

~ Bingle(75)

Dr Easy Bake(1)

~ Clover Ebi(32)


Not Voting (3): chemist1422(24), HoldenGolden(169), Dunnstral(10)

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Day 1 deadline is in (expired on 2020-05-11 11:45:03)

MOD REMINDERS

jjh927 needs a prod. The last post was at: 5/7/2020 10:07:00 AM which was 2 days 2 hours 54 minutes 46 seconds ago.
Creature needs a prod. The last post was at: 5/7/2020 12:33:00 PM which was 2 days 0 hours 28 minutes 46 seconds ago.

FLAVOR

Clover Evi and Bird and Boys are voting 1 person wagons
Conspire is on Birds and Boys, which is decent
Penguin is scumreading an unusually large amount of people, though his vote is on BS - not certain why, does that add up?

I think I convinced myself:

VOTE: Birds and Boys

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

I'm very concerned about Alyssa

-Calvin

[Calvin ānd Hobbes]

Dunnstral, please review BnB's activity up till their last post. Gobbles was scum in our WF game, I think his activity is much smoother here?

-Calvin

[Dunnstral]

Dunnstral, please review BnB's activity up till their last post. Gobbles was scum in our WF game, I think his activity is much smoother here?

-Calvin

He's in prod range though

I'm looking at Bitmap's posts and I don't like them

[Dunnstral]

Turducken's actual content is decent when we talk about their larger posts, except they're strangely obsessed with lynching me in smaller posts. I can buy Gobble seeing me doing more as town as a reason for me to be suspect though. Except he then moved off of me and onto HoldenGolden by himself, which is a headscratcher.

[Dunnstral]

We have 3 days though so we should probably group up at one point. I dislike both the main wagons in question.

When are we going to group up, on day 2?

[Dunnstral]

On the other hand, a professed mechanical conflict

What is the mechanical conflict?