SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[Auro]

11. Nahdia - catch up looked town motivated

She literally called the gamesolving towny slots (even if you disagree on Mastina) scum and peaced out after 3 posts. What town motivation?

[Nero Cain]

Dave just knows she's towm

[Tchill13]

Tchill's a bit of a weaker read as well, but I admit that is partially due to a post that he made that does sound like it was meant for the scum PT because I can't see the context for what it could've been in response to in this thread.

which post? this is laughably weak.

[Tchill13]

I'm pretty sure Tchill was gloating at ETL flipping town rather than scum, give he'd been calling it for the entire day phase. How is that a scumslip?

Oh that would be a plausible explanation.

But, the logic I was going off of, was that Tchill in that post was quoting the mod, and seemingly speaking to someone--like you would in a mafia PT. Speaking to someone, but with no tie to his other posted content. Nothing he said before, or after, that post, was tied to what he said in 2795. He didn't bring it up after the fact, either; it looked like a post he was hoping people would ignore, not notice, etc., because it looked like he was avoiding drawing attention to it; it looked like he made an isolated post that was meant for somewhere else, because of the out-of-place nature of it; with nothing previous leading into it, and nothing after it relating to it, it stuck out.

Which is where I was coming from on that.

oh i didnt gloat correctly



come on mastina.

[Alchemist21]

more Dave votes plox

No. While I found his rather unnecessarily annoyed attitude a bit scummy, I think as scum he'd continue to exhibit and direct play with that attitude exclusively.

Posting a readslist with some progress towards a solve doesn't fit with that. If the intent were to "look towny" he'd probably easily have more solid stances on most of the plist.

Dave gets annoyed or angry as Town. When he’s not angry he doesn’t seem like the type of person who would get angry in thread and it usually gets him scumread by people who haven’t seen it before.

[Tchill13]

tchil's hard town read of ETL doesn't make a ton of sense to me. I've played with tchill a ton and it feels like ETL ateing is something that he normally questions.

dude. just tr me. I've already explained that you cant fathom the lvl of play im on atm. Its a new existence. A new being.

[Tchill13]

And Tchill is Scum based on meta as well. Will link the game I am thinking of where I literally screamed that Tchill was Scum and then FL screamed at me back for, get this, not believing his claim.

GLHF.

i mean there was one game where I literally only wanted to fake out FL knowing he'd control the game if I could just get him on my side.

That said, if you want to read me with meta prepared to be annoyed. Im constantly trying to get better which involves changing things.

[Tchill13]

if its the miller fake claim thats one of my fav moments.

but please dont use meta. meta is shit. almost always. Im not spewing my tangent here.

[Tchill13]

y is tchill town?

Tchill isn’t avoiding the game like I think he would as scum.

What are your reads right now?

WHAT?

explain this. because thats a hell of a dig.

[Tchill13]

this seems like way more effort then Dave has ever put into a game.

It's a sad situation when more than half the game is actively refusing to be useful.

oh right

VOTE: davesaz

yeah nero's town. he'd be playing a better town game if he were scum.

[Tchill13]

Also I'm an easy as fuck lynch for scum to push here so please consider that. It is unlikely it started via scum because pushing an inactive slot can be dangerous at times, but def likely we have scum on it.

Everyone who votes ETL will get their very own personal fruit from me during the night.

VOTE: ETL

Gimme my fruit!!!

UNVOTE:

Srsly tho this is town via ISO and I don't get why they are being voted...

VOTE: Miss Lynch

This slot has really rubbed me the wrong way in everything I've read. Imma Iso dive later but I'm not a fan atm

I think ari is town. Would have been easy af to stay on the ETL wagon there.

hopped off. pushed a viable target imo.

Ari is probably town.

[Tchill13]

I mean. As it so happens--Ari not playing is his scum meta and his lackluster content this game strongly indicates that he is probably scum here, so.

if u felt this why do you ever change your vote to ETL?

Because she's scum

Also I should address the actual content here.

My scumgame used to be permeated by a lack of actual play and whatnot. That has become my standard as either alignment, and mastina knows this.

I dislike greatly that she would pretend this is not the case!

Aristophanes, why not vote Flavor Leaf?

I haven't read much from that slot. However, he didn't D1 solve and seemed kind of avoidy in that part of the game so why not XD
VOTE: Flavour Leaf

VOTE: Aristophanes
I want to pressure this and see how it behaves.

I mean, claiming it is a pressure vote always makes me chuckle inside, if that helps you at all

I like both of these posts.

@auro. Why do you believe ari is scum? im about to try and find out but im seeing town here.

[Tchill13]

{Auro, Alchemist, Aristophanes, 5G, Creature, Hoctac, Jake, gobbledygook}

Ive only seen enough from auro, ari, creature, hoctac to feel good about a stance from this group.

creature and hoctac can be lynched imo.

[Tchill13]

creature, hoctac, quick, mastina, FL can all be lynched atm.

I had such a strong TR on vecna im not even gonna look at ETL's content. Apparently hes known for trolling/throwing/being stupid? theres enough of that in here.

[Tchill13]

TSE not ETL

[Hoctac]

Pretty sure TSE is just a ETL alt anyway

[Nero Cain]

I figured it was easier to show you you’re wrong than it is to tell you.

but throwing out an ISO is ambigious and leaving it up to players to make up their own interpretations seems kinda It feels half-assed.

he'd be playing a better town game if he were scum.

exactly what information do you have that lets you know that I'm playing a bad game?

[Nero Cain]

Dave gets annoyed or angry as Town

@nero: here's a link. Don't know why it's so long.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go

Doesn't really seem angry or annoyed too me?

[Nero Cain]

in fact, Tchill I just called your #1 scum read scum. How exactly am I playing poorly if you think I'm correct on Mastina? Isn't that like talking out of both sides of your mouth?

[Tchill13]

in fact, Tchill I just called your #1 scum read scum. How exactly am I playing poorly if you think I'm correct on Mastina? Isn't that like talking out of both sides of your mouth?

you can read ebery player correctly and still play poorly as town

[Nahdia]

did some more reading. farside's frustrating with the state of the town (lots of lurkers and just people acting "weird" in her own words) feels towny to me. I feel like scum!farside would just revel in that and not be worried about needing to form reads. So that carries over to a decent townread on gobbledygook.

Not sure what to think of davesaz, maybe leaning town? Honestly a bit lost there. Still not liking Tchill but his hard townread on chill gives me some pause, but I have him leaning scum.

Really feeling like there might be a lot of scum in the lurkers. We need a townbloc. Any volunteers?
Wanna lynch in Creature, Saudade, Nero, 5G.

VOTE: Saudade

[Auro]

@auro. Why do you believe ari is scum? im about to try and find out but im seeing town here.

He beetlejuiced in D1, and his stances seem a bit... weak, a lot of buddying. The relative lack of content is not AI given my experience with him. This is not a confident read.

I was interested in your progression on Ari late D1 when you said you have to re-read: so does that mean you had no opinions of him D1?

[davesaz]

but throwing out an ISO is ambigious and leaving it up to players to make up their own interpretations seems kinda It feels half-assed.

It's a town game where I'm active and post reads lists. Direct refutation of what you were saying about how I play.

[Tchill13]

in fact, Tchill I just called your #1 scum read scum. How exactly am I playing poorly if you think I'm correct on Mastina? Isn't that like talking out of both sides of your mouth?

you can read ebery player correctly and still play poorly as town

im just aggravating you nero. I do think your town and it is because im not a fan of how you're playing but id rather not argue.

[Tchill13]

@auro. Why do you believe ari is scum? im about to try and find out but im seeing town here.

He beetlejuiced in D1, and his stances seem a bit... weak, a lot of buddying. The relative lack of content is not AI given my experience with him. This is not a confident read.

I was interested in your progression on Ari late D1 when you said you have to re-read: so does that mean you had no opinions of him D1?

its a slot I largely ignored.