Newbie 2007: Air [game over!]

[teacher]

Honestly the two of you interacting is making me like each of you less, and making the thread hard to read outside of you two. I kinda have to agree with Quick (even if I think he’s the scummier of you two) - stop the 1v1 and stop drowning out other conversations. That said, it’s nearly midnight, so I’m not long for the site. I’d like Gibus and Maru to give some board reads and see if that can start a new line of conversation.

[teacher]

For the record, I find Baileys high interest morph into a prodge of a post today the most interesting shift. I’m stuck on null on both Jumble and 72 - nothing they’ve said has really stuck to me.

[Quick]

For the record, I find Baileys high interest morph into a prodge of a post today the most interesting shift. I’m stuck on null on both Jumble and 72 - nothing they’ve said has really stuck to me.

Talk more about GB and 72. I want to resolve that sooner rather than later. It's not a lock that there is Scum there, but it sure looks like it to me where I am standing.

[teacher]

Bailey seemed super hyped to play and was active I. The first 24, but has basically petered out. He’s one I’ve been watching since that weird interaction with Poyzin on page 2. Now, it’s a holiday weekend and normal ebbs and flows and all that, but seemed an odd switch - almost too early to demotivate, but possibly pleased to let the spotlight shine elsewhere.

72 I really don’t have anything on. I wasn’t kidding - nothing they’ve said made me go “huh, that’s an interesting take”. (To be fair to them, they had the one take on me and gibus, but that wasn’t so interesting for me at least). I saw you ranked then high - why?

[Poyzin]

I saw you ranked then high - why?

<3

[NotAJumbleOfNumbers]

Poyzin - Townlean, liked his beginning burst of posts and his arguments

What arguments did you like, and what did you like about them?

The 1v1 with Quick in general, even if it got a bit drawn out after a while. I thought the arguments were clear and logical.

[Quick]

Bailey seemed super hyped to play and was active I. The first 24, but has basically petered out. He’s one I’ve been watching since that weird interaction with Poyzin on page 2. Now, it’s a holiday weekend and normal ebbs and flows and all that, but seemed an odd switch - almost too early to demotivate, but possibly pleased to let the spotlight shine elsewhere.

72 I really don’t have anything on. I wasn’t kidding - nothing they’ve said made me go “huh, that’s an interesting take”. (To be fair to them, they had the one take on me and gibus, but that wasn’t so interesting for me at least). I saw you ranked then high - why?

Because they don't have many posts. True story.

[Poyzin]

To be fair, I was only talking to Quick for as long as I was because I knew he would be active and posting consistently. There’s be no reason to ask Marashu a bunch of questions because I knew he wouldn’t answer them swiftly.

With that being said, I don’t see anything wrong with my behavior at the present. I’ll concede that most of my points have been directed towards Quick but it’s only because he is the hardest player for me to understand. He said that he scumreads me because I think the Earth is round for heaven sakes.

[Poyzin]

Poyzin - Townlean, liked his beginning burst of posts and his arguments

What arguments did you like, and what did you like about them?

The 1v1 with Quick in general, even if it got a bit drawn out after a while. I thought the arguments were clear and logical.

This is my favorite Jumble post thus far.

[Quick]

Poyzin - Townlean, liked his beginning burst of posts and his arguments

What arguments did you like, and what did you like about them?

The 1v1 with Quick in general, even if it got a bit drawn out after a while. I thought the arguments were clear and logical.

Still waiting for you to unpack your case on me bro. My reads list is based on interactions with other players here and you can still totally be Scum just with good interactions with Town.

[Poyzin]

I’d like to think my conversation with Quick was more productive than y’all are making it out to be. We didn’t just talk about each other; we talked about many other topics and I feel like it was a helpful conversation. (It was for me at least.)

[Quick]

I’d like to think my conversation with Quick was more productive than y’all are making it out to be. We didn’t just talk about each other; we talked about many other topics and I feel like it was a helpful conversation. (It was for me at least.)

No, it was shit and you should feel bad.

[NotAJumbleOfNumbers]

Also Jumble, you forgot Teacher in your readslist.

Teacher - Strong townlean, is really constructive with his posts

[Poyzin]

Poyzin - Townlean, liked his beginning burst of posts and his arguments

What arguments did you like, and what did you like about them?

The 1v1 with Quick in general, even if it got a bit drawn out after a while. I thought the arguments were clear and logical.

Still waiting for you to unpack your case on me bro. My reads list is based on interactions with other players here and you can still totally be Scum just with good interactions with Town.

I don’t recall you ever asking me to unpack my case on you, but I must add that you saying this directly contradicts your opinion in #320. In your own words, “why would I give scum more information on how I am reading them?”

If it helps, there was a good bit in the post where I voted for you.

What calculations lead you to believe that Jumble is the number 1 town?

[teacher]

Because I’m mostly a mobile player, I’ll say the walls got hard, but I will try them again when at a desktop. Overall, I’m a tone reader, and I think the levels of frustration Made tonereading harder in general for a couple of pages.

Pedit: this was at Poyzin 3 posts ago or so.

[NotAJumbleOfNumbers]

Marashu - Slight scumlean, incredibly lurky and hasn't brought up much

Is lurking a scum trait?

No, but combined with the second point (which I should clarify as hasn't brought up many

new

ideas), I think it's enough ground to slightly scumread him on.

[NotAJumbleOfNumbers]

gibus - Null, kinda lurky with not much else to talk about

What’s the difference between this and the Marashu read?

Marashu has a lack of original ideas. I just straight up have nothing on Gibus.

[Quick]

Marashu - Slight scumlean, incredibly lurky and hasn't brought up much

Is lurking a scum trait?

No, but combined with the second point (which I should clarify as hasn't brought up many

new

ideas), I think it's enough ground to slightly scumread him on.

Maybe Poyzin just isn't reading carefully. Or it's just fake Scum hunting. I wouldn't doubt either at this point.

[Poyzin]

Because I’m mostly a mobile player, I’ll say the walls got hard, but I will try them again when at a desktop. Overall, I’m a tone reader, and I think the levels of frustration Made tonereading harder in general for a couple of pages.

Pedit: this was at Poyzin 3 posts ago or so.

This is a good post, thank you. I agree that we were both frustrated with each other, which led to general negative opinions of the other player, which made it harder to get a proper read of the other player without harboring bias towards them.

[Quick]

Because I’m mostly a mobile player, I’ll say the walls got hard, but I will try them again when at a desktop. Overall, I’m a tone reader, and I think the levels of frustration Made tonereading harder in general for a couple of pages.

Pedit: this was at Poyzin 3 posts ago or so.

This is a good post, thank you. I agree that we were both frustrated with each other, which led to general negative opinions of the other player, which made it harder to get a proper read of the other player without harboring bias towards them.

I was only frustrated because it seems your super power is misrepping me.

[Poyzin]

Maybe Poyzin just isn't reading carefully.

And you went right back to it. I can read perfectly fine, thank you very much.

The exact verbiage used was “incredibly lurky and hasn’t brought up much”. In this instance, the “hasn’t brought up much” is a byproduct of somebody who is “incredibly lurky”, which means that the former should be the primary reason that should be looked at. (In addendum, not bringing up much can be explained by Marashu being incredibly lurky) I don’t understand your rationale of trying to re-hash more drama when enough has already occurred.

[Poyzin]

Because I’m mostly a mobile player, I’ll say the walls got hard, but I will try them again when at a desktop. Overall, I’m a tone reader, and I think the levels of frustration Made tonereading harder in general for a couple of pages.

Pedit: this was at Poyzin 3 posts ago or so.

This is a good post, thank you. I agree that we were both frustrated with each other, which led to general negative opinions of the other player, which made it harder to get a proper read of the other player without harboring bias towards them.

I was only frustrated because it seems your super power is misrepping me.

Show me a misrep. Show me ANY misrep. Let me look at it for myself so that I can tell you why I said it. You keep on saying I misrepresented you but you’ve never said where.

[Poyzin]

gibus - Null, kinda lurky with not much else to talk about

What’s the difference between this and the Marashu read?

Marashu has a lack of original ideas. I just straight up have nothing on Gibus.

What are gibus’ original ideas, and why don’t they affect your read of him, because you say that gibus is null?

[Poyzin]

Also Jumble, you forgot Teacher in your readslist.

Teacher - Strong townlean, is really constructive with his posts

How is being constructive townie? Fear nice scum.

[Quick]

Because I’m mostly a mobile player, I’ll say the walls got hard, but I will try them again when at a desktop. Overall, I’m a tone reader, and I think the levels of frustration Made tonereading harder in general for a couple of pages.

Pedit: this was at Poyzin 3 posts ago or so.

This is a good post, thank you. I agree that we were both frustrated with each other, which led to general negative opinions of the other player, which made it harder to get a proper read of the other player without harboring bias towards them.

I was only frustrated because it seems your super power is misrepping me.

Show me a misrep. Show me ANY misrep. Let me look at it for myself so that I can tell you why I said it. You keep on saying I misrepresented you but you’ve never said where.

I've already pointed them out in my case on you and 72. Look there for info. Last thing I said actually. Go reads it... carefully.