Newbie 2004: Trash Panada Hour. Redux! GAME OVER

[Battle Mage]

this game got heated

okay boys where we at, I'm pretty confident in that Lillith/Dunn slot being scum, unsure of the other

theres 1 scum in Nauci-Gibus. I'm not too sure which - who do you like and I'll go with ya?

they're both town though

why do you say this friendo

you think no scum on the Day 1 mislynch? unlikely!

[Battle Mage]

Hey BM. Yeah, well at least it's not AI. Once I get around to reading fish's iso, we'll see. I'm sure it's going to be "you think I'm mad... You haven't seen me mad. I've been a nice little boy so far."

How did you know?

P.S. your slot is locktown

If you've got experience with FF, do you know if, in his scum games, he also stirs up as much activity as he did? My town read of him is heavily based on the fact that even though he was frequently anti town, he stirred up way more activity in this game than was necessary which he wouldn't have reasons to do if he's scum.

this is less a reach, more of a desperate lunge for a reason to vote for me.

[Battle Mage]

ah Votato is Alora-town.

So let's lynch Nauci or Gibus. I'm backing Gibus!

VOTE: gibus

Is this based on posts as well or just wagon analysis?

wagons for now!

[Tuxedo Mask]

this game got heated

okay boys where we at, I'm pretty confident in that Lillith/Dunn slot being scum, unsure of the other

theres 1 scum in Nauci-Gibus. I'm not too sure which - who do you like and I'll go with ya?

Why do you say that? I've had gut pings on Gibus, but feathers seemed pretty obv town.

Day 1 wagon bound to have 1 scum on it I reckon, those are the only 2 on there who aren't obvtown to me anyway.

Gibus is probably my preferred - only guy who didn't replace out, scum?

I mean if you wanna really put on a tinfoil hat, last game Elmo modded that I replaced into, Newbie 1996. It had a similar thing where lots of player tension resulted in most of the players replacing out. All except three, two of which were the scum team.

The important thing to note is that Elmo is cursed.

[Nauci]

Hey BM. Yeah, well at least it's not AI. Once I get around to reading fish's iso, we'll see. I'm sure it's going to be "you think I'm mad... You haven't seen me mad. I've been a nice little boy so far."

How did you know?

P.S. your slot is locktown

If you've got experience with FF, do you know if, in his scum games, he also stirs up as much activity as he did? My town read of him is heavily based on the fact that even though he was frequently anti town, he stirred up way more activity in this game than was necessary which he wouldn't have reasons to do if he's scum.

this is less a reach, more of a desperate lunge for a reason to vote for me.

Why would I not want my reason for giving Formerfish a strong townread up until The Purge confirmed or debunked?

[Nauci]

The important thing to note is that Elmo is cursed.

The important thing to note is that Elmo is a very nice mod and we should all thank her for being infinitely more patient with players and replacement requests over the course of way too many games than we could ever be

The last time I modded a game with 9 replace outs I wanted to die

[Nauci]

Since the events of The Purge, I have a really, really hard time believing that Formerfish genuinely thought that Freddie's claim was faked and that another player (who he suspected was... Literally anybody?) coached them. The way he wanted to string up Freddie and Votato successively and believed in that logic even after votato and Freddie revealed a personal friendship and therefore additional meta-knowledge is just so incomprehensibly stubborn to me. Even Osuka changed their reads after that.

[BBmolla]

Hey BM. Yeah, well at least it's not AI. Once I get around to reading fish's iso, we'll see. I'm sure it's going to be "you think I'm mad... You haven't seen me mad. I've been a nice little boy so far."

How did you know?

P.S. your slot is locktown

If you've got experience with FF, do you know if, in his scum games, he also stirs up as much activity as he did? My town read of him is heavily based on the fact that even though he was frequently anti town, he stirred up way more activity in this game than was necessary which he wouldn't have reasons to do if he's scum.

he lurked as scum in team mafia

[Aloratom]

this game got heated

okay boys where we at, I'm pretty confident in that Lillith/Dunn slot being scum, unsure of the other

theres 1 scum in Nauci-Gibus. I'm not too sure which - who do you like and I'll go with ya?

Why do you say that? I've had gut pings on Gibus, but feathers seemed pretty obv town.

Day 1 wagon bound to have 1 scum on it I reckon, those are the only 2 on there who aren't obvtown to me anyway.

Gibus is probably my preferred - only guy who didn't replace out, scum?

I mean if you wanna really put on a tinfoil hat, last game Elmo modded that I replaced into, Newbie 1996. It had a similar thing where lots of player tension resulted in most of the players replacing out. All except three, two of which were the scum team.

The important thing to note is that Elmo is cursed.

I was the third but was lynched before you repped in. Elmo is battle worn.

[Battle Mage]

this game got heated

okay boys where we at, I'm pretty confident in that Lillith/Dunn slot being scum, unsure of the other

theres 1 scum in Nauci-Gibus. I'm not too sure which - who do you like and I'll go with ya?

Why do you say that? I've had gut pings on Gibus, but feathers seemed pretty obv town.

Day 1 wagon bound to have 1 scum on it I reckon, those are the only 2 on there who aren't obvtown to me anyway.

Gibus is probably my preferred - only guy who didn't replace out, scum?

I mean if you wanna really put on a tinfoil hat, last game Elmo modded that I replaced into, Newbie 1996. It had a similar thing where lots of player tension resulted in most of the players replacing out. All except three, two of which were the scum team.

The important thing to note is that Elmo is cursed.

yeah scum tend not to get too heated - I like your reasoning here

[Battle Mage]

Hey BM. Yeah, well at least it's not AI. Once I get around to reading fish's iso, we'll see. I'm sure it's going to be "you think I'm mad... You haven't seen me mad. I've been a nice little boy so far."

How did you know?

P.S. your slot is locktown

If you've got experience with FF, do you know if, in his scum games, he also stirs up as much activity as he did? My town read of him is heavily based on the fact that even though he was frequently anti town, he stirred up way more activity in this game than was necessary which he wouldn't have reasons to do if he's scum.

this is less a reach, more of a desperate lunge for a reason to vote for me.

Why would I not want my reason for giving Formerfish a strong townread up until The Purge confirmed or debunked?

Since the events of The Purge, I have a really, really hard time believing that Formerfish genuinely thought that Freddie's claim was faked and that another player (who he suspected was... Literally anybody?) coached them. The way he wanted to string up Freddie and Votato successively and believed in that logic even after votato and Freddie revealed a personal friendship and therefore additional meta-knowledge is just so incomprehensibly stubborn to me. Even Osuka changed their reads after that.

This progression doesn't look great...you went from strong townread, to "can't believe he's not scum" in less than a page? Surprising given you are an experienced player, and FF was quite clearly town, and even your odd meta-angle was "debunked" to use your terms. Again, I think you're stretching hard here, I'll bite.

VOTE: Nauci

[Aloratom]

Alright, I guess we've got some time. UNVOTE:

[Nauci]

"can't believe he's not scum"

That's a misrep; I didn't say I can't believe he's not scum

I am having a hard time believing that he genuinely believed what he did about Freddie being coached because it's so absurd, especially in the face of new information.

Also, my read was confirmed by his meta according to Aloratom, who I trust because of my read on votato. I had paranoia about whether or not the cues which led me to town read him based on his day 1 play were things he may also have done as scum, so I asked in order to rule that out.

I don't know what to make of his tunnel "logic" on day 2, but I don't see why he would do that as scum either.

[Nauci]

yeah scum tend not to get too heated - I like your reasoning here

Do you think this applies to Lilith's reaction to Formerfish back in early day 1 where he accused her of cunting up the thread but she was surprisingly not that offended?

VOTE: Dunnstral

I think the sentiment has some merit, but mostly I think that Lilith was using the big kerfuffle as a good time to effort IIOA and comment but not truly evolve reads on other players outside of that, which smells mighty scummy to me

[BBmolla]

idk vote count or my vote would be there

[Nauci]

idk vote count or my vote would be there

Hard to be sure since I've been mobile checking all day but I think it's like 2 on Blair, 1 on me, 1 on Dunn

It looked like there were many more but only because BM keeps changing his vote

[Nauci]

Not going to be super active for today/tomorrow because it's the last day of my 20s and I don't know if I should spend it just playing mafia and animal crossing

[BBmolla]

happy birthday fellow gemini

congrats on being done with puberty 2.0 (20-28)

I turned 27 on the 22nd so hopefully I'll become an adult soon

[Aloratom]

idk vote count or my vote would be there

On Dunnstral?

[Elmo TeH AzN]

~~~~~~

[Elmo TeH AzN]

~~~~~~

[Elmo TeH AzN]

~~~~~~

[Elmo TeH AzN]

~~~~~~

[Elmo TeH AzN]

~~~~~~

[Elmo TeH AzN]

~~~~~~