Newbie 2004: Trash Panada Hour. Redux! GAME OVER

[Nauci]

If Dunnstral and I were scum together, we had the opportunity to win the game yesterday if we could coordinate suspicion on to literally any townie.

So why would we initiate a 1v1 between ourselves so early in the phase when neither of us were under any real pressure? (Dunnstral had one person voting for him while most players seemed resigned to a no lynch)

I could see scum cross bussing near the end of the day after exhausting all other options, perhaps - but pretty much right out the gate? During what could have been a game-winning phase?

You know damn well I would never have stopped calling for his head yesterday so don't pretend there wasn't pressure

[Battle Mage]

Nauci, what is your role....?

[Nauci]

If I get to nominate, I want Tux claiming before Nauci.

Thought we were waiting on Nauci to make the call?

Erm no, I get to choose the next claimer.

Nauci is in charge of strategy for the remainder of the day.

Okay, I'm...

Town Jailkeeper

I Jailed FF N1. Softed here.

Everyone should click my link and post a comment on it in here. Kthxbai

That's So FFucking Cute!

Jailed Blair N2, which I didn't soft but it's how I knew Dunn was lying.

Then I jailed Battlemage N3 (probably a mistake in retrospect but I was really certain of that team), so he's conf town. Softed here.

Are you claiming that you tracked Blair to Alortrom last night so they must be the roleblocker?

YES

Lets end this battle.

VOTE: Dunnstral

You've been brilliant, mate

I'm so glad they didn't let me lynch you day 1 because I was SO DAMN SURE your predecessor was scum, goddamn

[Nauci]

Yeah, I thought they would, but was paranoid he'd be most likely to carry out the NK (especially if it was someone like Freddie) so I probably wasted N3 by double-checking you. This is my first time playing a PR, and Jailkeeper is a confusing one.

Nah it was the right play

N1 reduced it to a 50/50, N3 confirmed the most lynchbait slot, guaranteeing us victory

[Nauci]

Nauci, what is your role....?

VT

[Nauci]

Not sure why Nauci hasn't claimed yet??

Because I was catching up

[Nauci]

But also because this was like the first claimed slot in the game

[Nauci]

VOTE: Blair

GG Y'all!

Thanks to all of the replace ins, who really rescued a dumpster fire and turned it into a very interesting game!

[Battle Mage]

Yeah, I thought they would, but was paranoid he'd be most likely to carry out the NK (especially if it was someone like Freddie) so I probably wasted N3 by double-checking you. This is my first time playing a PR, and Jailkeeper is a confusing one.

Nah it was the right play

N1 reduced it to a 50/50, N3 confirmed the most lynchbait slot, guaranteeing us victory

He targeted me on N3 lol

[Battle Mage]

Nauci, what is your role....?

VT

Excellent, that confirms Tux as town then.

Vote: Blair

Let's avenge our fallen brothers!

[Blair]

Well played, Nauci. VT was the smart claim there.

You'd rather 1v1 me than Tuxedo, because there is already a path for lynching me.

This phase will boil down to whether Battle Mage and Tuxedo believe that Nauci/Dunnstral fumbled the start of their MYLO gambit (see: 2111) or that Blair/Dunnstral decided to 1v1 from the beginning for no reason (and no, Nauci "never stopped calling for his head" did not constitute pressure when no one else wanted to lynch him that day prior to his claim).

VOTE: Nauci

Battle Mage is cleared and since Nauci didn't counterclaim, Tuxedo is also cleared. Another 1v1 for Blair today.

[Nauci]

Yeah, I thought they would, but was paranoid he'd be most likely to carry out the NK (especially if it was someone like Freddie) so I probably wasted N3 by double-checking you. This is my first time playing a PR, and Jailkeeper is a confusing one.

Nah it was the right play

N1 reduced it to a 50/50, N3 confirmed the most lynchbait slot, guaranteeing us victory

He targeted me on N3 lol

He targeted you N1 and N3, unless you're not the Formerfish slot and I've been confused the entire time

[Battle Mage]

Blair you can self-hammer and it's fine. It doesn't matter either way, as if Nauci is scum we'll still win because Tux will block her, and then we'd lynch her tomorrow. So no reason for you to fight it if town.

[Battle Mage]

Yeah, I thought they would, but was paranoid he'd be most likely to carry out the NK (especially if it was someone like Freddie) so I probably wasted N3 by double-checking you. This is my first time playing a PR, and Jailkeeper is a confusing one.

Nah it was the right play

N1 reduced it to a 50/50, N3 confirmed the most lynchbait slot, guaranteeing us victory

He targeted me on N3 lol

He targeted you N1 and N3, unless you're not the Formerfish slot and I've been confused the entire time

Yep that's what I'm saying, don't worry though!

[Tuxedo Mask]

Just to be absolutely clear we are conformed that it is two mafia goons, me as cleared JK and BM as cleared Townie. So it is irrelevant who we lynch today, either town wins Day 4 or Day 5?

[Nauci]

Well played, Nauci. VT was the smart claim there.

You'd rather 1v1 me than Tuxedo, because there is already a path for lynching me.

This phase will boil down to whether Battle Mage and Tuxedo believe that Nauci/Dunnstral fumbled the start of their MYLO gambit (see: 2111) or that Blair/Dunnstral decided to 1v1 from the beginning for no reason (and no, Nauci "never stopped calling for his head" did not constitute pressure when no one else wanted to lynch him that day prior to his claim).

VOTE: Nauci

Battle Mage is cleared and since Nauci didn't counterclaim, Tuxedo is also cleared. Another 1v1 for Blair today.

I don't understand why you even care to 1v1 since town is already guaranteed victory here

I mean I personally would like to win earlier than later but it doesn't really matter does it

[Nauci]

Just to be absolutely clear we are conformed that it is two mafia goons, me as cleared JK and BM as cleared Townie. So it is irrelevant who we lynch today, either town wins Day 4 or Day 5?

Ya

[Blair]

If you actually try to blame me in post game Battle Mage I'll be disappointed. Townies who blame each other for misreads are the worst (notice I apologized to you for calling it wrong).

Tuxedo thought Dunn/BM too, let's not pretend it was an unimaginable perspective.

P-edit: That's fair.

I'll do that if Tuxedo affirms for sure that that's happening and he won't try to pull any crazy 4D Chess moves.

[Battle Mage]

I'm happy with this game - I think my first endgame win as town! And only my 2nd town win total (the other was my only other replace-in game)!

I'm a terrible player to start with, but a good super-sub.

[Blair]

(Guess Nauci should have counterclaimed, actually)

[Blair]

I'm happy with this game - I think my first endgame win as town! And only my 2nd town win total (the other was my only other replace-in game)!

I'm a terrible player to start with, but a good super-sub.

And my proud tradition of never surviving to endgame continues.

[Battle Mage]

If you actually try to blame me in post game Battle Mage I'll be disappointed. Townies who blame each other for misreads are the worst (notice I apologized to you for calling it wrong).

Tuxedo thought Dunn/BM too, let's not pretend it was an unimaginable perspective.

P-edit: That's fair.

I'll do that if Tuxedo affirms for sure that that's happening and he won't try to pull any crazy 4D Chess moves.

It's ok, as we will win regardless.

I do think you were dealt a bad hand in terms of how Dunnstral self-destructed and threw you under yesterday, but also your interaction towards him was incredibly scummy throughout.

[Battle Mage]

I'm happy with this game - I think my first endgame win as town! And only my 2nd town win total (the other was my only other replace-in game)!

I'm a terrible player to start with, but a good super-sub.

And my proud tradition of never surviving to endgame continues.

Haha well until this game I had a 100% record of

never

being mislynched in a game I started, but a 100% record of

always

being mislynched when I replace in.

[Blair]

My interaction being... when he claimed a guilty on me and I hard tunneled him until he was lynched?

[Battle Mage]

Just to be absolutely clear we are conformed that it is two mafia goons, me as cleared JK and BM as cleared Townie. So it is irrelevant who we lynch today, either town wins Day 4 or Day 5?

Yep, you can do the honours and hammer Blair!