Mini Theme 2145: The Weakest Link Game over

[Starbuck]

Where the hell is a softclaim here?

That's what we all would like to know.

[Titus]

1) Albert B. Rampage
11) midwaybear
13) springlullaby

yoo I'm actually town read lets go

farside, unwnd, tse, starbuck all give me doubts. And then I can't give it to PB or Cakez who I think are town(mostly Cakez). NDMath has posted way too little, and not that much substance. I can see myself giving it to Dunn or beeboy then. I like Dunnstral's posts because he seems critical of things others were saying, and veered away from sheeping, so VOTE: Dunnstral

Here is the sole mention of Dunn by midway before passing Dunn the chain.

I think I feel comfortable postulating a Spring, midway, Dunn team.

[midwaybear]

hmph. I don't really townread him anymore though because he hasn't done much D2+EoD1
maybe you should read dunn's chain pass to NDMath. super weird

[Titus]

hmph. I don't really townread him anymore though because he hasn't done much D2+EoD1
maybe you should read dunn's chain pass to NDMath. super weird

I'll look at that. Do you think Spring is scum? Do you understand if Dunn is scum, your pass looks really bad?
I love your personality but there's too many small things that make it impossible to TR you.

[Titus]

Alright, here's what I'm going to do:

VOTE: NDMath

Justification: My basis for this is that I want people to make a real choice for the lynch today (i.e. not the 'lurker' lynch)

and

I don't think his content is even bad, but I don't think anyone else will pass him the chain.

We can lynch in Unwnd/SirCakez today, preferably. I'll let other people read Pink Ball this game

I'm keeping in mind the quiz team needing to get the chain (i.e. Starbuck/farside won't be lynched)

My theory would suggest unwnd or SirCakez suspected Spring Dunn midway more than NDMath and/or NDMath was needed as a mislynch.

[midwaybear]

I'll look at that. Do you think Spring is scum? Do you understand if Dunn is scum, your pass looks really bad?
I love your personality but there's too many small things that make it impossible to TR you.

I agree that the Spring/ABR chain pass makes little sense, but I like her actions outside of it. Yes, I get that if Dunn is scum, it looks bad(and he probably is).

[Titus]

Maybe I should be more forthright and that's the way to be townread

ABR's position/stubborness is townie
TSE is a fucking loon, he plays like this regardless of alignment. I can no longer read it.
NDMath continues to sit on his hands
midwaybear has been the crux of many arguments but still remains largely uninvolved or seemingly unable to speak his mind. I never townread him and I don't now, fuck you TSE for putting words in my mouth sincerely
Beeboy is still Fine
Starbuck remains assertively passive, in the sense she says things that seemingly hold a lot of weight but does nothing with it. I don't like it
Farside is like, almost reverse of it. I can't see her interacting with Starbuck the way she is right now as scum
Springlulluaby's intent reads fine, but with new information being presented constantly I change my position about it
Raya has done nothing to be townread, Sircakez as well
Dunn and Pink both make posts and then I don't think about them at all, one of them being Dunn where I think the game needs to go on longer before I commit and the other being I don't know Pink at all

Unwind has all the theoretical as possible scum at the time of the Dunn --> ND pass

[Titus]

I'll look at that. Do you think Spring is scum? Do you understand if Dunn is scum, your pass looks really bad?
I love your personality but there's too many small things that make it impossible to TR you.

I agree that the Spring/ABR chain pass makes little sense, but I like her actions outside of it. Yes, I get that if Dunn is scum, it looks bad(and he probably is).

What specifically do you like from Spring?

[midwaybear]

I had a gut TR, but I'll try to find some quotes to support it.

[Titus]

I think I'm gonna stop reading TSE posts

I really dislike that quiz team, Starbuck, Raya and Dunn are not good choices. I want to reject it if a different one can be formed.

Ok to lynch: sircakez, unwnd, NDmath, midwaybear

This list even excluding me is not great

Dunnstral
Cakez
Pinkball
Raya
TSE

that was my team.
TSE is a stubborn guy but that doesn't change his role card.

why tse?

SirCakez doesn't like Dunn or Spring. No recent comment on Midway.

[springlullaby]

So what's the supposition here. That I passed the chain to ABR because he is my scumbuddy. And now Titus as my scumbuddy is bussing me?

I explained it again and again:
- I though it was a softclaim: ABR started the game by buddying up to Starbuck, then did a 180 started calling her scum. I thought nothing of it at that point yet. Then I posted my readlist with Starbuck in it: he was talking about at which point he posted a post asking to deny the quiz, and replied to me "You don't understand spring, Starbuck is Marie-Antoinette (scum) and you are helping her ". I thought in that moment it was a cop claim with a guilty on Starbuck. What I did is I tossed him the chain so a PR can survive.
- Then he retracted and said it wasn't a softclaim.

Hence I said he was scum.

Titus, I know you have a weird enmity with ABR. But it is weird for you to be calling that out, but not the other players who've said way worse. I've been called toxic, by player who are trying to start lip battle.
I didn't read ABR as "toxic" because I don't know his alignment. The rational I had for his weird post was that it was a softclaim.
Now you've confirmed it isn't a softclaim (and using that weird angle to attack me?), I can confirm that it was trolling in an anti-town manner.

You not understanding that I though his wtf post were breadcrumbing is weird to me.

[Titus]

So what's the supposition here. That I passed the chain to ABR because he is my scumbuddy. And now Titus as my scumbuddy is bussing me?

No. My supposition is that you passed the chain because ABR was loud, toxic, and wrong. The softclaim nonsense was a cover.

I am going to check if all three of you rejected the quiz proposed.

What are your thoughts on midway and Dunn?

[springlullaby]

Who is the tyrant now.

How do I put this...okay...

Starbuck is Marie Antoinette... you are like her servant that helps her put on those phat ass gowns with the feathers... and we, the people of France, are gonna divide her body in two at the neck.

We're gonna be a republic now. The era of the royalty is finished.

PASS THE CHAIN SPRING

That is the post which made me think he was breadcrumbing a guilty on Starbuck.

[springlullaby]

So what's the supposition here. That I passed the chain to ABR because he is my scumbuddy. And now Titus as my scumbuddy is bussing me?

No. My supposition is that you passed the chain because ABR was loud, toxic, and wrong. The softclaim nonsense was a cover.

I am going to check if all three of you rejected the quiz proposed.

What are your thoughts on midway and Dunn?

You supposition is useless unless you think I'm scum.

[springlullaby]

I said I'm for lynching the ABR's slot. I can pass the chain to Dunn I suppose.

[Titus]

I happen to think you're scum with Dunn and midway. All three of you rejected the quiz because none of you were on it.

It's no surprise that you're in favor of lynching me.

You also didn't answer about your reads on Dunn and midway.

[springlullaby]

I think I feel comfortable postulating a Spring, midway, Dunn team.

Midway bear, the person ABR passed a chain to is on your list of scum, when I was one of the first to point that out.
I am scum, because I, midway's scumbuddy, predicted that ABR town would pass the chain to my scumbuddy.
Dunn is scum... because?

You can't stop flooding the thread now, your read make zero sense.
Just fucking lynch that slot.

[springlullaby]

I happen to think you're scum with Dunn and midway. All three of you rejected the quiz because none of you were on it.

It's no surprise that you're in favor of lynching me.

You also didn't answer about your reads on Dunn and midway.

That is straight bullshit: I specifically said why I rejected the quiz team, and said that I'm ok with any team with beeboy and unwnd on it.
So you're saying that I'm lying about that as scum, when it's so easily falsifiable.

Lol.

[Titus]

I happen to think you're scum with Dunn and midway. All three of you rejected the quiz because none of you were on it.

It's no surprise that you're in favor of lynching me.

You also didn't answer about your reads on Dunn and midway.

That is straight bullshit: I specifically said why I rejected the quiz team, and said that I'm ok with any team with beeboy and unwnd on it.
So you're saying that I'm lying about that as scum, when it's so easily falsifiable.

Lol.

And yes, my theory supports this is misleading. Beeboy claims that he must automatically fail. Putting him on a quiz means you don't have to insist on partners.

What are your Dunn and Midway reads?

[springlullaby]

Titus's case on me:

Spring is scum because water+rocks=bananas.

Me: ahem, what?

Titus: water+rock+bananas=cheetos.

I already responded. Read the thread.

[Titus]

Mod: Do all town, regardless of role, pass a quiz by PMing you?

[springlullaby]

And yes, my theory supports this is misleading. Beeboy claims that he must automatically fail. Putting him on a quiz means you don't have to insist on partners.

Yeah ok, you are just throwing bullshit around.
You made a two pages case on me with quote, but yet you fail to mention when I said beeboy+unwnd, if unwnd target beeboy is improvement on town odds. 1/2 and 1/2 again.

According to you I as scum am insisting beeboy be on the quiz so that town fail.
But it only works if you think unwnd is lying and not town.
Yet unwnd is not in your scumlist.


That so many level of terrible, scum must be panicking in their qt.
Just so people understand: Titus is an adult, they are not bad at logic.
This is just bullshit.

[beeboy]

I believe spring thought ABR soft claimed. I am not sure why she thought that but I found her post had an "AHA!" moment when she thought ABR claimed and if he couldn't follow up on it he died and flipped scum.


Also asking about how my role interacts with unwnd's is kinda mute, given I already asked the mod and knows that our roles work together.

[beeboy]

Just to be clear, I'm supposing that was a softclaim of somekind ABR.
No way out of it otherwise.

ABR, why do you need to think? You want your lynch on starbuck, go ahead.

ABR, you are so confscum.

But yeah go ahead.

Nah, I'm just sitting looking who scum is going to pass chain to.

ABR, you are not making to the team. If you are town, you have zero reason to deny this.

^ This is a town sequence.

[springlullaby]

BTW, the other charitable (non scum) motivation I could suppose out of ABR's play was that he was raising hell to see who was going to land in the net of terrible reasoning.
But his subsequent play during that whole day was chaotic and his reads don't align with mine in case it was what he was doing.