Idk. I wait to see how or what is said by the player to determine if i believe the claim.In post 999, Ame wrote:Yes, you believe their claim?
Why do you expect me to vote? It takes four to vote and I'm not ready to lynch.
do you mean in general or in this situation? in general i have tried a handful of approaches i have adapted from other players that seemed to work for them to see how they would work for me, as well as testing various theories about what i thought mafia would be likely to do. in this situation i am currently sorting through potential associatives between the group i am quite sure there is at least one scum within {popopopopopopo, porkens, farside} and the claims. i do not really think popopopopopopo/you makes sense because replacing out because of pressure from your partner seems odd unless the scum pt was actually toxic nor do i think porkens/bugspray makes sense because causing your partner to claim like that would be weird strategically and also felt unplanned between them.In post 997, Ame wrote:@Inu what do you think is the best way to catch scum Inu?
Tracker/doc can get a bit one sided but if scum have an RB it takes that out.In post 1006, Porkens wrote:So is there any kind of consensus on whether hider+tracker+doc is possible or is there one scum there?
probably something along the lines of your approach to me in reservoir dogs but more extreme; scumreading and pushing every single post i make individually and forcing me to explain my thought process behind each, which also makes it nearly impossible for me to play as town. if you were to take that approach to my slot every game regardless of whether or not you were actually scumreading me i think i would rather not play with you outside of hydras though.In post 1003, Ame wrote:Sorry I meant what’s the best way too catch you in particular as scum?
i think it's unlikely because things like hider claims target(town), doc protects target(town), mafia doesn't know about doc so they also choose the same target, the target is confirmed town because the hider didn't die, no night kill, doc doesn't have to claim and can now protect the confirmed town, all while tracker investigates can happen.In post 1006, Porkens wrote:So is there any kind of consensus on whether hider+tracker+doc is possible or is there one scum there?
What made you think he wasn't an alt thought?In post 368, gobbledygook wrote:He was an alt FYI but the immediate joining of this game makes me think alt. When people join not newbie games I think they are altsIn post 363, inutile wrote:what made you think exemplar was not an alt?In post 61, gobbledygook wrote:You are not an alt?
If I were to pick one I would say Bug only because so far he hasn't done anything to change my impression of him.In post 1009, Porkens wrote:So would you say it makes more sense to lynch in or out of PRs today?
I bolded the ones that make the most sense to me.In post 1015, Ame wrote:I'm going to see how many of these combinations I can eliminate
Bugs + Farsi
Bugs + Inu
Bugs + Pork
Bugs + popo
Bugs + Gobbles
Inu + Farsi
Inu + popo
popo + Farsi
popo + Pork
I have and I would. I'm waiting to see if bugs does anything to change my read while poking on pox7In post 1018, Porkens wrote:Sorry just to clarify; are you saying that you don’t lynch a claimed PR without a Cc except when they are as scummy as Bugs?
that was my failing as i said at the end of that game. it just isn't something i have any idea how to overcome beyond getting better/faster at determining alignments. had i felt you were town earlier or not allowed your push on me to stop me from what i was otherwise doing i might have been productive, but that isn't your fault for pushing me.In post 1014, Ame wrote:Sorry for ruining your game in RD Shiki ]:
how did you eliminate the rest of the combinations?In post 1015, Ame wrote:I'm going to see how many of these combinations I can eliminate
Bugs + Farsi
Bugs + Inu
Bugs + Pork
Bugs + popo
Bugs + Gobbles
Inu + Farsi
Inu + popo
popo + Farsi
popo + Pork
what was the content of it?In post 1021, Ame wrote:Sigh, there was a post Inu made but it has disappeared and now I am thinking it was something I read in a dream and not reality >:
No I have and would hammer a claimed PR in CCd if I thought or felt they were scum.In post 1019, farside22 wrote:I have and I would. I'm waiting to see if bugs does anything to change my read while poking on pox7In post 1018, Porkens wrote:Sorry just to clarify; are you saying that you don’t lynch a claimed PR without a Cc except when they are as scummy as Bugs?
Who has decided to be as invisible as bug is in this game.
Well there is another time I voted a PR claim that wasn't CC but something didn't add up with the claim or target.
Are you saying you don't lynch a claimed PR or never have?
No; too scummy to be scum would be the only thing. I guess I have a sliiiight empathy for mishammering as town but I will hammer bug If they get in range.In post 1020, farside22 wrote:Follow up to Pork: Do you really see anything town about bug?
In post 1016, farside22 wrote:If I were to pick one I would say Bug only because so far he hasn't done anything to change my impression of him.In post 1009, Porkens wrote:So would you say it makes more sense to lynch in or out of PRs today?
Sense lynching a claimed pr????? The only time I think about doing that is with a CC, a game that is role madness or if something doesn't make sense.
Played a mini recently that had 2 miller claims and an IC. This was all on day 1. The CC I legit felt was town but the player that claimed read town to me so I looked elsewhere. Most disagreed and I could see too many would WIFOM the claim with the CC. So lynched the claimed miller even though I felt he was town.
I was right he was town and so was the CC. So nothing to me is ever really that simple.
Ultimately it's about does that player read as scummy.
With bug? Yes.
With Ame? No
With GG? I'm leaning on no.