Newbie 2007: Air [game over!]

[LicketyQuickety]

I am personally all about letting to claims sort themselves and lynching Marashu, but I am probably a minority in that.

[Poyzin]

Okay RP, riddle me this. Why tf did you “track” Koba instead of me, if I was your top scumread and I quickhammer ed a vt? In what world is Koba a better target, or did you pull that out of your ass because you knew you couldn’t be proven wrong?

From an outsider, I might sound like a hypocrite, because I don’t have any helpful results besides RP’s scum confirmation, but I at least made it very obvious that I got a green result on Koba D2 (to the annoyance of everybody, including Koba). Here, RP has literally no motivation to track Koba instead of me, especially because I quickhammered jaiden and they flipped town.

[Red Panda]

Not really. Deadline was coming up as well you could have just had your partner execute the kill.

I'm not like others I don't have "top" reads. And if you didn't hammer I would have as I was going V/LA for the next two days anyway.

[Poyzin]

You didn’t answer my question.

[Poyzin]

Why did you “track” (I know you didn’t, but for the argument) Koba instead of me?

[Red Panda]

I did. You didn't like the answer.
I had a hunch Koha was your partner what part of this didn't you understand? You know in newbie games the other mafia member can perform both actions? Why check you to get a false clear? I was playing the associative game and took a gamble. Didn't pay off.

[Poyzin]

No, you didn’t. You didn’t have a good answer. You cannot clear people as the tracker as long as there are two people left, so “false clears” should have never been an issue, so you should’ve stuck on your top scumread in the case that they were the one to kill, assuming of course that you’re the Tracker. You’re not the Tracker, but it’s too late to undo what you said, so I’ll make you regret ever counterclaiming me when I’m actually a PR.

Either mafia member could’ve performed the kill. If you were the tracker, you don’t EVER track your scumread’s potential mate; you track your scumread, period. They should be more likely to be scum, and because either of them could perform the kill, you are more likely to actually get something useful from your top scumread than from the person who they could be partnered with. This is basic Tracker logic, and your reasoning is absurd from a town PoV. And, as icing on the cake, they mysteriously died when you ended up claiming, meaning they can’t verify anything that you said, be it right or wrong.



@Marashu, I did breadcrumb D1. I’ll get to it.

[votato]

im 90% certain that its marashu. if its quick its quick and RP. and i dont really like RP's claim that much, but i still like it better than poyzin's. if its RP shes distancing/busing. the simple, easy, and obvious choice is poyzin and marashu. thats what my read was yesterday, and nothing has happened to change it. Dk i guess decided in the end that they thought poyzin was town because they doc'd there... but if RP were paying attention she wouldnt fake claim that.
VOTE: poyzin. im not certain, but im certain that this is what im doing today. ill be very disappointed if im wrong and the scumteam wins by lurking, but i dont think im wrong.

[votato]

No, you didn’t. You didn’t have a good answer. You cannot clear people as the tracker as long as there are two people left, so “false clears” should have never been an issue, so you should’ve stuck on your top scumread in the case that they were the one to kill, assuming of course that you’re the Tracker. You’re not the Tracker, but it’s too late to undo what you said, so I’ll make you regret ever counterclaiming me when I’m actually a PR.

Either mafia member could’ve performed the kill. If you were the tracker, you don’t EVER track your scumread’s potential mate; you track your scumread, period. They should be more likely to be scum, and because either of them could perform the kill, you are more likely to actually get something useful from your top scumread than from the person who they could be partnered with. This is basic Tracker logic, and your reasoning is absurd from a town PoV. And, as icing on the cake, they mysteriously died when you ended up claiming, meaning they can’t verify anything that you said, be it right or wrong.



@Marashu, I did breadcrumb D1. I’ll get to it.

poyzin, your claim follows all the same logic. why not cop on marashu? you have no results, so why is your cop claim more believable than her tracker claim?

[Red Panda]

Vote: Poyzin

[Marashu]

VOTE: Poyzin

[Marashu]

First things first. Marashu is scum. I haven't read anything yet. I just know this to be true because after an extensive study of Marashu's genetic code it has been concluded that the particular makeup of their genome resulted in an emergent property of RNG magnetism. In layman's terms, it is not possible for a random number generator to determine Marashu's alignment to be anything other than scum.

[Datisi]

Official Vote Count 3.final

---

With 5 votes in play, it took 3 to lynch.

Lynching

Poyzin

(3): votato, Red Panda, Marashu

Red Panda

(1): Poyzin

Not Voting

(1): LicketyQuickety

Deadline:

(expired on 2020-06-22 12:15:00).

Mod notes:

• ...

[/area]

[Datisi]

day 3 lynch - poyzin

---

Poyzin has been lynched Day 3. He was a

Town Cop

.

Endgame incoming.

[/area]

[Datisi]

Mafia victory!

---

votato,

Vanilla Townie

, is killed in the Endgame.
LicketyQuickety,

Vanilla Townie

, is killed in the Endgame.

Marashu,

Mafia Roleblocker

, survives and wins.
Red Panda,

Mafia Goon

, survives and wins.

Congratulations to the Mafia for winning Newbie 2007: Air!

[/area]

[Datisi]

Links

• Public thread
  
• Mod PT
  
• Mafia PT
  
• Dead thread
  
• GeorgeBailey PT

day 1

• GeorgeBailey
  is lynched with 2 scum on his wagon.

night 1

• Red Panda
  is killing
  72offsuit
  .
  
• Marashu
  is Roleblocking
  DkKoba
  .
  
• DkKoba
  is Doctoring
  votato
  . (fails)
  
• Poyzin
  is Copping
  DkKoba
  . (returns: town)

day 2

• jaıdenbox
  is lynched with 1 scum on her wagon.

night 2

• Red Panda
  is killing
  DkKoba
  .
  
• Marashu
  is Roleblocking
  Poyzin
  .
  
• DkKoba
  is Doctoring
  votato
  .
  
• Poyzin
  is Copping
  Red Panda
  . (returns: NO RESULT)

day 3

• Poyzin
  is lynched with 2 scum on his wagon.

[Datisi]

Thank you everyone for playing, and a huge thank you to all the replacements who were willing to help out. All the PTs are now open, except for the Mafia PT, which will be open in about 48 hours, or sooner if the Mafia tells me if they want to redact anything.

The thread is now unlocked for post-game discussion.

[Red Panda]

Um holy shit. TEACHERS ISO WAS SO SCUMMY AS HELL I SHOULD HAVE BEEN KILLED DAY ONE. but seriously I'm really tired of working 50-55 hrs a week I'm a tired panda.

[Red Panda]

Votato - I'm sorry.

Poyzin - I would have played the way I would as a tracker. I wouldnt do it as a top scum read.

[Red Panda]

Open the mafia pt

[LicketyQuickety]

Well that sucks. I wonder what would have happened if we lynched Marash instead...

[Marashu]

GG - we had no reason to win that one.

Also, I was reading the mod PT during a work meeting and reading the memes made me laugh during the meeting, so.....

Also, no redactions, open the mafia PT

[Datisi]

Also, I was reading the mod PT during a work meeting and reading the memes made me laugh during the meeting, so.....

<3

Also, no redactions, open the mafia PT

Mafia PT is open!

[Marashu]

@Koba we had guessed you were cleared by cop; we weren't going to NK Poyzin because that would give a conftown going into LyLo, but NK'ing you and RBing him means he goes into D3 with no info. Why were you so keen on protecting votato? He was town, but I think mafia always keeps votato alive there.

[Marashu]

PS - I think I need some help on how to roll town. I keep getting it wrong. :V