Mish Mash Movie Mwatch Mnight

[NotAJumbleOfNumbers]

Knives Out, Inside Out, Despicable Me, The Secret Life Of Pets, Big Hero 6

[VashtaNeurotic]

Okay, had a weird technical difficulty with challonge but it's good now. Bracket looks like this (seeding is random as is the assortment of your films if you didn't give me a preference for them). Most anyone has in the bracket is 4 films and it looks like:


Bracket is available at: https://challonge.com/jhnuaonn

You do need a challonge account to vote but they're free. Open question to all, should my vote count AND break ties, only break ties or have it count and we have some other tie breaking procedure?

[xofelf]

Definitely you should get to vote. Dunno how I feel about your vote breaking ties. If movies go back into future brackets, I'm kinda okay with a coin flip breaking ties instead.

[VashtaNeurotic]

Just made a section of films that went into brackets and didn't win, if we ever run out of new films that will be drawn upon (and rather quickly it'll be the longer list).

[VashtaNeurotic]

Oh and reminder, you can still suiggest films for future brackets, just not THIS one. Chances are I'll start up another next Tuesday so there's always 2 running. Though maybe every other week would be better to avoid burnout?

[Skelda]

Will movies that don't win get added to a future bracket? Like maybe the top half or something continue?

[VashtaNeurotic]

Will movies that don't win get added to a future bracket? Like maybe the top half or something continue?

They'll be added back if we run out of completely new films and I feel at some point that'll just be well...all the films. If there is popular support to add them in before that point whether it be the top half or quarter or whatever, I am more than willing to change that as it's just my initial impression as what's the most fair and provides enough variety.

[McMenno]

who killed captain alex?

[Ariel]

it would be helpful if the year was included with the movie title so i know what I'm voting for

[VashtaNeurotic]

Oldboy should be the 2003 version, I don't think any other movies should have duplicates in that bracket but will double check that and the list

[Aurathebirb]

http://prntscr.com/t5d59w

Trainspotting and Primer both seemed like things I'd want to watch so that was a tough choice
Arrival was also a difficult non pick
Some film noir picks which is nice I'm into it
Brick is amazing get out of here with bad cgi dolphins xof

[xofelf]

Woah, hang on. The bad CGI dolphins are Meme's contribution. Please give me Brick over that monstrosity.

[Aurathebirb]

Im sorry xof i never said i could read

[xofelf]

Yeah that tracks.

[Aurathebirb]

Same bird color and everything wow

[VashtaNeurotic]

Made a feedback form to get a temperature check on the timing of brackets and what should get re-entered (if anything). Note that this form uses check-boxes so just select all options you are okay with.
Link: https://forms.gle/8MzU4Q3oLLKeTX8m7

[VashtaNeurotic]

Also added years to Brick (2005), Circle (2015) and Night Moves (2013).

When suggesting films, try to add the year if it's possible there's two versions.

[VashtaNeurotic]

Probably gonna add years to all unbracketed films to the best of my ability, if any of them are incorrect do tell me.

[VashtaNeurotic]

Bracket is updated:


Round 2 has begun. Also please fill out the feedback form linked below and in the OP.

edit: And the bracket link: https://challonge.com/jhnuaonn
feedback form: https://forms.gle/8MzU4Q3oLLKeTX8m7

[xofelf]

Let's go.

[Aurathebirb]

http://prntscr.com/t6mecv

bamanos

[VashtaNeurotic]

Definitely need to consider what the tiebreaker will be if two films have an even number of votes. Any thoughts? otherwise is might just be random, which doesn't sound ideal.

[NotAJumbleOfNumbers]

Definitely need to consider what the tiebreaker will be if two films have an even number of votes. Any thoughts? otherwise is might just be random, which doesn't sound ideal.

You break the tie

[McMenno]

make it random coward

[xofelf]

make it random coward