Newbie 2014: Aesthetic | Game Over

[keyenpeydee]

Vote count 2.03

---

[1] Anthony87

- votato,

[1] VexoOssa

- Town looter,

[4] Not Voting

- Anthony87, VexoOssa, brassherald, Lunatic, Mikul,

MOD NOTES

: Good luck!
With

7

alive, it takes

4

to lynch. Day Two will end in

(expired on 2020-07-04 00:00:00)

.
#BlackLivesMatter

[keyenpeydee]

VexoOssa has requested for a replacement. Anthony87 still has 3 hours to respond.

[keyenpeydee]

Nash replaces VexoOssa. Welcome!

Since Anthony87 hasn't posted in this thread for 5 days, I think it's logical to starting finding a replacement for him. If he responds within 3 hours assuming no one still has taken his slot, he may still play.

[Nash]

Hey everyone!
Can someone give me an unbiased tl;dr?

I'll read the game and post my thoughts later.

[Town looter]

In no particular order:

Mikul was happy then sad.
Porkens forgot about us, then remembered, helped out, then died.
Arthur went bonkers and probably won't play forum mafia ever again.
votato has been succinct.
Mutesa, Brass, Anthony and your slot have all been inactive.
Lunatic arrived and set off my PTSD.

Oh and there was some irrelevant stuff about trackers and jailkeepers along the way, but I wouldn't worry about that.

[Town looter]

Oh and VOTE: Nash

I think you are scum.

[brassherald]

People voting Anthony when Vox whatever did less yesterday smh.

VOTE: Nash

[brassherald]

Also, don't out PRs as a PR when you don't see someone visit the night kill, that's the only way you get a confirmed guilty as a tracker, ugh.

[Nash]

I skimmed through the pages and realised that post 27 wasn't perceived well.

Nice to meet yall!! I know we can't stay friendly forever,

but not having to choose a solid vote is pretty calming.

The dice say Vote: mutesa1

nothing against you m8 just had to do something..

It's pretty obvious that the alignment known to have a problem with choosing a solid vote and urge to

do something

is the mafia, and any sane player would know this. To think that scum!Vexo typed that down and didn't feel even a tiny urge to scrutinise is a stretch, don't you think? I know for a fact that this slot is town and I can assure you that this is an authentic

case of TStBS

. Normally I wouldn't adopt a defensive tone like this, but we will lose both of our PRs with no extra information if we carry out a mislynch (assuming no CCs - A1).

Obviously the best move for scum at the moment would be to join the Nash wagon, and I'm confident that there's scum in {Town Looter, brassherald, ArthurConyl}.
Based on vote progression alone, I'll go for Town Looter for now. I can spot a scum agenda there.

I'm fairly convinced that votato is town.
If any of you have cases on one of the three, I'm all ears.

[Nash]

VOTE: Town Looter

[Nash]

People voting Anthony when Vox whatever did less yesterday smh.

VOTE: Nash

I'm sorry, but this is just BS.
If you are town, I'd suggest more caution. Try again.
The hypocritical vote isn't going to save you if you are scum.

[Lunatic]

ok i gues ill defer to mikul and lunatic since they were both in that game with you and know you better. but i still think brass is the best lynch today.

We were scum in that one together, and he was town. But his posts were very different from how they are here. First of all he was much less active and excited about the game. And most of his posts read as null to the other townies, which is ultimately how he got mislynched to win us the game. But yeah, he could have just learned from that game or something, but his posts are much more frequent here. I suspect he's more excited maybe from getting scum? I don't know.

[Lunatic]

As far as you are concerned, yes, but I don't see why you guys have cleared votat

He's not cleared 100%. But the logic is, as scum, it seems best to make one person carry out both the night kill and the roleblock so you have less people to potentially show up on tracker results. That means one scum gets burned instead of 2. Of course we have no way of knowing for sure if mafia are experienced enough to do that as a strategy, but it is assumed most logical scum teams would operate with that in mind. If that's the case, it looks really good for Votato being jailkept (roleblocked) and a kill still went through. At the very least he didn't carry out the night kill. That clears him as 50% not scum in my mind. I go further with it based on behavior though.

[Lunatic]

Also, don't out PRs as a PR when you don't see someone visit the night kill, that's the only way you get a confirmed guilty as a tracker, ugh.

Thanks for the massive bit of contribution here. I've explained why in detail I did this, and was tempted to even when I thought mikul was town. You are welcome to dis-agree with the benefits of the POE that you are conveniently in btw.

[Lunatic]

@ Mikul what do you think of Brassherald and his vote?

[Lunatic]

Obviously the best move for scum at the moment would be to join the Nash wagon, and I'm confident that there's scum in {Town Looter, brassherald, ArthurConyl}.

ArthurConyl is dead, I assume you mean anthony.

[Mikul]

VOTE: Herald


I'm going with my gut off this but go his page and click view posts. Look at his activity in the other game vs this one. It's not AI since I don't know what he is in the other game and since we can't discuss it but there is a huge difference in his posting patterns there vs here. I'd also wager it's because he drew scum and has an innactive partner.

[Mikul]

I also think an se would be more likely to target porkens

[Lunatic]

Im cool with it.

I would have expected a lot more post from an SE that just a quick quip and vote for the seemingly easy nash wasgon.

VOTE: BrassHerald

[brassherald]

I'm not here as an SE to play the game for you, I'm here to help you get better at the game.

So, get better.

[Lunatic]

I'm not here as an SE to play the game for you, I'm here to help you get better at the game.

So, get better.

I'll settle for just lynching you, oh wise one.

[brassherald]

I'm terrified.

[Mikul]

I'm not here as an SE to play the game for you, I'm here to help you get better at the game.

So, get better.

If you are here for people to get better , your lack of contribution is directly prohibiting that because anyone in their right mind would read that as scummy. Throwing out one line zingers and having nothing of value to add to the conversation while directly being active and engaged in another game is not "helping people learn"

You don't have a read, have not explained a read , nor have you posted anything of value. Why should we not lynch you ?

[brassherald]

I can give you some reads if you really want, but it seems like I had been filed into the scum pile purely for not posting when I was VLA and also not posting during a low content Day 1.

I refuse to waste my own time, and from what I can see "active lurking" aka, not being on the site 24/7 or most weekends, has gotten me a scum read I'm not going to shake with any posts, so why bother?

[Mikul]

I can give you some reads if you really want, but it seems like I had been filed into the scum pile purely for not posting when I was VLA and also not posting during a low content Day 1.

I refuse to waste my own time, and from what I can see "active lurking" aka, not being on the site 24/7 or most weekends, has gotten me a scum read I'm not going to shake with any posts, so why bother?

Did I not say you were vla? That's not why I scum read you or anyone scum read you.