Err excuse me I had like a thousand posts that game or something?In post 722, NorwegianboyEE wrote:If C9++
That one where you replaced out immediately.In post 726, Menalque wrote:Also I don’t think I ever rolled scum against you in a newbie @norwee?
Oh, that was illness, that really shouldn’t be considered representative of my meta. That probably would have been a high effort game if I hadn’t gotten illIn post 727, NorwegianboyEE wrote:That one where you replaced out immediately.In post 726, Menalque wrote:Also I don’t think I ever rolled scum against you in a newbie @norwee?
jezz its scary how quickly ur learning to read me >_<In post 722, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I think you both are quite easy to read for me at this point tbh, and i'm ready to just settle on both of you being town.
If C9++ and that newbie game i had with Mena are any indication then he is lazy as scum. Here he actually efforts.
Alisae mostly agenda posts as scum, not what they're doing here.
Okay but mechanics are boring and so I’m happy to let others try to solve the question of how we split resources and what we do about inspectionsIn post 724, Something_Smart wrote:Okay I reread your plan in 420 (nice, btw). I think that a world where the tomboy daughter gets a majority vote, official or unofficial, is not a world we're winning in anyway. Letting NK15 veto executions might work but it probably won't? If we did, he'd have to come up with the right percentage of the time to randomly veto a non-daughter execution (probably 1/15).
Your plan doesn't fix the main problem, which is the chance of the daughter being caught with tea (or equivalently, the chance that NK has to reject an inspection because the daughter is on it). That chance should be zero. Not sure whether inspecting one or two people is best, but either way NK should have full control over who is inspected. Inspecting someone who is likely tomorrow's execution isn't really bad because like I said if that person is the daughter, we were in hot water anyway.
Also there's something to be said about the difference between tons of posts VS effort. They aren't always mutually exclusive imo.In post 725, Menalque wrote:Err excuse me I had like a thousand posts that game or something?
EbwopIn post 732, Menalque wrote:Okay but mechanics are boring and so I’m happy to let others try to solve the question of how we split resources and what we do about inspectionsIn post 724, Something_Smart wrote:Okay I reread your plan in 420 (nice, btw). I think that a world where the tomboy daughter gets a majority vote, official or unofficial, is not a world we're winning in anyway. Letting NK15 veto executions might work but it probably won't? If we did, he'd have to come up with the right percentage of the time to randomly veto a non-daughter execution (probably 1/15).
Your plan doesn't fix the main problem, which is the chance of the daughter being caught with tea (or equivalently, the chance that NK has to reject an inspection because the daughter is on it). That chance should be zero. Not sure whether inspecting one or two people is best, but either way NK should have full control over who is inspected. Inspecting someone who is likely tomorrow's execution isn't really bad because like I said if that person is the daughter, we were in hot water anyway.
I think this setup is highly scumsided (my suspicion) so I’m kind of not expecting to win that much
The main thing is: is NK choosing between the two scummiest people on each day the best way to avoid executing the tomboy daughter without giving info on their identity? Which should be doable so long as NK doesn’t give out reads and thereby indicate whether he actively chose one person > the other or because he flipped a coin. If this isn’t the best way to solve the executing part of the problem, what is?
I high efforted that game! I counter claimed skitter as a vig and then retracted and then spent a LONG ASS TIME pushing the execution of neither of the claimed cops while somehow not becoming obvscum for doing so! That was very clearly a game where I efforted! It’s like my 4th most efforted scumgame!In post 735, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Also there's something to be said about the difference between tons of posts VS effort. They aren't always mutually exclusive imo.In post 725, Menalque wrote:Err excuse me I had like a thousand posts that game or something?
I’m trying but Maki did have a point and I’m already at 125 posts and while I’m ready to get some votes on notscience and maxwell and get some blood flowing from a good ole guillotine I’m not sure everyone else is, and I’m trying not to drown the thread too hard with my postingIn post 740, Alisae wrote:maybe you should channel that energy into this game so you could win this towngame >_>
who caresIn post 743, Menalque wrote:Maki did have a point and I’m already at 125 posts
The only way to avoid executing the tomboy daughter without giving any information away is for NK to randomize something to execute. The more randomness involved, the less information we give away. So if we offer up two and NK randomly picks one, that's twice as good as if we just execute one and pray.In post 736, Menalque wrote:is NK choosing between the two scummiest people on each day the best way to avoid executing the tomboy daughter without giving info on their identity?
It wasn't actually a gotcha, I wanted to know if you were confident you could easily read Datisi or were talking out your ass (and honestly, you might've been on to something).In post 668, GuiltyLion wrote:I'm not especially confident in my "meta" (if you can even call it that - I was more operating from a vibecheck perspective than like an actual Discerning Meta Analysis Thesis of how Datisi plays as either alignment), it's just the first impression I had and the first push I wanted to make. The question to me feels like a gotcha question rather than something maxwell is genuinely interested in, cause I think it should have been clear from how I was posting already roughly how 'confident' I was in it:
You're too late for that.In post 743, Menalque wrote:I’m trying not to drown the thread too hard with my posting
In post 742, Alisae wrote:mena don't get ahead of yourself
u still got a lot to learn and if I can figure out you were scum by the end of d1 in TM then you still got a ways to go
Also no offence but even if you did figure it out N1 after that I’m pretty sure you weren’t winning if you tried to force it 1v1 on D2In post 1984, Alisae wrote:also, I don't think anyone in my townbloc is to worry
maybe Mena but I don't think so.