Smuggler's Port [Game Over]

[maxwell]

WE GOT ONE. Hopefully this means people can calm down a little, end of day yesterday was really painful. We get to play mafia! Thank fuck.

ship wheat
Execute maki

Not executing nk is absolutely the wrong play but fuck it might as well hand the game over to scum

This isn't the post of someone who knows they're about to get guiltied.

This is a bad pool that I don't understand. Iconeum, I suggest you reconsider.

This is.

Vote: Moment

I

think

the play here is to execute one and inspect one of the remaining two, then we have a guaranteed hit tomorrow and can select a new pool based on the flips. Alternately we could submit a new one now but we'd be working with less info/reducing suspects right away which I'm not sure I like but it does give us more flexibility for checks down the line.

[Menalque]

I think if we really did want to investigate there again after notscience flipping scum would be a (datisi, norwee) pool

[Menalque]

Although I guess if not science flips town a solo invest on one or the other would be good

[Something_Smart]

Why did you not confirm yourself Icon

[GuiltyLion]

I think that’s a waste if notscience flips town probably

VOTE: notscience

uhh, what? If notscience flips town it guarantees we find the scum in the other two

[GuiltyLion]

Why did you not confirm yourself Icon

am I missing something? I don't see why confirming himself there matters

[Menalque]

I think that’s a waste if notscience flips town probably

VOTE: notscience

uhh, what? If notscience flips town it guarantees we find the scum in the other two

Well yeah, exactly? Why are we using it on a solo invest when we could be adding one extra? It’s also partly because I still think datisi is town and I think moment is town

Hmm, actually yeah, you have a point in that moment is probably more town than dats

[Menalque]

Oh wait, right, I meant it notscience flips scum, my bad

In that case I think it’s a waste to invest dats solo as I think notscience!scum probably means datisi!town and moment!town

[GuiltyLion]

hmm actually thinking about maxwell's post I guess notscience is never scum with nk (clearly) whereas if Moment is scum, he benefits regardless of nk's alignment bc if nk is scum he lives longer with Moment's defense and if nk is town he looks hella bad on a Moment scumflip combined with the fakeclaim and probably gets miseliminated anyway

[maxwell]

We're not re-investigating people in a new pool because if we miss today we learn nothing new, we either solo investigate today as a contingency or do an all-new group to investigate. My thinking is if we wait until tomorrow for a new pool we can do it based on associations with confirmed scum rather than guessing blindly still.

I think notscience

probably

doesn't pitch as huge a fit yesterday knowing he's about to be caught as scum but that's just my instinct and it was yesterday as it was happening. Could be crazy wrong though. I'm just going to trust Mena on Datisi here.

[Alisae]

I like this maxwell post
VOTE: maxwell

[Alisae]

WAIT NO WRONG VOTE IM SORRY
VOTE: moment

[Something_Smart]

am I missing something? I don't see why confirming himself there matters

I mean there is absolutely zero reason not to

[Menalque]

I think notscience probably doesn't pitch as huge a fit yesterday knowing he's about to be caught as scum

Err

Why not?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Last day's lynch was ass. Can we do better today?

[Radical Rat]

Okay, absolutely bonkers idea here, buuuut

Iconeum/NK15/notscience scumteam.

[Umlaut]

WE GOT ONE. Hopefully this means people can calm down a little, end of day yesterday was really painful. We get to play mafia! Thank fuck.

ship wheat
Execute maki

Not executing nk is absolutely the wrong play but fuck it might as well hand the game over to scum

This isn't the post of someone who knows they're about to get guiltied.

This is a bad pool that I don't understand. Iconeum, I suggest you reconsider.

This is.

Vote: Moment

This is an excellent point. I was intending to vote notscience today if we found tea, but I need to think about it now. I did like a lot of Moment's posts yesterday but if I try to imagine him as scum I could sort of see him still being able to make those posts.

Going to think and read more before voting. If nothing else we don't want anyone getting executed before we have a good shipping and inspection plan.

[Umlaut]

Okay, absolutely bonkers idea here, buuuut

Iconeum/NK15/notscience scumteam.

I'm happy to entertain bonkers ideas, but I really can't imagine the PA not outing if this were the case.

[Something_Smart]

Last day's lynch was ass. Can we do better today?

No

[Something_Smart]

Okay, absolutely bonkers idea here, buuuut

Iconeum/NK15/notscience scumteam.

Inb4 this is a PA soft

[Menalque]

Okay, absolutely bonkers idea here, buuuut

Iconeum/NK15/notscience scumteam.

This is literally losing if you think about it for more than like 5 seconds

Unless this is a memepost in which case, ehh 3/10

[Menalque]

I may have an incorrect model of moment in my head but I thought their posting yesterday was overall v town

I’ll look again at their and notscience’s reactions to being in the pool though (and datisi’s I guess?)

[Something_Smart]

I don't see what was towny about Moment if NK is town.

[Umlaut]

hmm actually thinking about maxwell's post I guess notscience is never scum with nk (clearly) whereas if Moment is scum, he benefits regardless of nk's alignment bc if nk is scum he lives longer with Moment's defense and if nk is town he looks hella bad on a Moment scumflip combined with the fakeclaim and probably gets miseliminated anyway

If my hypothesis is correct that NK15 is scum who claimed PA without realizing the consequences, then I could easily see a scum!notscience deciding to throw them under the bus as quickly and definitely as possible on the assumption he's going down anyway. Is there a reason his play yesterday couldn't be explained in that way?

[NorwegianboyEE]

VOTE: Datisi