Mini Normal 2148 (Post Game)

[Not_Mafia]

Tempted to lynch NPOM because his posting is just that bad

[NoPowerOverMe]

Uh oh, the mafia wants to lynch me. I'm quivering.

[NoPowerOverMe]

NM is understandably upset that his scum gambit didn't work.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I'm not claiming a guilty on anyone.

This doesn't explain why you think NM is scummier than bob simply because he was on two exec wagons

[NoPowerOverMe]

I see it as too convenient.

[NoPowerOverMe]

Also if NM was town I don't think he would be on tilt, I think he would try to offer a more reasonable explanation.

[Not_Mafia]

It's "too convenient" to be on the first 2 lynch wagons? I was only even on Geraint as a deadline lynch and consistently tried to still get the Porkens slot lynched

[NoPowerOverMe]

Your guilty is convenient, not your voting history.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

bob why aren't you voting for NM?

[Not_Mafia]

You don't find bob's claim too convenient?

[NoPowerOverMe]

What's unreasonable about being a vanilla cop?

[maxwell]

I'm not voting bob without a claim from another investigative role given likely distributions of power in the setup.

bob3141 - cop
Looker (HK 50 Truth ) - town (cop result)
DoctorPepper - town (cop result)

Not_Mafia - JOAT

Leaving:
Cat Scratch Fever (Ghost Ganster stungun0404)
Green Crayons
farside22
NoPowerOverMe (votato)

He claimed vanilla cop, not cop. It likely fits thematically with the other PRs in the setup. We have 2 known roles with the simple modifier which only works on vanilla players. Also I'm still in the game last I checked.

[NoPowerOverMe]

@maxwell, what makes you think there is another investigative role?

[bob3141]

You were a feasible lynch for tomorrow but not the most likely, now, you're the most likely

So now your rowing back on my likelyhood of being lynched.

Even if you though i was a likely lynch. Woudnt you still if you were town visited someone else. You claim you could of got me lynched with out a result. Yet you didnt visit someoen you though was scum yet couldnt be lynched. If you were geuine i would have though you would have visied soemoen else and claim a inno/guility and claim a guility on me from night one. If you were town. If you were that sure i was scum. Instead you used an action on player you claim to have been sure was scum before the night even started.

Where you that unsure on me that that you had double check me. Yet the way you posted would imply you were 100% set on me beign scum.


And ive only seen scum use words like feasible about lynches. So your in fact saying you thought although possible to get me lynched, if i had revealed i was a pr before you faked your guility. You wouldnt of been able to get me lynched. Thus you would leave a town pr alive.

Again i keep comign back to teh fact if you were town and thought as you say "feasible". Wouldnt you have first tried to run me up and get a claim. Hoping to catch me out as I tried to do with hk slot. To see if he would fake claim a town pr. Even though his role day 2 could only have been vt or goon



VOTE: Nm

Every way i look at it i cant see you being fellow town pr.

[DoctorPepper]

Couldn't NM be a mafia rolecop claiming gunsmith for towncred?

Yeah but isn't this a risky play as it says GC is a liar as well for confirming they're neighbors?

More inclined to see NM as the JOAT role rather than a fake claim just because it endangers two potential scum?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

bob you keep saying you wanted to push HK50 to a claim yesterday, but you weren't voting HK50 until like 2 days before deadline

[Cat Scratch Fever]

GC/NM aren't neighbors. GC confirmed he received mail from NM on night 1

[DoctorPepper]

Are we choosing bet. Bob and NM? Can see a world where both claims are true but I'm inclined to believe NM more just because GC vouched.

Bob why did you investigate me N2?

P-Edit: okay my bad. I miss read that. Still, I'd be more inclined to believe that as a town role since it's functionally a fruit vendor

[NoPowerOverMe]

I was going to vote NM before the claim. The way I see it, GC only vouches for him being a neighborizor, not any other part of his role.

[NoPowerOverMe]

Ok, well if not neighbors, then some sort of similar mechanic.

[Not_Mafia]

Mailman

NPOM are you even reading?

[maxwell]

@maxwell, what makes you think there is another investigative role?

Normal setup power distributions. As it stands now if our only power roles are 2-shot simple vig + simple doctor + JOAT that's an exceedingly weak town and unlikely to pass review for balance.

Think it's very likely though that it's an all-goon scumteam because of this though.

[maxwell]

Mailman

NPOM are you even reading?

I'm not sure he's read a single word in the thread.

[Not_Mafia]

Or two goons and a mafia doctor; fits with the gunsmith and simple vig, possibly

I ran Neapolitan + Two Masons with an all goon scum team once. 2-shot simple vig, simple doctor and JOAT seems reasonable against 3 goons

[maxwell]

Mafia doctor would mean the vig is likely to only kill town which would be a shit setup. Setups seem to have more power in them now when I last played, I can go through recent games as a reference.