Mini Normal 2148 (Post Game)

[NoPowerOverMe]

Yep, I'm guilty of bad form. Not guilty of being scum. I think my reasoning is pretty solid however, even though I have no way of convincing anyone of my towniness.

[DoctorPepper]

I could go for Maxwell today actually

We should have done that yesterday

[DoctorPepper]

VOTE: Maxwell

FOS: DoctorPepper

This is a weird pair considering my general gimmick of "Maxwell is scum"

[DoctorPepper]

What an odd kill, it's almost as if mafia have some sort of rolecop

Did you really need a Rolecop tho? She claimed PR lol.

Was thinking she was trying to bait out a kill (could have been PGO or BP) but apparently she wasnt

[Not_Mafia]

lol I forgot she claimed PR, I'm a dumbutt

[DoctorPepper]

lol I forgot she claimed PR, I'm a dumbutt

I'm sure you're town so I trust you.

Who do you think needs to go today, I'm willing to sheep

[maxwell]

That is a really scummy post.

[Not_Mafia]

I wanna hear from GC first

[Green Crayons]

I need to reread because, between replacements and the long delays, I really don't know anything.

[Green Crayons]

Is this really YOLO? If so, mass claim is optimal play, right?

[DoctorPepper]

We have like 2 Vanillas, a dead PR and a JOAT

[DoctorPepper]

Oh and a vanilla cop

[bob3141]

I vannilla copped powers last night but got no result. At first I thought scum had roleblocked me but seeing cats flip. It's more likely that cat simply roleblocked me last night. Even if all it did was stop a fellow townie verifying powers role claim.

[maxwell]

Why'd you cop a claimed VT?

[maxwell]

Nvm, reading is tech. don't think it was the best play regardless since a goon would likely claim VT, but it is what it is.


So I'll lay out what I've been holding onto:

I am the Town Simple Doctor

. This makes me confirmed town via moderator error. I assume no one is likely to counterclaim. Unfortunately, my role became totally useless when other power roles out - I really wish CSF had not claimed yesterday. Feel free to discuss your hypothetical scumteams with this knowledge.

[bob3141]

To see if they were scum fake claiming vt. If he came up not vannilla i would have know for sure he was scum lying about being a pr.

Alternative was nm who if he was scum. Would certainly come up not vannilla as he already claimed to have sent a message to green. Which green confirmed so at the very least he is mailman. So wouldnt learn anything there

already visited dp. And you, cat and green had been town reads at point

[bob3141]

And seeing the fact that cat was a odd night pr and not full pr. Im inclined to beleive nm is town. As it does leave a hole in town pr if he is scum.

By my guesstimation even if we faced a full team of goons

Vanilla cop
2 shot simple vig
Simple doc
Odd night roleblocker
Plus if nm role is a joat.


a scum nm would leave us short of town power

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: NPOM

Shouldn't have backed out of this yesterday

[maxwell]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p11919854

Vote Count 1.12

clidd

(6): Not_Mafia, Green Crayons,

stungun0404

,

Malakittens

, bob3141, votato

Dunnstral

(4): DoctorPepper,

farside22

,

HK 50

,

notscience

Green Crayons (1):

clidd

notscience

(1):

geraintm

Not_Mafia (1):

Dunnstral

Not voting (0):

How much faith do people here put in VCA?

[NoPowerOverMe]

Why is it mod error?

[maxwell]

I made an error with the Night 1 role flip. notscience was incorrectly flipped as a Tiwn Simple Doctor, and was supposed to flip as a Town 2-shot Simple Vigilante. I'm sorry for how this will affect the game, but after reviewing with a Listmod I've decided to continue the game. Thank you for your patience.

The deadline has been unpaused and will end in (expired on 2020-07-08 08:05:34).

Mod posted the wrong flip for notscience after night 1 at first, thereby confirming the existence of my role in the setup.

(the most annoying thing about this is I tried to protect notscience night 1, and if my role weren't so crappy we'd be in a much better position)

[DoctorPepper]

Why does this assume that the mod flip was because of a role in this game being revealed?

Are we supposed to take this at face value!

[DoctorPepper]

Plus nothing in your posting post mod flip indicates that you felt there was a mod error compromising your role entirely.

Idk, I would have guessed that you wouldn't have posted in the thread and contacted the mod instead

[maxwell]

Do you think it is likely for a moderator to post the flip of a role that is not in their setup? Do you think the accidental reveal of a role not in the game would warrant a thread lock of several days and a consultation with the listmod? This is stretching things beyond credulity.

Truth be told, I didn't bat an eye at his role flipping identical to mine at first - I thought it was possible it might be doubled up because it's a fairly weak role. Why would I publicly react in such a fashion, anyway? To do so would be giving my role away, for no good reason. I had

planned

to do a crumb upon replacing in, but after the reveal, why bother? any clues could only be helpful to scum. This was, however, why I asserted you pushing on me yesterday would end badly for you - really you should've been lynched a long time ago.

I think you're scum that is scared I'm no longer an avenue to push.

[Micc]

.