Newbie 2019 | Game Over!

Redados · Post Post #725 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 3:14 pm

In post 717, ItalianoVD wrote:As a matter of fact I don’t like the doubt that you seem to be brewing.

I'll brew whatever I want, we limmed scum, this is how I feel right now:

In post 510, SJReaver wrote:

shellyc · Post Post #726 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 3:16 pm

Hello, hello here we go. Salutations to another day. Also YESSS, we got the scum yesterday!

T-Bone, are you saying because of the "correct" kill made, an SE is more likely to be scum? (i dont know what correct means)
I feel like Italiano is pretty much locked town here. His posts are coming from a townie mindset in my opinion, and he was TR by SJR.
Red in 713, you put it like Porkens is the only guy that needs to scumhunt. This isn't true, it's our shared objective.

At the start of the game I TR Porkens, because I tend to see aggressive people as town.
But after a bit of reading, I feel like aggressive =/= town, and scum can feign it.
I think Porkens might be a good lynch today, but i'd like to see his defense.

Redados · Post Post #727 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 3:22 pm

In post 726, shellyc wrote:Hello, hello here we go. Salutations to another day. Also YESSS, we got the scum yesterday!

T-Bone, are you saying because of the "correct" kill made, an SE is more likely to be scum? (i dont know what correct means)
I feel like Italiano is pretty much locked town here. His posts are coming from a townie mindset in my opinion, and he was TR by SJR.
Red in 713, you put it like Porkens is the only guy that needs to scumhunt. This isn't true, it's our shared objective.

At the start of the game I TR Porkens, because I tend to see aggressive people as town.
But after a bit of reading, I feel like aggressive =/= town, and scum can feign it.
I think Porkens might be a good lynch today, but i'd like to see his defense.

I'm not speaking for T-Bone, but SJReaver was the correct kill imo. If someone is lock town like SJReaver was, then they're the correct kill.

I've towntunneled Italiano pretty hard at this point, I would be really surprised if he were scum. I'm not sure if SJR or GG's reads clear people necessarily, what clears Italiano for me was him hammering Word.

Pretend #713 was replaced with the contents of #722, that's more of what I meant to convey there.

shellyc · Post Post #728 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 3:29 pm

I like Red a lot here. He's not in my lynchpool. He has posted a few long posts analysing various aspects. I feel like scum wouldn't have the motivation to do this.

Porkens, Mini, possibly T-Bone? would be my lynches.
Also you TR T-Bone in post 701 but put him in lynchpool in post 723. That's contradictory.

My reads: (in order from town -> scum)

GeniusGamer

ItalianoVD

Redados

T-Bone

MiniMegabyte

Porkens

Redados · Post Post #729 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 3:32 pm

In post 728, shellyc wrote:Also you TR T-Bone in post 701 but put him in lynchpool in post 723. That's contradictory.

723 is my lynchpool

only

in regards to the post I'm quoting. AKA who do I think could be scum if I was basing it only on who died last night. Hence, including myself. I would never actually eliminate myself.

shellyc · Post Post #730 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 3:35 pm

Noted with thanks Redados. I missed the NKA part.

ISO · Post Post #731 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:20 pm

Yes, that is what I meant by correct kill.

ISO · Post Post #732 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:24 pm

I think Shelly also towntold over and over again. So really the lim-pool from my perspective is just Porkens and Redados. Outside chance on Minimegabyte simply because I can't think of a single thing they've done all game. That's not a knock, that's good strategy considering if they are indeed scum.

Lock townread on Genius obviously. I think Italino and Shelly have both townslipped.

ISO · Post Post #733 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:25 pm

Red, why didn't you even consider GeniusGamer to be the correct kill when you spoke of it in #727?

Redados · Post Post #734 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:35 pm

In post 733, T-Bone wrote:Red, why didn't you even consider GeniusGamer to be the correct kill when you spoke of it in #727?

I'm not trying to be mean or disparaging with what I have to say:

SJR and GG were both lock town. SJR helped the town more than GG. Therefore SJR was the correct kill.

ISO · Post Post #735 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:44 pm

You're too good, and that's why I've narrowed it down to two.

shellyc · Post Post #736 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:50 pm

Hmmm. Where do you consider me to have "townslipped"? I don't know what you mean. But it's nice to see you reading me as townie.

shellyc · Post Post #737 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:52 pm

In post 735, T-Bone wrote:You're too good, and that's why I've narrowed it down to two.

Is stating the correct NK townie? I think thats NAI in my opinion

ISO · Post Post #738 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 4:57 pm

No, I'm saying that if it isn't Porkens as the last scum, it's because it is Redados.

Redados · Post Post #739 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 5:13 pm

In post 735, T-Bone wrote:You're too good, and that's why I've narrowed it down to two.

are you... pocketing me????

(am I using that word right?)

In post 736, shellyc wrote:Hmmm. Where do you consider me to have "townslipped"? I don't know what you mean. But it's nice to see you reading me as townie.

You townslipped when you asked why SJR was the "correct" kill

In post 738, T-Bone wrote:No, I'm saying that if it isn't Porkens as the last scum, it's because it is Redados.

I haven't rolled scum in forum mafia/werewolf yet, but IRL in the Resistance/SH etc I talk a lot and don't shut up when I'm the on the good guys, and I stay pretty quiet and laid back when I'm one of the bad guys. I'm starting to find my playstyle here online and it's a combination of stream of conscienceless and big analytical posts. Not sure if I could pull this off if I were scum.

MiniMegabyte · Post Post #740 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 5:53 pm

Hello to you all, I forgot the day had started my bad. I do want to ask the question as to why a lot of people are scum reading Porkens?

MiniMegabyte · Post Post #741 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 5:53 pm

I care on to update my thoughts and things the other day to realise day had ended. Great job on getting scum though! Now let’s hope we can find the partner

shellyc · Post Post #742 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:09 pm

In post 740, MiniMegabyte wrote:I do want to ask the question as to why a lot of people are scum reading Porkens?

PoE, NKA, how his posts are NAI

Porkens · Post Post #743 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:16 pm

Hey y'all. I've read through Micc and Word, and then reread with each potential partner. I will do a little writeup later tonight before I got to bed. For now, here are my raw notes:

Spoiler:

Redados · Post Post #744 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:31 pm

In post 743, Porkens wrote: —MiccWord and T-Bone—
Votes micc
Calls micc scummy
Calls micc scummy again
Calls micc scummy again

lmao

In post 742, shellyc wrote:
In post 740, MiniMegabyte wrote:I do want to ask the question as to why a lot of people are scum reading Porkens?
PoE, NKA, how his posts are NAI

I'll elaborate on this for you, Mini.

1. PoE (process of elimination). This isn't 100% a factor for me, but if you re-read my post 701, I make the case that if we go strictly by votecount, either you (MiniMega) or Porkens is the mafia. Of course, that's not how this works, but it's a factor!

2. NKA (something about Night Kill). The argument here is that only about four players would have night-killed SJReaver, including Porkens (I make this argument in post 723).

3. How his posts are NAI (Not Alignment Indicative). I talk about this in post 722. Basically, I can't tell if Porkens is town or mafia.

None of these things makes me go, "Porkens must be the spy." But when you look at them all together, it makes me want to vote for him and see what he has to say.

Redados · Post Post #745 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:31 pm

I just looked in the wiki and NKA stands for "night kill analysis," for anyone else like me who didn't know that one

MiniMegabyte · Post Post #746 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:49 pm

744 Okay that’s understandable I did get on and see that word321 was being voted but I didn’t vote as when I got on they were at E-1 and no claim had been made from them. When I got the time to jump back on site they had been eliminated and it was night time so if you like I can post my reads since the confirmation of the two masons and the elimination of word321

Redados · Post Post #747 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:57 pm

In post 746, MiniMegabyte wrote:744 Okay that’s understandable I did get on and see that word321 was being voted but I didn’t vote as when I got on they were at E-1 and no claim had been made from them. When I got the time to jump back on site they had been eliminated and it was night time so if you like I can post my reads since the confirmation of the two masons and the elimination of word321

Please post a reads list, more information is good!

In regards to (1), now that T-Bone has posted his night kill analysis, I don't think that you (MiniMegabyte) are mafia.

My reads list-

Town:
GeniusGamer
Redados

Convincing Town:
T-Bone
ItalianoVD

New Town:
ShellyC
MiniMegabyte

Scum?:
Porkens

This is evolving and it's totally possible that I'm tunneling here. Also possibly sheeping because I honestly had not really thought more about the night kill until T-Bone said something.

MiniMegabyte · Post Post #748 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 7:01 pm

Okay so i'm not exactly scum-reading anyone but there are 2 people that I haven't been able to really make a decision on. I have a pretty good idea though that the people listed under town are in fact town.

Town
Italiano
Shelly
Tbone
Mini
GenuisGamer

Unsure
Porkens
Redados

shellyc · Post Post #749 (ISO) » Mon Jul 27, 2020 7:16 pm

In post 728, shellyc wrote:I like Red a lot here. He's not in my lynchpool. He has posted a few long posts analysing various aspects. I feel like scum wouldn't have the motivation to do this.

Porkens, Mini, possibly T-Bone? would be my lynches.
Also you TR T-Bone in post 701 but put him in lynchpool in post 723. That's contradictory.

My reads: (in order from town -> scum)

GeniusGamer

ItalianoVD

Redados

T-Bone

MiniMegabyte

Porkens

Might change porkens to purple zone after that post