Mini Theme 2155: SIN: This Impurity must be Cleansed!

[Dumb and Dumber]

if it's like literally 5 to vote out i'd switch to jackel for y'all but like under duress and protest

- Dumber

[BananaCucho]

I don't understand how you townread Jackel and scum read Star

I don't really townread jackel

I just don't scumread her, whereas I actively scumread star

I don't understand why you're giving Jackel a pass

She's not even coming back probably. She's a cooked goose

[BananaCucho]

Literally rolling over

[Dumb and Dumber]

I feel like we're basically talking past each other
we're basically scumreading our respective scumreads for the exact same reasons, but for some reason that's manifesting as jackel-first to you and star-first to me

the thing is that i'm willing to acknowledge that jackel is doing the exact same thing as star and that she's in my poe pool too (hence why i'd switch if we need five voters cuz we won't get anywhere otherwise) but i'm baffled that you're all but ignoring star

like i don't think jackel is town and i'm not giving her a pass
i just have personal history with star and i know this is what her scumgame looks like, whereas i don't have that history with jackel so for all i know, she actually plays town this way

like i think jackel looks bad for the exact same reasons that you do, and for the exact same reasons i scumread star

i just happen to know that it's literally scum indicative for star, whereas i don't know that for jackel

i hope that explains my position better

and i'm just baffled that you lot are all ignoring star for ??? reasons

- Dumber

[Dumb and Dumber]

aside do you have any thoughts on why you're not dead?

[BananaCucho]

aside do you have any thoughts on why you're not dead?

Yes

[Dumb and Dumber]

did u elaborate on that anywhere?

[BananaCucho]

No.

[redtea]

You really want me to start speculating third party shit again banana. You don't know what you're encouraging.

D&D I think what you're missing that Jackel is partially a policy elimination here. Not totally, but people have expressed not wanting to have to deal with Jackel's slot at ELo. In other words, they'd rather have Starbuck around still than Jackel.
Also the (most obvious) reason banana isn't dead is that us clerics needed to be gimped.

[BananaCucho]

Speculate away Redtea. I'll die tonight finally and it wont matter lol

[BananaCucho]

That is if Jackel is town

If they are scum it also wont matter lol

[BananaCucho]

ngl, kinda tired of rereading everything

[BananaCucho]

Its been 4 irl days and Jackel and Starbuck literally have said nothing

[Dumb and Dumber]

n other words, they'd rather have Starbuck around still than Jackel.

a) i'm aware that this is mostly a policy thing, i'm pointing out that it's silly to level a policy thing against jackel alone when star is doing ... the exact same thing

b) even though it's mostly a policy thing, certain people are presenting it as being a scumread

[Dumb and Dumber]

Its been 4 irl days and Jackel and Starbuck literally have said nothing

whoo, progress

[BananaCucho]

n other words, they'd rather have Starbuck around still than Jackel.

a) i'm aware that this is mostly a policy thing, i'm pointing out that it's silly to level a policy thing against jackel alone when star is doing ... the exact same thing

b) even though it's mostly a policy thing, certain people are presenting it as being a scumread

Starbuck has shown more presence and progression and thought than Jackel has over the 3 days of this game

[catboi]

yeah at this point flip jackel, cleric dumb and dumber, if the game isn't over then vote starbuck I guess (If banana is alive just make sure he confirms his role). I could do more rereading but it's boring and I won't consider a vote on anyone else today.

[BananaCucho]

Flip the alligatorsheep

Dew it

[BananaCucho]

[BananaCucho]

FrozenSheep

[catboi]

She might have flaked, but that is a strong reason why that slot just needs to go. I think I should be the one to hammer here?

[BananaCucho]

I'm fine with that. We need all 5 votes lol

[BananaCucho]

zzzzzzzzzz

[catboi]

Jackel98 Jul 23, 01:37am Aug 17, 07:53pm 1 day 19 hours
Starbuck Jul 23, 08:47am Aug 16, 11:58pm 2 days 15 hours

might be a problem

[BananaCucho]

If both of them are town somehow it's extremely disappointing to say the least