Newbie 2023 - Hedgehogs - Day 3

[shellyc]

Hi. So you read the SEs / people on the wagon as scum? I think the NS push on Bella is fine, I don't think Bella's ISO looks that good.

I am still reading the game. My inclined TRs are Bell and NS.

[The Bulge]

They have a statistically higher chance of guessing what roles are in the game

?

[The Bulge]

Also yeah given the kill I expect one if not both scum on the wagon

Walk me through this? I don't disagree but what does walter have to do with it?

[notscience]

There’s more people to hide in on the wagon. There’s less room to hide off it.

[The Bulge]

I'm seeing it now yea, with two green flips off the wagon.

What do you think of shelly's entrance?

[notscience]

Newbtown whose posts I can actually read

[notscience]

She also didn’t trip my super secret scumtell for newbies. So that’s a point in her favor

[The Bulge]

Newbtown whose posts I can actually read

it's refreshing isn't it


what ever happened to the andre wagon btw? (open q)

[shellyc]

Initial Impressions (I am not a scumhunting god; will revisit this)

Andresvmb - This slot is really scummy to me. They were the other wagon yesterday and IV was town. They were on the IV wagon. Their ISO doesn't look good at all.

Nash - Lurker. On IV wagon. This is a null leaning scum read - I really want 'em to talk more.

Bell - I am leaning town on this slot. They are open, flexible, engaging, and spontaneous. I liked that initial interaction with me. However, they were on the IV wagon...

Bellaphant - Were on the IV wagon, and voted late. I don't really have an idea on this slot. Null read, maybe a teensy scumlean

The Bulge - I am null on this lad. Been a little bit lurking, also under the radar for most of the game. I want a closer look, but I think they are leaning town.

notscience - They read me as newbtown. I see they are a competent player who has been protown, but I believe they might be able to fake it... Still, a townread.

[shellyc]

She also didn’t trip my super secret scumtell for newbies. So that’s a point in her favor

What is your secret scumtell by the way? This post makes me curious

[Bell]

They have a statistically higher chance of guessing what roles are in the game

?

Mafia have one of three roles assigned to them. Based on what role they have they have a general idea of what the power roles are, for example, If mafia have a roleblocker there's a 2/3 chance that there's a tracker in the game.

[The Bulge]

I was more wondering if that was scumslip bait, a partnerslip, or just confbias

[Bell]

In otherwords, you disagree.
Do you have anything you'd like to share?

[The Bulge]

I think the our slot is more than likely town, yes.

nothing much off top although I am not entirely of sound mind atm

[Bell]

And why is his slot town?

[Bell]

Oh, that explains the scumslip, partnerslip, conf bias thing.
It didn't make sense to me because If I were scum I wouldn't know walter was a tracker until he just died right now. Unless he crumbed somewhere and would have thought Our was the tracker and nked him instead.

[The Bulge]

for all the senseless distracting shit he went on about, nothing really stood out to me? I didn't feel any kind of slip ups or weird detractions in his logic.

pedit yea no i think you're town the partnerslip was just logically one of 3 conclusions there

[Bell]

Okay.

[shellyc]

If mafia have a roleblocker there's a 2/3 chance that there's a tracker in the game.

To correct you, only one setup has Tracker in column A.

[Bell]

I got the role cop/role blocker confused. TeeHee.
Thanks.

[Bellaphant]

In a normal situation, that's fine ns, but we were elim-ing literally anyone as time was running out, and you were literally cheerleading the wagon?

Like, these feels really distanced and not actually related to what happened

[shellyc]

NS - Bella have this conflict. As I do not strongly townread any of them, I am wary of this interaction. This could well be scum theatre.

[Bellaphant]

Im only in conflict because it's nonsense. Or refuge in audacity - I can't work out why ns is yelling 'se scum on the wagon': maybe it's true!

[shellyc]

NS was on the wagon himself. NS, why are you using logic that scumreads yourself? That's weird

[notscience]

Scum on the wagon is common logic.

I know I’m town and am townreading two others on the wagon, so naturally I want to look where I’m not townreading.

I don’t think this is a new concept at all and this confusion from bella is very interesting.

Bulge?

Also how did we not comment on me getting called newbtown lmao