FGO: Mafia in the Lostbelt (Game Over!)

[Servant Avenger]

It’s in additional set up notes. I’m playing on tablet for alt slip reasons so I can’t quote it.

[Servant Foreigner]

1. This game heavily focuses around the fact that your class is known, but your specific servant's identity is not. Be aware that just is as true of most stories, knowing one's myth means knowing one's weaknesses. Be careful when claiming or revealing information about your role.

Berserkers are supposed to be weak to foreigners and that clearly isn't working so far.

[Servant Lancer]

yes dumbass i'm asking what makes them distinct in your view

Their approaches aren't really similar at all besides wanting the master vote, and the whole list has reason to want that.
I like Avenger's early sorting and reactions and I don't really like Berserker's.

Also don't call me a dumbass, asshole.

the only posts they have which could really be construed as "sorting" are 60 and 70, which, if that's what it takes, color me unimpressed - the scumread is even the exact same one as berserker's, so, like, what gives


looks like a fake distinction for a manufactured read from you imo tbh

1) They haven't played anything alike and your continued claim they have is super wild
2) Feels like you pressed me for what you think is a towncase so you could have something to shut down.
3) Again, do you have any reads of your own?

[Servant Foreigner]

Alter Ego isn't really pressuring me either.
This entire game is a flavor fail already.

[Servant Caster]

I just assumed people didn't want to claim because in fate revealing your identity is typically bad.

Then... why did you ask us to...?

[Servant Lancer]

Maybe I should read the OP.
I just assumed people didn't want to claim because in fate revealing your identity is typically bad.

In mafia revealing your identity is usually bad, too?

I didn't realize it was in Fate, though. That's kind of cool.
I don't need another gacha game in my life so getting invested may be a mistake. and yet.

[Servant Avenger]

If anyone would like to claim their attribute I would appreciate it.
My role benefits from having that knowledge.

I am aware of Beasts and Shielders attribute already. I will not state on how I know this.
I also know I am dissapointed in Ruler and if they know about the Fate series I am going to be pissed.

If you’re town this post kinda sucks and I would like you to think about information security.
Maybe use your notes section to think about it more before posting it.

[Servant Avenger]

Imagine being Achilles lancer.
Telling people about it would not be a good idea.

[Servant Caster]

Towns:

In mafia revealing your identity is usually bad, too?

Also Towns: [most players have heavily implied their role by the end of day 1]

[Servant Foreigner]

Imagine being Achilles lancer.
Telling people about it would not be a good idea.

I think the idea of scum learning Rider is Achilles and having scum!Lancer throw something at his heel to slay him is a bit far fetched in practice.

[Servant Lancer]

It's not really far-fetched to consider the game would be set up that way when Cabd warned about it from the beginning.

Inb4 someone else comes in saying they can break this game with a D1 massclaim.

[Servant Foreigner]

What servant in fate can interact with someones true name?
Even with warning from the mod I don't actually think it would be that bad to claim but I digress I'll drop it if you guys don't want to humor this conversation.

My role contains info about the setup.
As someone with fate knowledge who has a role that specifically requires me to find out peoples traits.
I can confirm I can reasonably deduce a lot about traits by just your class and a single line of text in my role pm.

I don't see why I'd enter this game more informed then scum?

[Servant Foreigner]

Maybe some Casters or some Rulers could interact with True Names?
But the pool would be so limited we know where it's coming from anyway.

[Servant Avenger]

It was to illustrate the idea of fate stay night flavor. Not a literal one to one,
You’re revealing information in a way that is poorly considered. I don’t mean that to be insulting but if I was scum I would be going over what you just said with a fine toothed comb and it’s against my win condition not to warn you to be careful.

[Servant Avenger]

Well for one if we tell you our attributes, they can wiki our attributes cross reference it to our classes and if they have any abilities they fuck us.

[Servant Lancer]

Informed is literally an established role modifier.

Tbh I see this "My one role PM tells me enough about the setup that it's safe to claim, actually" sort of attitude way more often than I think I should but it also comes from town enough I wonder if there's a tell for it.

[Servant Foreigner]

Well for one if we tell you our attributes, they can wiki our attributes cross reference it to our classes and if they have any abilities they fuck us.

I am going to get flamed for delving into this.
But I could post multiple peoples traits right now.

[Servant Foreigner]

I am now done with this topic.

[Servant Avenger]

Okay. Thank you.
It’s clear you have some already (more information) but that you don’t have all. And telling scum that could be bad for us.
I understand what you’re getting at and perhaps you feel cock blocked because you can’t run your role to its full extent with more experience you would know that there are absolutely ways for your role to work even without having us directly claiming to you

[Servant Caster]

Well for one if we tell you our attributes, they can wiki our attributes cross reference it to our classes and if they have any abilities they fuck us.

I am going to get flamed for delving into this.
But I could post multiple peoples traits right now.

I think I may know what you mean by this.

[Servant Alter Ego]

Hi guys!

VOTE: Servant Rider

Hello. Any thoughts so far?

[Servant Avenger]

I am now done with this topic.

Could you go back and read your role

carefully and throughly

and think about how to utilize it to benefit town the most?

I could use more votes by the way.

[Servant Assassin]

1) They haven't played anything alike and your continued claim they have is super wild
2) Feels like you pressed me for what you think is a towncase so you could have something to shut down.
3) Again, do you have any reads of your own?

haven't

played alike

is a surface-level distinction. they've had a different

style

but in terms of meaningful content they're not that different. it's just especially notable you give a vague reason of liking their "early sorting" but w/ seemingly no regard for what they actually said - both of them have expressed a scumread of foreigner, so why is one trustworthy and one not? i pressed you because i thought what you said was notable and the answers i've gotten from you don't look like real reasoning - they look like you're giving reads based on appearances, rather than trying to evaluate intent. yes, i have other reads. no, i'm not gonna talk about them right now.

[Servant Avenger]

I’m no longer expressing a scum read on foreigner. I wasn’t expressing a scum read on foreigner to begin with, I was alluding to the idea that foreigners might be different from the rest of us and that maybe him/her sticking out isn’t that odd after all. But I wasn’t going to interfere with good ol’ pressure to see more from him either.

[Servant Assassin]

Well for one if we tell you our attributes, they can wiki our attributes cross reference it to our classes and if they have any abilities they fuck us.

I am going to get flamed for delving into this.
But I could post multiple peoples traits right now.

please do not do this

I’m no longer expressing a scum read on foreigner. I wasn’t expressing a scum read on foreigner to begin with, I was alluding to the idea that foreigners might be different from the rest of us and that maybe him/her sticking out isn’t that odd after all. But I wasn’t going to interfere with good ol’ pressure to see more from him either.

yeah they're town, berserker vs foreigner was p boring