Newbie 2027 | Doggos | Town Win

[shellyc]

That's why I'm trying to get my thoughts out

Redados brings an IIoA vibe to me in this game

are you an SE now, redados?

[shellyc]

unrelated note: PAGETOP

[Noraa]

but I don't think its fair to prioritize another claimed power role just cuz it can be checked. then again the real power role, whichever it is, will prolly end up night killed I agree. I suggest we lim sirius d1 that way the checkable one we'll get results tmrw. Plus pls target someone who ur sure is town. If they r iffy, don't risk it cuz this is really important. Shelly try saving whoever u think will be killed and we can see what happens d2 to determine which ones the fake.

[Redados]

I did AtE at E-1 in 2019

it's exactly the same. listen to logic not emotion.

For anyone wondering, AtE = Appeal to Emotion

Here is scum!Shelly's appeal to emotion in Newbie 2019:

I'm vanilla town. I'm just a town, on the verge of a mislynch.
Why is this game so unforgiving to newbies? I don't see why I'm locked scum by everyone.
...

Not everyone thinks you are scum, hence the people voting for word321 instead. Relax. Someone has to get limmed on Day 1.

You know, I got my VT role PM, went into this game as a total newbie, pushed a guy that I had no idea was Mason, and just got pushed. And I'm tunneled by confirmed town. I'm legit freaking out right now

[Noraa]

That's why I'm trying to get my thoughts out

Redados brings an IIoA vibe to me in this game

are you an SE now, redados?

he said he was a noob

[shellyc]

Mundivore's plan fails if setup is A1

[Noraa]

I did AtE at E-1 in 2019

it's exactly the same. listen to logic not emotion.

For anyone wondering, AtE = Appeal to Emotion

Here is scum!Shelly's appeal to emotion in Newbie 2019:

I'm vanilla town. I'm just a town, on the verge of a mislynch.
Why is this game so unforgiving to newbies? I don't see why I'm locked scum by everyone.
...

Not everyone thinks you are scum, hence the people voting for word321 instead. Relax. Someone has to get limmed on Day 1.

You know, I got my VT role PM, went into this game as a total newbie, pushed a guy that I had no idea was Mason, and just got pushed. And I'm tunneled by confirmed town. I'm legit freaking out right now

Don't bring up stuff like this. it just makes u seem like u hold grudges against players from game to game and that's not cool

[shellyc]

He's played in two games with me. him spitting mafia theory gave me an SE vibe lol

[Redados]

That's why I'm trying to get my thoughts out

Redados brings an IIoA vibe to me in this game

are you an SE now, redados?

he said he was a noob

I'm a newb. I have played in one completed game: Newbie 2019. I am a participant in an ongoing game which I will not discuss. This is my third newbie game. Outside of Mafiascum, I have not played forum mafia since 2012. I have not played any games on Mafiascum outside of The Road to Rome.

[Noraa]

...I'm a noobie.

[Noraa]

took me a while to find it

[Redados]

I did AtE at E-1 in 2019

it's exactly the same. listen to logic not emotion.

For anyone wondering, AtE = Appeal to Emotion

Here is scum!Shelly's appeal to emotion in Newbie 2019:

I'm vanilla town. I'm just a town, on the verge of a mislynch.
Why is this game so unforgiving to newbies? I don't see why I'm locked scum by everyone.
...

Not everyone thinks you are scum, hence the people voting for word321 instead. Relax. Someone has to get limmed on Day 1.

You know, I got my VT role PM, went into this game as a total newbie, pushed a guy that I had no idea was Mason, and just got pushed. And I'm tunneled by confirmed town. I'm legit freaking out right now

Don't bring up stuff like this. it just makes u seem like u hold grudges against players from game to game and that's not cool

I think using the meta of a completed game is fair. Shelly said, "I did Appeal to Emotion in 2019 and this is exactly the same" in post 940. I'm showing Shelly's appeal to emotion so people besides me can understand what she's talking about. I'm adding context, I'm not criticizing Shelly's play in that game. She played incredibly well and she fooled me 100%.

[Redados]

That's why I'm trying to get my thoughts out

Redados brings an IIoA vibe to me in this game

are you an SE now, redados?

Had to google that abbreviation!

In my catch up I did a fair bit of analysis over information. I feel like the last few hours have skewed more heavily towards information just because I felt like Noraa wasn't understanding the power role setups etc.

My general thought is that if I don't know something (like IIoA standing for Information Instead of Analysis), then there's a good chance someone else might not either, especially because we're in a newbie game. So I might as well explain in case someone else was on the same page as me.

[shellyc]

IIoA = Information INstead of Analysis.

Sure if you think that way, explaining the columns does clear up the gamestate

[Sirius9121]

but I don't think its fair to prioritize another claimed power role just cuz it can be checked. then again the real power role, whichever it is, will prolly end up night killed I agree. I suggest we lim sirius d1 that way the checkable one we'll get results tmrw. Plus pls target someone who ur sure is town. If they r iffy, don't risk it cuz this is really important. Shelly try saving whoever u think will be killed and we can see what happens d2 to determine which ones the fake.

lol this decides my vote
UNVOTE:

[Sirius9121]

VOTE: Noraa

Heavily considering a Noraa/Shelly Scumteam.

[Noraa]

but I don't think its fair to prioritize another claimed power role just cuz it can be checked. then again the real power role, whichever it is, will prolly end up night killed I agree. I suggest we lim sirius d1 that way the checkable one we'll get results tmrw. Plus pls target someone who ur sure is town. If they r iffy, don't risk it cuz this is really important. Shelly try saving whoever u think will be killed and we can see what happens d2 to determine which ones the fake.

lol this decides my vote
UNVOTE:

oh? does it make ur vote me?

[Noraa]

Ah so u just vote for whoever votes u eh? getting scum vibes here. If one of the two(plus and shelly) is scum, sirius or redado might be the partner.

[Redados]

Noraa, I really don't like your playstyle. I don't think it's alignment-indicative necessarily, but I really am not a fan of how you are playing.

[Noraa]

VOTE: Noraa

Heavily considering a Noraa/Shelly Scumteam.

ur scum teams change every time u pop in for a hot 2 seconds and disappear for the next two days

[Sirius9121]

noraa stop being naïve, they’re not both town

yeah wtf noraa WE'RE NOT BOTH TOWN

noraa stop being naïve, they’re not both town

yeah wtf noraa WE'RE NOT BOTH TOWN

T^T I'm getting yelled at for trying to believe in my reads

Readslist

Noraa: New and confused town or scum. VERY CONFUSING PLAY, VERY POOR INSISTENCE AT US BEING TvT. Posting feels like me in 2019, few to no reads, scum!them playing chaos style to distract the town from reads
Redados: Gives me a DIFFERENT VIBE. Intentional "hammer", 825 wants to go me BUT VOTED FOR PLUSJOY EARLIER: contradiction. Sceptorus was also playing very agreeable which is scummy
Frogsterking: "I think shelly and plusjoy are town" YOU ARE AN SE DUDE! but giving thoughts and also tries to solve, null leaning town
Echovision: almost hard town, shows geniune emotion and town energy when I claimed
Mundivore: definitely easier to read than the predecesor, placing huge effort to gamesolve, decent reads, second best TR
72offsuit: knowledge of plusjoy being scum does make them look better. leaning town on casing plusjoy but they've disappeared
Sirius: VI / jester style of play, anti-town but that seems quite implausible as scum. NULL BUT A HAIR TRIGGER FROM DROPPING TO SCUM

idc that im a jester
logic tells me that Noraa, and possibly Shelly, is scum.

The only thing stopping me from killing Shelly is that, they are a newbie, and from previous Marathons they seem to be......

[Noraa]

Noraa, I really don't like your playstyle. I don't think it's alignment-indicative necessarily, but I really am not a fan of how you are playing.

hm I will listen to constructive feedback. tell me what's wrong with my play style

[Sirius9121]

Ah so u just vote for whoever votes u eh? getting scum vibes here. If one of the two(plus and shelly) is scum, sirius or redado might be the partner.

SMH ITS CERTAIN THAT ONE OF THEM IS SCUM

VOTE: noraa
pls

[shellyc]

wtf are you doing Noraa

gives me vibes from my game in 2019 and you've done nothing

give you reads now

[Sirius9121]

VOTE: Noraa

Heavily considering a Noraa/Shelly Scumteam.

ur scum teams change every time u pop in for a hot 2 seconds and disappear for the next two days

so?
tbh, my D1s are like this.