In post 1176, Servant Assassin wrote:All right. I'm going to throw out a list of names. If there's a gun to your head, is that person town or scum? Don't hedge, no null reads, no IDK, no leans, just pick one or the other, say the first thing that comes to your mind.
In post 1190, Servant Assassin wrote:Final set of names, thank you all for participating. Ideally this would be done with more participants but MS isn't really conducive to live posting, only wish I'd thought of it sooner after the flip. p-edit: Glad to have you join us, Berserker!
SABER
AVENGER
ALTER EGO
BERSERKER
FOREIGNER
town, town, town, town, town
ok now that the game has begun you will likely see me being a bit different. i had no particular interest in being mastered. while i historically frequently get scumread early (especially as town), i rarely get lynched (especially as scum). put me in the hotseat. i will say that at this point im very much lhf, and so im a bit skeptical of people who dont have a better guess at where scum is than me.
In post 1207, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:How many people actually think Ruler is scum in a scenario where a gun isn't being held to your head?
Looking for people actively scum reading that slot rathet than just not town reading.
i feel like ruler is a bit tough to sort. i also feel that to some extent its very easy for scum to blend in on day 0, so i think we should probably take our current readlists with a grain of salt.
In post 1207, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:How many people actually think Ruler is scum in a scenario where a gun isn't being held to your head?
Looking for people actively scum reading that slot rathet than just not town reading.
i feel like ruler is a bit tough to sort. i also feel that to some extent its very easy for scum to blend in on day 0, so i think we should probably take our current readlists with a grain of salt.
In post 1207, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:How many people actually think Ruler is scum in a scenario where a gun isn't being held to your head?
Looking for people actively scum reading that slot rathet than just not town reading.
Honestly I have the same reads even without the gun to my head. Even though you think I am altering my reads out of fear of being shot in this game I am not, those are just my reads.
Let's be honest people only have 3-4 scum reads in a forced environement which is odd, we have to pull the trigger on some people we are unsure about eventually. Please do not look at the first letter of each sentence in this post.
In post 1207, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:How many people actually think Ruler is scum in a scenario where a gun isn't being held to your head?
Looking for people actively scum reading that slot rathet than just not town reading.
Yeah, I don't have a full blown scumread on Ruler. In fact somewhere in my notes I told myself that at the time, although there weren't many posts to go by, I liked their fluidity.
I think (and please, Alter, correct me if I'm wrong) she's suggesting Shielder has some kind of on-death ability. Considering Avenger gets some kind of bonus if he correctly guesses the next person to die, I'm inclined to agree.
In post 1207, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:How many people actually think Ruler is scum in a scenario where a gun isn't being held to your head?
Looking for people actively scum reading that slot rathet than just not town reading.
Honestly I have the same reads even without the gun to my head. Even though you think I am altering my reads out of fear of being shot in this game I am not, those are just my reads.
Let's be honest people only have 3-4 scum reads in a forced environment which is odd, we have to pull the trigger on some people we are unsure about eventually. Please do not look at the first letter of each sentence in this post.
I have to say I'm finding the data interesting and somewhat startling on tabulating it, although that may partly be a consequence of a drawn out phase 0 with a lack of meaningful pressure. I'll be working on compiling some notes in the meantime. I don't mean to be a high and mighty dictator commanding everyone who to vote but for now I'd like to comply with Avenger's request to settle on an elimination target by the time he can submit his action. However, this will not be settled on hasty impulse but a measured evaluation of what has transpired so far. Rushing decisions based on surface impressions is what loses games and I do not want that to be a part of my leadership.
In post 1207, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:How many people actually think Ruler is scum in a scenario where a gun isn't being held to your head?
Looking for people actively scum reading that slot rathet than just not town reading.
Honestly I have the same reads even without the gun to my head. Even though you think I am altering my reads out of fear of being shot in this game I am not, those are just my reads.
Let's be honest people only have 3-4 scum reads in a forced environment which is odd, we have to pull the trigger on some people we are unsure about eventually. Please do not look at the first letter of each sentence in this post.
I have to say I'm finding the data interesting and somewhat startling on tabulating it, although that may partly be a consequence of a drawn out phase 0 with a lack of meaningful pressure. I'll be working on compiling some notes in the meantime. I don't mean to be a high and mighty dictator commanding everyone who to vote but for now I'd like to comply with Avenger's request to settle on an elimination target by the time he can submit his action. However, this will not be settled on hasty impulse but a measured evaluation of what has transpired so far. Rushing decisions based on surface impressions is what loses games and I do not want that to be a part of my leadership.