Mini Theme 2162: Wherewolf [Game over | Village win]

[TheFuzzylogic99]

prob will vote Garon unless some can convince me to vote Italian without copping him.

[brighteningskies]

From the slightly trolling way Italino is posting vs the very vague posts from Galron.. uh I'm still thinking Italino is either a bold wolf or a Jester. Can the clairvoyant please check him tonight?
Then I suppose that leaves Galron today. Unless you have anything to say, Galron?

[insomnia]

Glitch - what makes 159 and 160 anti-town and why is that wolfy as opposed to not just...anti-town??

I don't see the difference. Your lazy attitude toward game mechanics is very off when we're playing a game where the best hunting to be done is through game mechanics. Sheeping. Lazy. Not interested in doing the work of a townie. That's scum indicative to me.

Who am I sheeping?

[insomnia]

I'm trying to figure out why you would say that just because I'm not engaging into mechanics than that makes me lazy and therefore scum, when I have plenty of other posts and thoughts on the game that you're ignoring. Mainly the fact that you wanted Italiano balloted in that post and I'm the one that twisted the key into that engine.

[insomnia]

I regret not having the day extended by 24 hours so I could have balloted Glitch here. I think he cherry picked the living crap out of those posts of mine.

I don't even know if I necessarily see a newbie seeing the game like that, it still feels far-fetched from how a new villager would think about the game.

[brighteningskies]

The day was already extended 24 hours I thought while Cm1 looked for a replacement

Also, I think while you have a fair amount of posts they lack reads on people and are mostly a bit vague and neutral. (This is to insomnia btw)
I think balloting someone just because they're suspicious of you is unhelpful and a bit ridiculous. Instead of balloting Glitch maybe just defend yourself instead of attacking back and asking rhetorical questions. (Not criticising your gameplay, just your response to being scumread)

[brighteningskies]

I found the term I was looking for it was bugging me: OMGUS

[ItalianoVD]

We can make this phase real short.

How?

Ummm...

have you considered our offer to work with town for a few days and then get killed?

It appears that plan has backfired.

But I did read Almost50’s little idea. So basically you want me to wait until Day 4 to get eliminated? What kinda Tomfoolery is this? And what would I do with all this extra time on my hands?

[ItalianoVD]

Galron, how did you end up here with me? Seems like some untrustworthiness going down in the town. You scoundrels.

[brighteningskies]

Aren't jesters supposed to be funny?

[insomnia]

The day was already extended 24 hours I thought while Cm1 looked for a replacement

Also, I think while you have a fair amount of posts they lack reads on people and are mostly a bit vague and neutral. (This is to insomnia btw)
I think balloting someone just because they're suspicious of you is unhelpful and a bit ridiculous. Instead of balloting Glitch maybe just defend yourself instead of attacking back and asking rhetorical questions. (Not criticising your gameplay, just your response to being scumread)

Well this point is laughable, if wolves push on me then should I abstain from calling then wolves just because they’re pushing me?

How is that logical at all? If I were a wolf and I pushed a fake read on you based on bogus reasons then from your logic I’m not a wolf and you’re just being Omgus-y, no?

[insomnia]

“A wolf is attacking you so defend yourself instead of pushing him”

Lol

[brighteningskies]

“A wolf is attacking you so defend yourself instead of pushing him”

Lol

That's not what I'm saying! Lol I'm saying he was scum hunting and you have no idea if he's a wolf yet you react by saying you're gonna ballot him just for simply scumhunting. Are we not allowed to suspect people and question them at all without them voting for us in return? You're not even on the ballot yourself so he probably didn't even vote for you.

[brighteningskies]

I mean if someone said to me "I think this thing you said was suspicious you gotta explain yourself" why would I respond to that by wanting to vote for them immediately

[Galron]

If I were provable Town and he were provable jester, which elimination would win Town the game? Re-read A50's 202 and 226. By putting me on the ballot, we're boned.

[Galron]

A-1: 7-3-1 >> 5-3-1 >> 3-3-1 GAME OVER
A-2: 7-3-1 >> 6-3-0 >> 4-3-0 E-Lo
B: 8-3-0 >> 6-3-0 >> 4-3-0 E-Lo
C: 8-2-1 >> 6-2-1 >> 4-2-1 >> 3-2-0 E-Lo
D: 9-2-0 >> 7-2-0 >> 5-2-0 >> 3-2-0 E-Lo

These are all possible scenarios (T-W-3P). I so not believe the top 1 is at all likely, but I considered both eliminating the Jester and not.
B & X are more likely now (depending on whether Italiano is Scum or Jester). eliminating him today ensures we don't lose before D4 (worst case scenario). If we are in D we probably are on auto win if we eliminate Italiano today.

[img]index.jpeg[/img]

I think we're in (C), which makes this navigable.

[ItalianoVD]

Aren't jesters supposed to be funny?

Wrong. Jesters are entertainers. You’re assumptions will get you killed.

[Glitch]

I'm trying to figure out why you would say that just because I'm not engaging into mechanics than that makes me lazy and therefore scum, when I have plenty of other posts and thoughts on the game that you're ignoring. Mainly the fact that you wanted Italiano balloted in that post and I'm the one that twisted the key into that engine.

In this game, spending time understanding the mechanics and game setup is the best way to catch scum. A lack of interest in that seems scummy. You asked who you were sheeping; but you clearly and distinctly said you werent gonna bother understanding mechanics and just roll with whatever A50 said. I get A50 is really townie but that doesn't resolve each player of all their town duties. Unless they don't have town duties.

Your argument back at me feels pretty OMGUSy.

[brighteningskies]

Aren't jesters supposed to be funny?

Wrong. Jesters are entertainers. You’re assumptions will get you killed.

Idk that reply was pretty funny, Jester..

[DK]

hi there

[brighteningskies]

A-1: 7-3-1 >> 5-3-1 >> 3-3-1 GAME OVER
A-2: 7-3-1 >> 6-3-0 >> 4-3-0 E-Lo
B: 8-3-0 >> 6-3-0 >> 4-3-0 E-Lo
C: 8-2-1 >> 6-2-1 >> 4-2-1 >> 3-2-0 E-Lo
D: 9-2-0 >> 7-2-0 >> 5-2-0 >> 3-2-0 E-Lo

These are all possible scenarios (T-W-3P). I so not believe the top 1 is at all likely, but I considered both eliminating the Jester and not.
B & X are more likely now (depending on whether Italiano is Scum or Jester). eliminating him today ensures we don't lose before D4 (worst case scenario). If we are in D we probably are on auto win if we eliminate Italiano today.

[img]index.jpeg[/img]

I think we're in (C), which makes this navigable.

I'm inclined to agree, the balance is probably C or D and therefore I would advise eliminating a Jester but I understand if not everyone feels that way. But I am curious about you saying "If I were provable Town" and "By putting me on the ballot, we're boned."

I think you may still need to defend yourself since some players aren't convinced by burning the Jester/are more suspicious of you than Italiano?

PEDIT: Hi DK! Welcome

[insomnia]

I'm trying to figure out why you would say that just because I'm not engaging into mechanics than that makes me lazy and therefore scum, when I have plenty of other posts and thoughts on the game that you're ignoring. Mainly the fact that you wanted Italiano balloted in that post and I'm the one that twisted the key into that engine.

In this game, spending time understanding the mechanics and game setup is the best way to catch scum. A lack of interest in that seems scummy. You asked who you were sheeping; but you clearly and distinctly said you werent gonna bother understanding mechanics and just roll with whatever A50 said. I get A50 is really townie but that doesn't resolve each player of all their town duties. Unless they don't have town duties.

Your argument back at me feels pretty OMGUSy.

I never once said I wouldn't get involved in mechanics, you're painting it out to be like that. I just don't know if it's because you're a wrong villager or a wolf yet.

One thing I know for sure is that you aren't doing a good job of reading my posts. I said I'd take it if A50 were cop checked so that I wouldn't have to bother with mechanics and follow his mechanical sage advice.

We probably won't fit well in this game together because we think differently of the game on a fundamental level so I won't really reply to you anymore unless I think you're a villager. For now I think you're moderately wolfy and discussing with you isn't really productive for anyone.

[Almost50]

so on the one hand im all for voting galron. that slot is scummy as hell. on the other hand, id like people to claim who voted for whom. i dont trust that it was townies who balloted galron and italiano. the scum are a large enough voting bloc that they should be able to get at least one person on the ballot unless town coordinates, which we didnt.

I changed my mind several times. I am certain I did vote each of them at least once. I just don't remember which one I ended up on before the deadline hit. I "think" it was Galron or -maybe- WLC.

@MOD: Would it be possible for one to request that you PM them their own voting history?

[Almost50]

I am also positive the Wolf pack voted the Jester (and will vote him here too). They get TWO KILLs if he is eliminated, so why not?

[CreativeMod1]

.

@MOD: Would it be possible for one to request that you PM them their own voting history?

I'll reply to this shortly

WeyounsLastClone has been prodded and has 24 hours to make a post