Open 795 | Noir | Game Over

[Not_Mafia]

I’d like a MWNN, Penguin, Lost or MURDERCAT Elim today.

Townreading Norwee Isis, Taylor and bob

Bumbi is being weirdly defensive and reticent to post, but I haven’t played with him in a while so hard to say this is a tell.

I want to keep Genius around purely for my own amusement

[Not_Mafia]

Don’t see MURDERCAT going along with a BM kill actaully

[NorwegianboyEE]

Where’s P-P-P-Pingu Pingu!

[MURDERCAT]

I'm confused about PP but feeling good about norwegian and isis and the bob vote is obviously going nowhere

Do you have sufficient history with norwegian and isis to show either of them as particularly prolific scum hunters?

Not sure why this would matter, I already said I want clarity on PP too

[MURDERCAT]

Don’t see MURDERCAT going along with a BM kill actaully

I'm curious as to why but not really for game reasons

[NorwegianboyEE]

I would like to know the purpose behind post 698.

[ManWithNoName]

I am trying to figure out why voting to PP rather than what is presumably a scum read in your list is superior play to get "clarity" we have lost two town members, I would think one would be more likely to pursue a scum read if there is no basis that two town reads are better at scum hunting than an average player.

To me, it doesn't matter if someone is town to vote with them unless you respect their scum hunting ability. I trust my abilities more than those of just random town reads.

The clarity will, perhaps, help me sort MURDERCAT.

I do not think "wanting clarity on PP" is a great reason to vote for PP. Thus, I have some more information on MURDERCAT.

Would you all like me to walk you through why I am asking questions every time I ask one? I'm more than willing to assume you cannot think on your own.

[Isis]

N_M is probably town. I don't think he'd feel as amused by GeniusGamer as scum. He wouldn't feel threatened I don't think but like.. I think it'd be some kind of different tack

[NorwegianboyEE]

Would you all like me to walk you through why I am asking questions every time I ask one? I'm more than willing to assume you cannot think on your own.

Questions that allows deduction of the intentions behind the person asking helps me to clarify their alignment.
You sound very passive aggressive about being asked that question.

[ManWithNoName]

When the answer is that obvious, I don't see why multiple people needed to ask the question.

[Isis]

That's not how communication works, multiple people asking would indicate that it was, in fact, not obvious

[ManWithNoName]

Fine

[NorwegianboyEE]

ManWithNoName be like:

Spoiler:

[ManWithNoName]

Please refrain from using non-Clint Eastwood gifs for me.

Nic Cage is also acceptable

[NorwegianboyEE]

For looking like a very befitting character of the noir genre, you show surprisingly little roleplay ManWithNoName. I thought that would be one of the main reasons for why you'd sign up up to this game.

[ManWithNoName]

I signed up because the worst.

[Isis]

I signed up because MURDERCAT!

[NorwegianboyEE]

I signed up for Me, Myself and I!

[GeniusGamer]

I signed up because this was the closest to an open normal game I could find!

[GeniusGamer]

N_M is probably town. I don't think he'd feel as amused by GeniusGamer as scum. He wouldn't feel threatened I don't think but like.. I think it'd be some kind of different tack

Remember Show, Don’t Tell? I don’t think someone simply claiming they’re amused would make someone look town.

[Isis]

sure, I'll keep looking for evidence of actual amusement

[NorwegianboyEE]

I'm not sure i want a NM elimination today. Yes, what he did was really lame. But it's not inherently scummy for him because he does things like that all the time.
I like to have an open mind when it comes to players doing hyper scummy things for the heck of it. It doesn't mean they can't be town.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I saw a trolling player claim miller mason on day 1 of a game once and i argued vehemently of the fact that they were town even though literally everyone in the game scumread him. This is because you have to read their motivations. (He did turn out to be town btw)

I'd figure scum!NM would be more careful about blatantly lolhammering someone they'd know would flip town and make him look bad like that, but town!him might have just believed he caught scum and Dong was giving up so he just took his chances to get a flip sooner.

[Not_Mafia]

sure, I'll keep looking for evidence of actual amusement

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA

[Isis]

both alignments of NM take every available hammer on players of any alignment