Musician Mafia: Guitarists GAME OVER

[Galron]

TOWN

Iecerint
TiphaineDeath
A50
Titus
Doctor Drew
Pooky
a2rudeboy aka Hypnotoad
Galron
Pisskop
Gamma
BrightEyed
Starbuck
Princess Leia/REPLACEMENT

Lavender
Nono

Looker
DGB
IKS
Walter
Bambi
NPOM

SCUM

I don't get the Looker read with so little content. Actually, without some explanations, this entire list looks fishy. Someone made a point of saying how can you have reads on 20 players. I subscribe to that. I'll ask what's your process here?

pedit: Ninja'd

[WaltertheDunce10]

I am not really liking galron.
AlsoVOTE: unvote
I should stop hopping and make an actual contribution.
I don't like Icerint's list because it has a lot of town reads I feel like for this early in the day. pedit Coincidentally, now that I am looking at that list, slot's looker npom are reads I have a hard time with are listed as scum.

[Galron]

piss- It is a noticeable Decisive Action, by two players who haven't done much in that realm before or since

'Cept nono didn't vote IKS, right?

what's happening

IKS is scum and you should be voting there.

[Galron]

I am not really liking galron.
AlsoVOTE: unvote
I should stop hopping and make an actual contribution.
I don't like Icerint's list because it has a lot of town reads I feel like for this early in the day. pedit Coincidentally, now that I am looking at that list, slot's looker npom are reads I have a hard time with are listed as scum.

Yeah, that guy is not likable at all.

[WaltertheDunce10]

Yeah, I can see why.

[Doctor Drew]

Dave, why is it you can't get a read on PK or myself when one has been decently active the whole game(me) and the other has provided content in a short time(PK).

Not a loaded question, generally curious.

And I hate how the wagon formed on SiteFlake, but I also kinda hate Siteflake. Gets wagoned and basically has done nothing to convince people that they are barking up the wrong tree, at least TD seemed to care and eventually posted reads.

[NoPowerOverMe]

Next to pointless readlist

[davesaz]

Dave, why is it you can't get a read on PK or myself when one has been decently active the whole game(me) and the other has provided content in a short time(PK).

Not a loaded question, generally curious.

Time since my previous post to that one is about 5 min, and I used the term snap read in the post for a reason. On a less technical level, I have very little on either of you for obvious tells and I didn't see clear enough resemblances to previous games to make a call.

[Starbuck]

Busy last day or so. Catching up in a bit.

[davesaz]

Next to pointless readlist

Would have been cool to have a reference to whose.

[NoPowerOverMe]

The one with the pretty colors.

[davesaz]

I should stop hopping and make an actual contribution.

Do you think what you did before this wasn't actual contributions? if not, why not?

[DrippingGoofball]

Scum points for trying to get someone modkilled though.

MAJOR scum points.

[DrippingGoofball]

I am not really liking galron.
AlsoVOTE: unvote
I should stop hopping and make an actual contribution.
I don't like Icerint's list because it has a lot of town reads I feel like for this early in the day. pedit Coincidentally, now that I am looking at that list, slot's looker npom are reads I have a hard time with are listed as scum.

VOTE: WaltertheDunce10

[Titus]

I'll be back Sunday. I may pop in tomorrow but don't expect it.

X post all games.

[BrightEyedFish]

UNVOTE:

[BrightEyedFish]

I've need to get focused.

All I remember is that I think A50 is town and NPOM is probably town. rudeboy too.

Everyone else is scum for now.

[WaltertheDunce10]

I should stop hopping and make an actual contribution.

Do you think what you did before this wasn't actual contributions? if not, why not?

I sort of feel like I have been reactionary voting by going along with what others are saying without forming my own proper opinion on a slot. Just going along with a bandwagon.

[Iecerint]

TOWN

Iecerint
TiphaineDeath
A50
Titus
Doctor Drew
Pooky
a2rudeboy aka Hypnotoad
Galron
Pisskop
Gamma
BrightEyed
Starbuck
Princess Leia/REPLACEMENT

Lavender
Nono

Looker
DGB
IKS
Walter
Bambi
NPOM

SCUM

uhhhh

REASONS?

I'm happy to answer specific questions you have. You can see my thoughts from the posts I made as I caught up with the game.

[Iecerint]

I don't get the Looker read with so little content. Actually, without some explanations, this entire list looks fishy. Someone made a point of saying how can you have reads on 20 players. I subscribe to that. I'll ask what's your process here?

pedit: Ninja'd

1. I copy-pasted the list from page 1
2. I went through each player and divided them into TOWN NULL SCUM WHO? lists
3. I read the iso of everyone in WHO and tried to put them into TOWN or SCUM.
4. I read the iso of everyone in NULL and tried to put them in TOWN or SCUM.
5. I re-ordered all players within each category from town to scum. So, after this, the entire list is ordinal.
6. I posted the result.

Looker was NULL and then placed into SCUM in step 4. I placed him there because he posts and does not scumhunt. IIRC he's close to the null side of the SCUM section. He does have a post where he says something like "people are bored I think" (one of his last ones) which felt vaguely town, which accounts for the weaker read (not to mention that there's not much content, as you say).

I think most of the rationale for my reads should be pretty clear from reading my catch-up posts (with exceptions for a few players like Looker).

[a2rudeboy]

Let's just lynch all the lurkers, clear the field, and keep the game going with active people.

[a2rudeboy]

(Just gonna put that obvious sarcasm there, in case someone needs a bullshit basis to build on me later)

[Looker]

• Does the thread lose steam when scum have become complacent?

---

So we should just randomly wagon?

No. We randomly wagon until someone objects, then that someone is automatically town.

Spoiler:

I'm town I don't lie.

Actually, town lieing is OK in some occasions.
For example if you are PGO and you fake claim doctor to draw scum on you.

But then you kill the watcher instead

I believe, that there is at least one scum in {Looker, DrippingGoofball, pisskop, pookythemagicbear, WaltertheDance, Bambi Jay}
Slots from that set with 0 content: {Looker, Bambi Jay}
Since I have already played a game with town lurking Looker, I will VOTE: B. Jay

who are you

I think that yes rudedude does come out looking somewhat worse for wear from the last 24 hours.

I don't know what "worse for wear" means. I can't find it in Urban Dictionary.

UNVOTE:

Was this to avoid the risk of a hammer?

Looker was NULL and then placed into SCUM in step 4. I placed him there because he posts and does not scumhunt. IIRC he's close to the null side of the SCUM section. He does have a post where he says something like "people are bored I think" (one of his last ones) which felt vaguely town, which accounts for the weaker read (not to mention that there's not much content, as you say).

I approve.

---

VOTE: TiphaineDeath Surely Gamma knows what he's doing

I don't mean to besmirch the game of mafia, but a lot is NAI for me right now. I'm moreso just enamored by DGB's longevity.

[Galron]

I don't get the Looker read with so little content. Actually, without some explanations, this entire list looks fishy. Someone made a point of saying how can you have reads on 20 players. I subscribe to that. I'll ask what's your process here?

pedit: Ninja'd

1. I copy-pasted the list from page 1
2. I went through each player and divided them into TOWN NULL SCUM WHO? lists
3. I read the iso of everyone in WHO and tried to put them into TOWN or SCUM.
4. I read the iso of everyone in NULL and tried to put them in TOWN or SCUM.
5. I re-ordered all players within each category from town to scum. So, after this, the entire list is ordinal.
6. I posted the result.

Looker was NULL and then placed into SCUM in step 4. I placed him there because he posts and does not scumhunt. IIRC he's close to the null side of the SCUM section. He does have a post where he says something like "people are bored I think" (one of his last ones) which felt vaguely town, which accounts for the weaker read (not to mention that there's not much content, as you say).

I think most of the rationale for my reads should be pretty clear from reading my catch-up posts (with exceptions for a few players like Looker).

Intentional obtuseness is fun.

[davesaz]

Worse for wear = clothing that is worn a lot doesn't look as good as clothing that's brand new. Same goes for furniture, cars, etc. Items accumulate scratches, stains, etc.
In mafia it means looking worse aka scummier over time.

Beetle juice noted.

Spoiler:

Yeah I know that's not the right term. I don't feel like spelling it right now.