Mini 2167: Illicit Substances Mafia (Game Over!)

[MariaR]

This game started 2 days ago btw

[morph the cat]

This game started 2 days ago btw

Spoiler: Lady 1-Gent 6 Lovers PT

Ignore the game thread then and let's talk, lady the first.

[morph the cat]

Spoiler: Lady 1-Gent 6 Lovers PT

We put out a reads list prematurely primarily for your benefit. It sure would be great if you'd read it and step off from there.

[MariaR]

Spoiler: Lady 1-Gent 6 Lovers PT

We put out a reads list prematurely primarily for your benefit. It sure would be great if you'd read it and step off from there.

Spoiler: Lady 1-Gent 6 Lovers PT

Sure I'll go read it right now and give my rundown on each player. Thanks!

[morph the cat]

Spoiler: Lady 1-Gent 6 Lovers PT

We put out a reads list prematurely primarily for your benefit. It sure would be great if you'd read it and step off from there.

Spoiler: Lady 1-Gent 6 Lovers PT

Sure I'll go read it right now and give my rundown on each player. Thanks!

Spoiler: Lady1-Gent6 Lover's PT

We're probably going to post an updated one soon but it's a good starting point to re-enter the thread. Ignore me getting pissy, I was in a mood. Muffin may be an arrogant twat sometimes, but he's OUR arrogant twat.

[MariaR]

Spoiler: Lady1-Gent6 Lover's PT

After engaging with Bell and prodding him with a few questions I can comfortably agree that he's town. While I didn't really understand his style and that one post did strike me as bad/odd it doesn't outweigh how his thought process comes across very clear and geninune to me.

Midway I haven't personally played with, but after modding a game for him it's clear he comes across as scummy very easily. I have not seen there scum game so it's very hard for me to properly get a handle on this slot. I expect it to be handled over time.

Plus iso on a quick skim (and I mean very quick) I was worried about them being a lew effort scum at first given the little content in each post, however the more it goes on the better it gets. I don't really see much of an agenda in what comes across. I think they're town.

S_S is null on the side of somewhat scummy. I don't think they're really doing much of anything just kinda coasting along. I would need to hear why they're seemingly not interested in the game before I go into more detail about this read.

Prim's 454 is odd, I understand wanting to wait for reactions or get some as it's something I do nearly every game to some extent, but the way they went about it and further explained in posts comes to me in a way that is more likely to come from scum than town. 497/501 support my theory. Ah, I see they got replaced.

VOTE: 420

[MariaR]

I don't think it is possible for me to play this game at the extent I fully wanted to given the pace it's going. Now that doesn't mean I won't replace out of course, but if I want to keep up at a pace I am content with it requires a lot less deep thinking and note taking and that's gonna drive me insane. Live interaction and isos will probably be my only savior.

[morph the cat]

Spoiler: Lady1-Gent6 Lover's PT

After engaging with Bell and prodding him with a few questions I can comfortably agree that he's town. While I didn't really understand his style and that one post did strike me as bad/odd it doesn't outweigh how his thought process comes across very clear and geninune to me.

Midway I haven't personally played with, but after modding a game for him it's clear he comes across as scummy very easily. I have not seen there scum game so it's very hard for me to properly get a handle on this slot. I expect it to be handled over time.

Plus iso on a quick skim (and I mean very quick) I was worried about them being a lew effort scum at first given the little content in each post, however the more it goes on the better it gets. I don't really see much of an agenda in what comes across. I think they're town.

S_S is null on the side of somewhat scummy. I don't think they're really doing much of anything just kinda coasting along. I would need to hear why they're seemingly not interested in the game before I go into more detail about this read.

Prim's 454 is odd, I understand wanting to wait for reactions or get some as it's something I do nearly every game to some extent, but the way they went about it and further explained in posts comes to me in a way that is more likely to come from scum than town. 497/501 support my theory. Ah, I see they got replaced.

VOTE: 420

Spoiler: Lady1-Gent6 Lover's PT

Good to see you aren't completely resigned to non-effort-fun. Did the slots you left out just not strike you in general, or are you doing this as a multi-post catchup or something?

Muffin did a not-very elaborate defense of the Prismposting a while back, do you put any stock in that?

Really interested in your Alisae read, when you get that far.

P-edit: Just play like dancegame and hang out in this very real PT instead of dealing with the fucks in the main thread like gentlemen 4, he's icky. Gent 8 is sus too.

[MariaR]

Ah Alisae is town good to know.
Onto April
and then Muffin and then Secret...oh boy I need some ginger ale

[MariaR]

Alisae Bell PlusJOYED

The Bulge, April Ludgate

midwaybear, zmuffin man Secret Tunnel

Something_Smart

420 Blaze It Remilia Scarlet

Yeah this feels right

[MariaR]

If you have questions on a certain read that isn't yourself ask away and we can chat over it. Probably the best way we can help each other. For now I'm playing league~

[zMuffinMan]

"why?" to pretty much all of that

[MariaR]

Then what one puzzles you the most.

[zMuffinMan]

though feel free to start with your scum reads and the very strong town read on alisae

[midwaybear]

Just play like dancegame and hang out in this very real PT instead of dealing with the fucks in the main thread like gentlemen 4, he's icky.

Well this is a new development

Maria, how much of your current reads are based off of Morph's reads? Because I'm a little curious in how you placed reads on 3 slots in 7-ish minutes.

[MariaR]

Sure, I explained the read on Prism that you can check in the talk with morph. I then went to check 420 and they're just an empty slot so my feelings from Prisms short iso have gone to the 420 slot.

With Remilla I was confident I'd be able to read Gif but Gif isn't posting so it's a lot harder. I think a lot of the Ramilla slot is playing like they have information in a tmi way. Like they're setting up plans for the future based on flips they already know. This becomes a lot more obvious to me if you look at the last 30 posts or so they made. If you can't notice the trend I can point it out in more detail.

Alisae has a lot to do with tone, but I'd like to think I know Alisae to be able to tell the difference. Besides that I feel like the angles they've taken are ones that are strictly not needed for scum to take. It's an entirely different approach than I'd expect.

[MariaR]

Maria, how much of your current reads are based off of Morph's reads?

None at all. I just used it as a ref on where to start. Why I placed them so quickly is I only really needed to glance at some of April/Alisae to get a read on them. The rest of the time was spent on the Hydra

I gave up trying to read muffin though

[midwaybear]

oh is this sort of a meta read?

[morph the cat]

Just play like dancegame and hang out in this very real PT instead of dealing with the fucks in the main thread like gentlemen 4, he's icky.

Well this is a new development

Maria, how much of your current reads are based off of Morph's reads? Because I'm a little curious in how you placed reads on 3 slots in 7-ish minutes.

HOW CAN YOU READ MY PT ARE YOU A MAFIA PT SPY?!?

[midwaybear]

wait am i actually not supposed to read it...

[morph the cat]

Are you Lady 1 or Gentleman 6? I don't think you are.

[morph the cat]

Alisae Bell PlusJOYED

The Bulge, April Ludgate

midwaybear, zmuffin man Secret Tunnel

Something_Smart

420 Blaze It Remilia Scarlet

Yeah this feels right

You will have to go through spayhalf to elim Remilia, jsyk

[zMuffinMan]

what angles has alisae taken?

[zMuffinMan]

eh, i am not in the mood to be subtle here so the follow up question: how does that not depend on who's scum?

[zMuffinMan]

I understand wanting to wait for reactions or get some as it's something I do nearly every game to some extent, but the way they went about it and further explained in posts comes to me in a way that is more likely to come from scum than town

you literally just came out of a game where catboi (town) did the same thing

explain the difference