Silent Star 2: Menagerie

[Tayl0r Swift]

Each lover pairing has at least one unconfirmed player. So there's two executions until we lose. Tomorrow it's possible a confirmed townie has to self vote if they believe their partner is scum, today confirmed townies can put that unpleasantry off if they prefer

No, me and Ydrasse have two, which is why I think it highly unlikely she’s scum, because I don’t think she’s an idiot.

why doesnt this point to NM as much as me? like i generally buy the argument. but NM is equally implicated.

[Tayl0r Swift]

If you believe I have dyslexia than you don’t believe I slipped. This post is incredibly scummy btw.

wrong, events can and do have more than one cause.

[Isis]

loki dokie votes pookythemagicalbear in 1.6 putting to E-1; why if mafia?

I already had him as locktown but I guess there can always be more chains and padlocks

[Isis]

Ydrasse could have put an unconfirmed player with herself for wifom


this would kind of explain confirming PLUS as town instead of confirming Loki as town, maybe

[drusilla]

loki dokie votes pookythemagicalbear in 1.6 putting to E-1; why if mafia?

I already had him as locktown but I guess there can always be more chains and padlocks

at the same time pookythemagicalbear moved to loki dokie instead of the second largest wagon though. need to reread thread with the big magnifying glass tomorrow.

[Loki Dokie]

do we know if pooky was the recruited or the recruiter?
did the maf know about lovers?

I have no idea but I’m guessing he more likely be the recruited because I don’t think he’d likely pick Tayl0r. I do think it ridiculous that she echoed flipped scum on debunking my meta argument and that she accuses me of scumslipping when I said I’m dyslexic. I think town!Tayl0r wouldn’t automatically jump to that conclusion, which is why I think it makes no sense for Ydrasse to have paired herself with an unconfirmed slot. I don’t think NM has any reason whatsoever to want me be the next executed pair and I thought for a moment that I was taking crazy pills that no one was seeing how the lovers pairings most logically point to Tayl0r, so thank you for helping me to maintain my sanity.

lets do a little exercise here. as ydrasse, what pairings would you pick? as me what pairings would you pick? as NM what would you pick?

How the hell would I know that? I can tell you that I would 100% pair myself with a confirmed slot. In my case probably plus over Isis for the exact reasons I’ve already explained. I also think scum!me wouldn’t have treestumped Kanna over plus. I don’t know but I think it’s really freaking obvious that Ydrasse and me were set up to be the first execution and the fact that you’re pushing a player in an unconfirmed slot first is pretty sketchy, imo because it’s pretty obvious we were very likely intended to be the first execution, eventhough mechanically it makes absolutely no sense to anyone who hasn’t had a recent lobotomy.

[Loki Dokie]

Each lover pairing has at least one unconfirmed player. So there's two executions until we lose. Tomorrow it's possible a confirmed townie has to self vote if they believe their partner is scum, today confirmed townies can put that unpleasantry off if they prefer

No, me and Ydrasse have two, which is why I think it highly unlikely she’s scum, because I don’t think she’s an idiot.

why doesnt this point to NM as much as me? like i generally buy the argument. but NM is equally implicated.

Because I was pushing you and I am in the unconfirmed slot. Why do you think NM does this to me specifically? I was pushing you not him.

[Loki Dokie]

If you believe I have dyslexia than you don’t believe I slipped. This post is incredibly scummy btw.

wrong, events can and do have more than one cause.

No, you’re either being extremely scummy with this or you need to do some godamned reading about the topic.

[Isis]

I would love if I could figure out that Ydrasse was set up to be first execution due to Ydrasse coming to the thread and townspewing

[Loki Dokie]

loki dokie votes pookythemagicalbear in 1.6 putting to E-1; why if mafia?

I already had him as locktown but I guess there can always be more chains and padlocks

Drusilla is mistaken, that was Kanna, I put him to E - 2. I voted Pooky after Drusilla, then you. I am very obviously town and I honestly think it’s disgusting that Tayl0r is trying to claim my dyslexia is some sort of scum slip.

[Isis]

I didn't interpret it that way and I sure hope she was not

[Tayl0r Swift]

how about this. flip NM today. if green, ill put in serious legwork to figure out how Ydrasse or loki could be scum. but i have ydrasse as town and i guess consensus is that im wrong on loki.

[Loki Dokie]

loki dokie votes pookythemagicalbear in 1.6 putting to E-1; why if mafia?

I already had him as locktown but I guess there can always be more chains and padlocks

Drusilla is mistaken, that was Kanna, I put him to E - 2. I voted Pooky after Drusilla, then you. I am very obviously town and I honestly think it’s disgusting that Tayl0r is trying to claim my dyslexia is some sort of scum slip.

Oh nm, she was referring to D1.

[Isis]

What do you find scummy about NM, T?

[Tayl0r Swift]

loki dokie votes pookythemagicalbear in 1.6 putting to E-1; why if mafia?

I already had him as locktown but I guess there can always be more chains and padlocks

Drusilla is mistaken, that was Kanna, I put him to E - 2. I voted Pooky after Drusilla, then you. I am very obviously town and I honestly think it’s disgusting that Tayl0r is trying to claim my dyslexia is some sort of scum slip.

the main reason i still kinda think youre scum is that you twist everything i say and misrep me. you take the worst possible interpretation of everything i say and assume that that was my intention. you arent engaging with me in good faith, and to me thats a pretty big scumtell. but im not even pushing you. youre just deathtunneling me with this massive shitpush and i can either ignore what youre saying or respond. can i ask you to take 20 minutes away from the thread and come back and give me the benefit of the doubt that im not a shitty person?

[drusilla]

I would love if I could figure out that Ydrasse was set up to be first execution due to Ydrasse coming to the thread and townspewing

does this:

@Ydrasse

I told myself I was going to write you beautiful poems when I saw you in the list of players for this game.

Some crazy things happened that kind of derailed these plans.

You see I was turned into a Tiger, and then a Dolphin and neither are very conducive to writing poetry - our moderator has a wicked sense of humor.

By the time I could speak again, I had been condemned and had to deal with a trial of sorts and I think I'm going to die now.

It's almost surreal this feeling - how death gives you a sharp focus on what's important in life - I love you and will miss you dearly - I wish we did not have to say goodbye so here's a song for you;





Maybe next time we play together things will turn out a little bit less tragic - you have my heart always <3 - now and forever..

read more like 'hey come to the thread and vote for isis' or 'you are my mafia partner'?

[Loki Dokie]

Ydrasse, Not Mafia, and Tayl0r Swift rank below you.

Ydrasse - it's more likely to have trouble getting footing in a game as scum compared to town. It feels mean when you have to scumread someone who is struggling if they are actually town, but that's how it is.

N_M - I felt like he didn't meme in any phase of the game as much as he would if town.

Tayl0r - being irritating in condemn phase is very weakly town indicative, I'm underwhelmed now. People have pointed out some possible inconsistency in her condemn phase mind set

Good night Pooky

VOTE: ISIS

Just thought it should be pointed out this post preceded his vote on you. He never voted you on either day of the post-restrictive phase.

[Loki Dokie]

loki dokie votes pookythemagicalbear in 1.6 putting to E-1; why if mafia?

I already had him as locktown but I guess there can always be more chains and padlocks

Drusilla is mistaken, that was Kanna, I put him to E - 2. I voted Pooky after Drusilla, then you. I am very obviously town and I honestly think it’s disgusting that Tayl0r is trying to claim my dyslexia is some sort of scum slip.

the main reason i still kinda think youre scum is that you twist everything i say and misrep me. you take the worst possible interpretation of everything i say and assume that that was my intention. you arent engaging with me in good faith, and to me

thats a pretty big scumtell. but im not even pushing you

. youre just deathtunneling me with this massive shitpush and i can either ignore what youre saying or respond. can i ask you to take 20 minutes away from the thread and come back and give me the benefit of the doubt that im not a shitty person?

So tell me Tayl0r, if you’re so sure I’m scum why are you pushing NM over me? This looks like you’re setting me up to be executed after NM should he flip town. That’s certainly how this post reads to me.

[Isis]

I would love if I could figure out that Ydrasse was set up to be first execution due to Ydrasse coming to the thread and townspewing

does this:

@Ydrasse

I told myself I was going to write you beautiful poems when I saw you in the list of players for this game.

Some crazy things happened that kind of derailed these plans.

You see I was turned into a Tiger, and then a Dolphin and neither are very conducive to writing poetry - our moderator has a wicked sense of humor.

By the time I could speak again, I had been condemned and had to deal with a trial of sorts and I think I'm going to die now.

It's almost surreal this feeling - how death gives you a sharp focus on what's important in life - I love you and will miss you dearly - I wish we did not have to say goodbye so here's a song for you;





Maybe next time we play together things will turn out a little bit less tragic - you have my heart always <3 - now and forever..

read more like 'hey come to the thread and vote for isis' or 'you are my mafia partner'?

you're giving me more indirect reasons to townread her when I want to do so directly!

[Loki Dokie]

I would love if I could figure out that Ydrasse was set up to be first execution due to Ydrasse coming to the thread and townspewing

does this:

@Ydrasse

I told myself I was going to write you beautiful poems when I saw you in the list of players for this game.

Some crazy things happened that kind of derailed these plans.

You see I was turned into a Tiger, and then a Dolphin and neither are very conducive to writing poetry - our moderator has a wicked sense of humor.

By the time I could speak again, I had been condemned and had to deal with a trial of sorts and I think I'm going to die now.

It's almost surreal this feeling - how death gives you a sharp focus on what's important in life - I love you and will miss you dearly - I wish we did not have to say goodbye so here's a song for you;





Maybe next time we play together things will turn out a little bit less tragic - you have my heart always <3 - now and forever..

read more like 'hey come to the thread and vote for isis' or 'you are my mafia partner'?

Wouldn’t he write her poetry in their scum PT? I mean it’s obviously wifom but why does scum!Ydrasse align herself with an unconfirmed slot? She’s supposedly not terrible at playing scum, is she? I did a meta check on her and she’s had quite a bit of practice at it.

[Isis]

I think drusilla was trying to side with you on that thought, Loki

last time I played with scum!Ydrasse everyone but me had a very easy time catching her

[Tayl0r Swift]

loki dokie votes pookythemagicalbear in 1.6 putting to E-1; why if mafia?

I already had him as locktown but I guess there can always be more chains and padlocks

Drusilla is mistaken, that was Kanna, I put him to E - 2. I voted Pooky after Drusilla, then you. I am very obviously town and I honestly think it’s disgusting that Tayl0r is trying to claim my dyslexia is some sort of scum slip.

the main reason i still kinda think youre scum is that you twist everything i say and misrep me. you take the worst possible interpretation of everything i say and assume that that was my intention. you arent engaging with me in good faith, and to me

thats a pretty big scumtell. but im not even pushing you

. youre just deathtunneling me with this massive shitpush and i can either ignore what youre saying or respond. can i ask you to take 20 minutes away from the thread and come back and give me the benefit of the doubt that im not a shitty person?

So tell me Tayl0r, if you’re so sure I’m scum why are you pushing NM over me? This looks like you’re setting me up to be executed after NM should he flip town. That’s certainly how this post reads to me.

im not sure youre scum. at all. i think on balance youre probably town. im just telling you why i have a nagging suspicion of you despite the other evidence. and see here you go again misrepping me pretty blatanly.

me: i think NM is scum, loki is likely town
loki: if youre so sure im scum, why push NM
me: (((
loki: only scum would use that many ( in a frowny face

[drusilla]

I mean it’s obviously wifom but why does scum!Ydrasse align herself with an unconfirmed slot? She’s supposedly not terrible at playing scum, is she?

hm. why would this be terrible scumplay? you were largely townread yesterday, yes?

[Loki Dokie]

But these aren't even mafia games. These are Secret Hitler games run in real time during Marathon day. You're not really comparing apples to apples here.

her lack of commitment and detachment is very scum-indicative. Mafia usually do feel detached in these nomination scenarios when they do not have anything at stake.

she doesn't have any completed longform mafia games as far as I can tell from looking at her history.

the ones you've listed are real-time ones.

If you believe she is mafia who do you think she recruits or would recruit her?

I think I play a lot differently between real-time and slow-form - but everyone is different.

like when I'm playing real time I usually have a lot harder time following the thread.

These series of posts are strange. why is he constantly waffling on his Tayl0r read?

[Tayl0r Swift]

But these aren't even mafia games. These are Secret Hitler games run in real time during Marathon day. You're not really comparing apples to apples here.

her lack of commitment and detachment is very scum-indicative. Mafia usually do feel detached in these nomination scenarios when they do not have anything at stake.

she doesn't have any completed longform mafia games as far as I can tell from looking at her history.

the ones you've listed are real-time ones.

If you believe she is mafia who do you think she recruits or would recruit her?

I think I play a lot differently between real-time and slow-form - but everyone is different.

like when I'm playing real time I usually have a lot harder time following the thread.

These series of posts are strange. why is he constantly waffling on his Tayl0r read?

because hes scum?