Silent Star 2: Menagerie

[Kanna]

taylor also seems very townie today, or is that just me?

if i had to bet the game on a read right now, it's town!taylor. but i'll do a more in depth reading tomorrow.

[Isis]

i lean town on her today so far

[Tayl0r Swift]

this is a good bet.

[Isis]

Who do you want to eliminate taylor

[Loki Dokie]

mmmmmm but

i think it's just loki

and if not, then ydrasse

taylor is towny for the deadline hammer + pooky's early wagoning
n_m i think is more likely town than not

there's the argument that scum wouldn't want to pair with an unconfirmed, but that's wifom

You’ve actually read my entire ISO, right?

[Tayl0r Swift]

Who do you want to eliminate taylor

thats a good question. my vote is on NM, but seeing that other people are reconsidering loki has given me a bit more confidence. NM is pure null and the only way to sort the slot is to flip it IMO. NM is not likely to be scum because who would pick NM? well maybe pooky, pooky is a little cooky sometimes.

to me Loki is the scummiest and lunching that loverpair is best EV. but i dont know how im going to scumcase NM tomorrow if loki is town. theres literally 0 content.

[Isis]

Which alignment reveal surprised you the most and why?

[Tayl0r Swift]

Which alignment reveal surprised you the most and why?

pooky being scum. who saw that coming?

[Isis]

Why did you vote him instead of selfing with me then? I didn't understand your first explanation

[Loki Dokie]

mmmmmm but i think it's just loki and if not, then ydrasse

taylor is towny for the deadline hammer + pooky's early wagoning

n_m i think is more likely town than not

but if he thinks it’s me, then both of you ought to be smacked (figuratively speaking).

there's the argument that scum wouldn't want to pair with an unconfirmed, but that's wifom

It’s a pretty compelling argument. The fact that you even suspect me should prove that.

We agree on one of these things. Why is Tayl0r townie for the deadline hammer when I put Pooky at E-2 and voted Pooky at E-2. But please ignore my entire ISO, which you clearly would have to be doing. Have you reread it? Please tell me what parts scream scum to you?

[Isis]

Lol
Loki you're pretty towny but not townie enough to get sarcastic about.

Mafia is naturally subject to lots of conflicting interpretations

[Loki Dokie]

Who do you want to eliminate taylor

thats a good question. my vote is on NM, but seeing that other people are reconsidering loki has given me a bit more confidence. NM is pure null and the only way to sort the slot is to flip it IMO. NM is not likely to be scum because who would pick NM? well maybe pooky, pooky is a little cooky sometimes.

to me Loki is the scummiest and lunching that loverpair is best EV. but i dont know how im going to scumcase NM tomorrow if loki is town. theres literally 0 content.

This is why I was unconfirmed. Anyone reading my ISO and voting patterns should not even be having me on their radar, if they’re town.

[Loki Dokie]

Lol
Loki you're pretty towny but not townie enough to get sarcastic about.

Mafia is naturally subject to lots of conflicting interpretations

I disagree. I think it’s beyond obvious I’m town here and if you guys vote me, you had better be confident Ydrasse is scum.

I think we vote Tayl0r today and Ydrasse tomorrow, because I don’t think it’s NM.

[Loki Dokie]

mmmmmm but i think it's just loki and if not, then ydrasse

taylor is towny for the deadline hammer + pooky's early wagoning

n_m i think is more likely town than not

but if he thinks it’s me, then both of you ought to be smacked (figuratively speaking).

there's the argument that scum wouldn't want to pair with an unconfirmed, but that's wifom

It’s a pretty compelling argument. The fact that you even suspect me should prove that.

We agree on one of these things. Why is Tayl0r townie for the deadline hammer when I put Pooky at E-1 on D1 and voted Pooky at E-2 yesterday. But please ignore my entire ISO, which you clearly would have to be doing. Have you reread it? Please tell me what parts scream scum to you?

[Tayl0r Swift]

Why did you vote him instead of selfing with me then? I didn't understand your first explanation

insufficient engagement to feel confident in my own judgement, plus knowing that my theory was tinfoil-hatty

[Loki Dokie]

1279. I think I’ve made an extremely strong case why it’s likely Tayl0r. Pooky first tries to discredit my case due to them being marathon games and not in “real time” and then suddenly switches to oh she’s so disconnected because he knows arguing my case further would probably raise my suspicions of him and guarantee his death. He had absolutely no reaction to you pushing Ydrasse. He did mention NM but unlike Tayl0r, what he said about NM actually made sense.

I have every freaking right to be sarcastic Isis and it pisses me off that Kanna is completely ignoring this.

[Isis]

Mafia is a lot more fun to play if you expect to be scumread and just get pleasantly surprised when you're townread

[Isis]

1489 seems like a townpost to me and Ydrasse seems pretty scummy so far

[Tayl0r Swift]

i think if NM is mafia hed vote me today. so i think the scum is in loki or ydrasse.

does that make sense?

[drusilla]

who saw that coming?

what about my case as to why pookythemagicalbear was mafia seemed completely dismissable to you?

[Loki Dokie]

Mafia is a lot more fun to play if you expect to be scumread and just get pleasantly surprised when you're townread

It’s not pleasant when people are clearly ignoring my entire ISO and voting patterns. So no it’s fucking ridiculous that anyone seriously thinks it could be me. I’m still trying to decide on Tayl0r vs. Ydrasse. But yeah, that’s beyond seriously dumb.

[drusilla]

But yeah, that’s beyond seriously dumb.

do you think this is... helpful?

[Isis]

i think if NM is mafia hed vote me today. so i think the scum is in loki or ydrasse.

does that make sense?

No, I very rarely and cautiously try to predict the way miltank plays

[Isis]

Like I don't understand his play usually so I'm cautious to guess at it. Anyway can you explain why you think he'd vote you?

[Loki Dokie]

i think if NM is mafia hed vote me today. so i think the scum is in loki or ydrasse.

does that make sense?

I don’t think it’s him because of voting patterns and nothing is connecting him to Pooky. It’s never me. It’s either you or Ydrasse.