Silent Star 2: Menagerie

[Tayl0r Swift]

Like I don't understand his play usually so I'm cautious to guess at it. Anyway can you explain why you think he'd vote you?

im clearly the lunchbait today. going for me today and then for the +ev townplay of two unconfirmeds tomorrow is a solid way to get an easy win.

[Loki Dokie]

But yeah, that’s beyond seriously dumb.

do you think this is... helpful?

No but I’m annoyed that Kanna thinks it could be me, because she is literally ignoring my entire voting patterns and ISO.

[Loki Dokie]

But yeah, that’s beyond seriously dumb.

do you think this is... helpful?

No but I’m annoyed that Kanna thinks it could be me, because she is literally ignoring my entire voting patterns and ISO.

Not to mention what looks remotely partnery between me and Pooky? So, yeah I do think it’s bad she thinks it could be me but Drusilla is right, those comments aren’t helping but I’m just not particularly good at keeping my mouth shut when people post silly things but I’ll try harder.

[Loki Dokie]

But yeah, that’s beyond seriously dumb.

do you think this is... helpful?

No but I’m annoyed that Kanna thinks it could be me, because she is literally ignoring my entire voting patterns and ISO.

Not to mention what looks remotely partnery between me and Pooky? So, yeah I do think it’s bad she thinks it could be me but Drusilla is right, those comments aren’t helping but I’m just not particularly good at keeping my mouth shut when people post silly things but I’ll try harder.

Sorry @Kanna, I don’t mean to be rude but you’re dead wrong and I don’t know how anyone can criticality read my ISO, voting patterns and interactions with Pooky and come up with me as his most likely partner, so I think my irritation with you is beyond justified even if the particular way I chosed to convey was clearly not. Just open your eyes and don’t ignore my case on Tayl0r in case Ydrasse is town. Thanks.

[PlusJOYED]

Loki I promise not to blame you if we lose this game you had above average play through the game imo

sometimes I just don't always agree with someone and that's part of mafia

Let’s say we vote NM and game doesn’t end and Ydrasse is town, then we freaking lose.

If you convince PlusJOYED to vote Taylor and Ydrasse agrees, then you win the final day

well im voting who isis tells me to

[Isis]

Yay!

[Isis]

Like I don't understand his play usually so I'm cautious to guess at it. Anyway can you explain why you think he'd vote you?

im clearly the lunchbait today. going for me today and then for the +ev townplay of two unconfirmeds tomorrow is a solid way to get an easy win.

Is there a reason you don't see Ydrasse going for the same play?

[Loki Dokie]

Anyway, I think the game is won, so long as we don’t vote off NM. So I guess it really doesn’t matter whether we vote Tayl0r or Ydrasee first but I still think it’s Tayl0r > Ydrasee but I’m less confident on it.

I think if Ydrasee flips town and you vote off NM, we’re probably going to lose. And for all of the shit I’m getting for the unconfirmed thing, no one has really explained why it makes sense for scum!Ydrasee to do that, especially with me.

I guess we just have to wait on Ydrasee and see if she towns it up or not and if she actually does do that and you guys vote us, you should feel really bad but if she doesn’t, I might be persuaded to vote her in that case despite her aligning with an unconfirmed slot seems really suboptimal, it’s still a better vote than NM.

I think we will lose if we execute him.

[PlusJOYED]

i agree with loki but i'd prefer voting ydrasse today

[Isis]

I really want to get as much as we can out of this phase

[Loki Dokie]

i agree with loki but i'd prefer voting ydrasse today

I’m not convinced my case on Tayl0r is wrong yet + Pooky’s weird hedging on her but her recent posting is making me a lot less confident. I would like to hear from Ydrasse first.

I think that if we all agree that NM should not be voted, we’re probably going to win.

So either way, we don’t lose.

I think if it really does turn out to be Ydrasse then I’m going to be really pissed at her for putting me in this position. If it is her than she clearly over estimated Kanna’s ability to correctly read me. I still don’t see why she wouldn’t confirm me but eh.

[Isis]

VOTE: Isis

[PlusJOYED]

VOTE: Isis

VOTE: isis

[Isis]

Good man

[Tayl0r Swift]

Like I don't understand his play usually so I'm cautious to guess at it. Anyway can you explain why you think he'd vote you?

im clearly the lunchbait today. going for me today and then for the +ev townplay of two unconfirmeds tomorrow is a solid way to get an easy win.

Is there a reason you don't see Ydrasse going for the same play?

mainly that i dont see ydrasse doing anything. ydrasse is pure coasting. ydrasse cant go for the same play of lunch me and then lunch the two unconfirmeds, because that means scum!ydrasse loses. ydrasse has to lunch me and then lunch NM

[Kanna]

But please ignore my entire ISO, which you clearly would have to be doing. Have you reread it? Please tell me what parts scream scum to you?

lol, those were my gut-takes coming into the day. no, i haven't done an in-depth reading yet and no, i don't think you're scummy - quite the opposite actually.

it's like you're so townie, i'm confused why you aren't confirmed, and in the case you are town and scum didn't confirm you to make us suspicious of your pair, i feel like they'd choose me for the job instead. after all, isis/drusilla, the two people who know me best among this list, were both paranoia-scumreading me and i was pushing them both for whatever reason. if i was scum, i would also confirm you every time. this situation is a strange curveball

[Kanna]

i want to wait for ydrasse to say things

[Isis]

It was implicit in the last readslit I gave Pooky that I had flipped on you Kanna. So the scum knew.

In hindsight Pooky fished beneficial information about the gamestate with his last breaths

[Isis]

While I was away, I wondered, what if Swift didn't confirm Loki so that we wouldn't listen to him when he tunneled Swift.

Then I wondered, did Swift really didn't know whether scum is post restricted in the scum PT.

You saw the announcement that they are post restricted in the PT, right Ydrasse?

[Tayl0r Swift]

i shoudnt be given towncred for dumbtelling lol

[Kanna]

+ev townplay of two unconfirmeds

this is true, right? so i wonder if scum are framing the pair to get lunched or going the wifom route and actually don't want us to lunch them

first impression is they don't want us to lunch them, seeing as loki/ydrasse were both townleaning yesterday. which means we should lunch them :s

but i've always been a sucker for wifom, i don't know how much i should trust myself

[Kanna]

It was implicit in the last readslit I gave Pooky that I had flipped on you Kanna. So the scum knew.

In hindsight Pooky fished beneficial information about the gamestate with his last breaths

in hindsight, pooky was also quite survivalistic in his last moments. i am very glad you did not self vote <3

[Isis]

I'm glad I didn't self vote but I feel like I am going to miss this 67% shot 90% of the time

[Isis]

I feel worried Pooky cares about winning an argument more than being town in the argument if that makes sense, its somewhat mafia indicative

This is kind of strange. Why would it make sense for a Pooky!scum to want to win an argument? It doesn't help my position in any way - arguing is usually counterproductive to survival especially in a setting like this where it's 1 or the other.

oh yeah, i remember seeing this earlier and having what is probably a dumb thought at it but isn't the simplest answer to wanting to win an argument that... whoever you "beat" might reconsider you/etc? like, i don't get how arguing is counterproductive in the sense that it's how you like... make people reconsider you, or is at least one way and one of the most straightforward.

i don't understand how it going one way or another makes a difference?

This post should solve Ydrasse for me if I was good at mafia

[Isis]

solving Ydrasse wins the game.
solving Tayl0r wins the game.
solving N_M wins the game.

I don't feel confident doing any of these things but maybe Kanna or shiki will